It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Pastamancer
reply to post by Jubes
I'd.. suggest to take your daughter to another psychiatrist for a second opinion.
Some advice.. be cautious about the medications the doctor prescribes for her, especially if he just happens to have an armload of samples he comes out with. It's the nature of the beast for Psychiatrists to get cozy with Drug Reps. The Psychiatrist isn't per se evil or corrupted for doing this. He gets obscene amounts of samples to help patients who can't always afford medication, he stays on the good side of the pharmaceutical company, gets supplementary income for his practice and access to literature on cutting edge medicine.
There's a whole new wave of anti-depressants and mood stabilizers out there right now. It sounds like your daughter may require an anti-psychotic through her teenage years but I advise not to do it unless she becomes a danger to herself. They're very dangerous drugs and can wreak havoc on a growing nervous system. Only use them if you think she may do more harm to herself without them than the drugs would do to her in the long term.
Last bit of advice.. you're the consumer. She's the patient. Make darn well sure you get your money's worth. She's your little girl and you'll never get another one just like her. Don't let the doctor tell you what needs to be done. Ask him what needs to be done. You make the final call. It's her life in the balance, her happiness. Not his. Not his child's. There's.. a lot of truly mentally damaged people that get into the line of work a doctor does. Control freaks, superiority complexes.. it's pretty nasty. Especially when they feel they don't need help because they're a doctor. They're still people. Still flawed, still vulnerable. Take advice with a wary eye, always, ALWAYS read the full little pamphlet that comes with her medications from A-Z and be on the lookout for side effects, especially the listed dangerous ones.
Originally posted by topherman420
Originally posted by Pastamancer
reply to post by Jubes
I'd.. suggest to take your daughter to another psychiatrist for a second opinion.
Some advice.. be cautious about the medications the doctor prescribes for her, especially if he just happens to have an armload of samples he comes out with. It's the nature of the beast for Psychiatrists to get cozy with Drug Reps. The Psychiatrist isn't per se evil or corrupted for doing this. He gets obscene amounts of samples to help patients who can't always afford medication, he stays on the good side of the pharmaceutical company, gets supplementary income for his practice and access to literature on cutting edge medicine.
There's a whole new wave of anti-depressants and mood stabilizers out there right now. It sounds like your daughter may require an anti-psychotic through her teenage years but I advise not to do it unless she becomes a danger to herself. They're very dangerous drugs and can wreak havoc on a growing nervous system. Only use them if you think she may do more harm to herself without them than the drugs would do to her in the long term.
Last bit of advice.. you're the consumer. She's the patient. Make darn well sure you get your money's worth. She's your little girl and you'll never get another one just like her. Don't let the doctor tell you what needs to be done. Ask him what needs to be done. You make the final call. It's her life in the balance, her happiness. Not his. Not his child's. There's.. a lot of truly mentally damaged people that get into the line of work a doctor does. Control freaks, superiority complexes.. it's pretty nasty. Especially when they feel they don't need help because they're a doctor. They're still people. Still flawed, still vulnerable. Take advice with a wary eye, always, ALWAYS read the full little pamphlet that comes with her medications from A-Z and be on the lookout for side effects, especially the listed dangerous ones.
I chopped up the post a bit to appease the mods on quoting blocks of text lol
What you said there is so true based on the experiences ive had. I live in Canada where free health care is a wonderful application, but it has its problems. Just because its free doesnt mean im going to just sit here and accept the first diagnosis, out of the first mouth. Or sit by if i dont agree with the treatment cause "hey at least its free". Now if you pay for insurances for medical treatment, then you have even more right to dictate your medical treatment. Second opinions should always be found, no matter how many diplomas hang on that wall. Corruption exists everywhere theres money involved (hippocratic oaths or not), as in the above example of drug companies making doctors who promote them happy. But its not every doctors whim to just make money and harm their patients. Their are doctors out their who actually treat their PhD as their life's continuing work, not just a salary. If medicine is pushed as an easy solution for an unknown problem, its of course lazy and un ethical of the doctors. But in the cases of any brain disorders, they are complicated to diagnose properly, as well as difficult to treat. Some are just ones made by the person themselves because of traumas and such in their lives, others are because of just a simple imbalance of chemicals that we naturally produce in our brains. Therapists find and treat the traumatic memories, but medicine wont do it. On the other hand a therapist cant physically rewire or fix a problem with the brain, therefore medicines are made to help treat the symptoms and live with the problem more effectively. They arent designed to CURE and alot of people misconstrue cure for treat.
