It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.

Please white-list or disable in your ad-blocking tool.

Thank you.


Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.


Three Words That Could Overthrow Physics: “What Is Magnetism?”

page: 3
<< 1  2   >>

log in


posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 06:29 PM

Originally posted by mc_squaredBut nobody out there is acting like they have all the answers

Then why these quotes?

‘A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it..’— Max Planck

‘First a new theory is attacked as absurd; then it is admitted to be true, but obvious and insignificant; finally it is seen to be so important that its adversaries claim they themselves discovered it.’— William James

‘New ideas pass through three periods:
• It can’t be done.
• It probably can be done, but it’s not worth doing.
• I knew it was a good idea all along.’ — Arthur C. Clarke

Mainstream science is infamous for this, pretending that they do know everything, throughout history. This magnet thing is only one example of thousands of subjects in which scientists try to maintain an appearance of omniscience, which can be detected primarily when new ideas arise, their response. Most often I've seen these ideas attacked and dismissed out of hand without ever being considered. This is exactly why we don't understand things, because science has been politicized.

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 06:31 PM

Originally posted by boncho
reply to post by grizzle2
You want me to address the "facts" you posted:

Make me look foolish by explaining how magnets act on ferrous objects at a distance. Please.

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 06:35 PM
This thread was so interesting until boncho came in.

Can we please start a fresh with a thread that simply asks "how does magnetism work?"

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 06:40 PM
Just wait until the OP leans about something called "Ferrofluid".

Liquid magnets HOW DO THEY WORK?!?!

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 06:49 PM
Heres another topic in science without a clear answer. There are some good explanations but no answers.

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 07:09 PM

Originally posted by boncho
reply to post by grizzle2

I've already destroyed your argument's credibility by showing that you referenced a satire article written by someone who has no background in science.

English Lit., does not = physics.

Comedy, does not = reality.

The article could have been a damn cooking recipe for all I care , the important part are the facts that it tries to convey to the reader , which is that mainstream science has a huge problem in explaining a basic thing like how a magnet works.. Which part of this article/satire/cooking recipe did you not understand ? I could care less about who wrote this article or in which column of the recent science journal, fishing guide, cooking recipe book or batman comic book it was presented . Stick to the god damn point of the article instead of jumping around it trying to pick a fight over who the author is and who he is not . The fact is , whoever he is, he is stating a fact about magnetism.

Edit : The standards at this forum have lately started to piss me off , with all those new would be experts and critics that run around every thread trying to pick a fight with posters for the heck of picking a fight , without even starting a constructive debate on the actual topic that is being presented . I so miss the old time skeptics, debunkers (gosh I never thought I will say that) and tactful "experts" that even thou they usually destroyed most of the "fringe" threads they did it with painfully logical debate over the points of the threads and ideas that have been presented and not by attacking the authors of the ideas. Ehh where is Phage when You need one...
edit on 20/4/11 by Thill because: (no reason given)

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 07:59 PM
reply to post by idonotcollectstamps

I've MADE ferrofluid before, thanks.

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 08:05 PM

Originally posted by Thillthe important part are the facts that it tries to convey to the reader , which is that mainstream science has a huge problem in explaining a basic thing like how a magnet works.. Which part of this article/satire/cooking recipe did you not understand ?

Thanks. Yes that is the point, that they promote an image of themselves as only having a few unimportant things left to work out and then they will know all. As if nobody but them can understand anything.
And the consequence that the other things they have built on false premises could be giving us a severely wrong picture of reality. Meanwhile they're preventing new theories from being discussed in academia and elsewhere by virtue of ham-handed use of political clout (politics meaning "the allocation of power").

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 08:11 PM
reply to post by Thill

Here's an example of a simple permanent magnet motor. I would like someone to tell me where the energy is coming from to perform this work, since the scientist's definition of energy is the capacity to perform work:

Youtube video (short)

Virtual photons?

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 09:04 PM
reply to post by grizzle2

What is magnetism? Well what is anything? No one knows.
Summed up:The principle of reality is sacrifice or Divine Ignorance, not pseudo-knowledge.