Im surprised the thread is still going honestly. lol
Originally posted by Pastamancer
reply to post by Jubes
I feel obliged to take another crack at this, due to the importance of it and that I have a soft spot for kids.
Diagnostic criteria are vital to determining a mental disorder. It's not good enough to leave off at "Well she has BiPolar and that explains most of it.. she hears voices but we're just going to chalk that one up to crazy." Auditory Hallucinations are nowhere near the diagnostic criteria for BiPolar disorder. The Manic episodes sound like they're reaching their typical hormone fuelled wildfire point and the halodol is sometimes a regretfully necessary course of action.
The psychosis that sometimes is a sequellae of BiPolar often has more to do with the mind unable to cope with loss of control and the turbulent and unyeilding pressures within and without and it's.. really similar to Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Violent outbursts, anxiety, fits of paranoia.. but I should really, REALLY point out here that the auditory hallucinations.. hearing and talking to things that aren't there.. that has nothing to do with BiPolar and really merits a serious look as to an accompanying condition.
I don't know enough to make even a hypothesis because there's more than one thing that can cause it and none of them are pleasant. If it's dug out soon and treatment is started she'll be much better off than letting this lay dormant and playing the thorozine shuffle with her until they find the right medications to treat the bipolar that also just happen to make the auditory hallucinations go away.
My first instincts.. I'm going to name off a couple medications and if she hasn't tried them ask your doctor about them. They have fairly innocuous side effects and they belong to the newer wave of treatments. She may be hesitant at first, but have her look up the literature on them.
The first is Geodon. The main side effects are sensitivity to heat and light, nausea and fatigue. These lessen over time. At first the symptoms can be pretty substantial. She'll need a dark, cool place to sleep and may need some pills for nausea at first. Alltogether said it's one of the few medications I've seen that doesn't have a really nasty toll on the body over a long period of time.
The second is Celexa.. it has a generic form.. I can't remember the name of it off the top of my head but its side effects are pretty much in the vein of nausea and slight aggitation and I believe weight loss, which is a far cry better than some of the weight gain from monsterous drugs like Lithium, Zoloft or Depakote. If she's on any of those three, cease that medication right away. You have no idea how much long term damage those will do to her. I don't care how comfy the doctor is with prescribing them and how well the treatment works. You'll regret it if she continues on them.. and she'll bear the worst of it.
Other medications I'd warn you off of are Risperadol (Though sometimes the lesser of two evils.. this is the nuclear weapon of antipsychotics, Do not allow her to take this lightly.) and .. hm.. Cymbalta. I believe that's how it's spelled. There's survivor groups for that drug. It's horribly addictive and has all kind of nasty side effects. It's an experimental tricyclic antidepressant and I realy think there should have been more testing on it until they put it in the wild.
en.wikipedia.org...
Read that and get down to the part about differential diagnosis. These things like to hide in the noise. I can't emphasize enough that you need to make an issue of the auditory hallucinations and insist it be examined as a possible accompanying disorder.
Originally posted by Cannon
any medicine, unless crucial, is just masking the symptoms.... it's like buying bigger and stronger locks for your skeletons in your closet, they are still there and when that lock can't hold them anymore, they will have gained momentum combined with a larger then life LUST for revenge/!!!.. jc
Originally posted by Pastamancer
Child's safety is the topic of the thread and this is what you choose to post in it. Those who live in glass houses shouldn't fire bazookas.
Originally posted by Pastamancer
reply to post by inven104u2
To you.. and the previous poster.. no offense intended, I have respect for the devout and those wholly dedicated to their art whether they be a master sculpter or a man of the cloth. ..................................................
.................
What I am saying is.. please.. for the sake of the child, don't assume this is simply a matter that can be resolved by faith. Countless scores of sick and even spiritually tortured children and even grown adults have died in the dedication to faith healing. If it does turn out to be a demon.. which honestly I'm not sure of, there needs to be more information.. then yes. Faith. Hope.. Love. The greatest of these is Love. But please don't assume that's what it is. He could simply be sick. This isn't an issue that will be resolved with one piece of advice or one moment of insight.
Paranormal Studies: This forum is for the general discussion of a wide range of paranormal phenomena that includes remote viewing, ESP, OBE, telepathy, ghosts, spirits, etc. Participants should be aware that this is a highly speculative forum where topics and responses will tend to lean in favor of the existence of these phenomena. Those who would wish to refute these subjects should be aware of AboveTopSecret.com's tradition of supporting the free examination of "alternative topics" which includes the paranormal.