Adi Da the Fourth Great Incarnation of the Divine:

Consider this ashtray. This very ashtray itself is the object that I have used for some time now to demonstrate and consider this necessary philosophy, or "love of wisdom," relative to Divine Ignorance. This is the object I have used. And I have said to you on occasion, and it remains true even to this day, that, from a practical point of view, from a chemical point of view, from an aesthetic point of view, from the point of view of any kind of ordinary discipline of knowing, you may know all kinds of things about this ashtray and its origin and its content. But no matter what you may know about it, before and after and while you know anything about it, you do not know what it is. I mean what it is . . . is . . . you have not the slightest knowledge of what it is. And none of your experience increases your awareness of what it is. This same logic pertains to everything. No matter what you may come to realize by experience about anything, you still do not know what it is. All of you belong to this realm of ambiguity. None of us knows what any other human being is. We just simply do not know it. In our practical involvement with one another, we know about one another—but we do not know what we are. Knowledge, in other words, does not penetrate to this degree. It never has. This failure is not just a reflection of the silliness or stupidity of ancient beings. It is also fundamentally a reflection upon our own existence, and also, therefore, upon the existence of all other beings who have ever lived. The atoms that are in this ashtray have existed for perhaps twenty billions of years—far beyond the mere five billion of the earth. They come out of the manifest cosmos, from the center of the explosion that manifested everything. We know very little about anything, ultimately. And we do not know what it is in fact. Thus, our mind itself, our own existence, is totally, unqualifiedly, inevitably, irrevocably, and irreducibly Ignorant. No one, regardless of his or her sophistication or experience, no one, not even myself, knows what a single thing is. Not what anything is, you see. This presumption could have been made at any time in the past, and it can be made at any time in the future. No matter how much experience intervenes, no matter how sophisticated men and women become, no matter how much we may know about anything through experience, we still do not and will not know what it is. What it is. What is a shape, what is a place, where is it? We do not know that. That is not what we know. We presume something about that ultimate affair that is like knowledge, but in fact, we do not know. All that may be said about our consideration, our understanding, our belief, our experience is this: Not only now, but not at any time in the past, in any civilization, even the most magnificent beyond belief, nor in the future on this earth in any great moment, nor in any other occasion, any planet, any place, in all of the manifestation of existence, does any individual know what anything is. Ignorance is the Principle of existence. This is absolutely true. We do not know what anything is. We are totally mindless, and totally beyond consolation or fulfillment, because there is no way to know what anything is. The only thing you can know about anything is still about it. But you do not know what it is . . . is . . . is ... or why it happens to be. You have not the slightest knowledge of what it is. And no one has ever had it. Not anyone. Not Jesus, not Moses, not Mohammed, not Gautama Buddha, not Krishna, not Tukaram, not Bubba Free John, no one has ever known what a single thing is. Not the most minute, ridiculous particle of anything. No one has ever known it, and no one ever will know it, because we are not knowing. We do not know what anything is. The summarization of our existence is Mystery, absolute, unqualified confrontation with what we cannot know. And no matter how sophisticated we become by experience, this will always be true of us. This Teaching, then, will never be transcended. Upon this absolute Truth we must build our lives, and I must build my Church. This Truth is summary, unqualified, irredeemable, irreducible, and absolute. It can never be changed. No matter what sophisticated time may appear, no matter when, in the paradox of all of the slices and planes of time, any moment may appear in which beings sit together as we do, oblivious to Infinity, no matter what time may appear in which men and women consider the moment, no one will ever know what anything is. That is the Truth. Becoming submitted to that Truth is spiritual life. It leads you to the transformation of all other occasions. All the possibilities of your experience are transformed by this disposition. Obviously, then, it is very important to realize this Ignorance, because it is the only digit at Infinity that can transform your existence. Everything else only modifies your existence and amounts to a contraction in your consciousness, a summation upon a point. We exist in the moment of Infinity. Look—everyone who ever looked like us has died. Every one of us will die. In the meantime, we are capable, in the form of our structure, to experience all kinds of things, to be associated with all kinds of influences. But if we abandon this Truth, this Understanding, this Intuition of the nature of our experience, all experience will accumulate upon us. We will, therefore, adapt to experience in itself, and we will become the reflections of it. We are awakened at Infinity only if we can realize that the fundamental point of our existence is not knowledge at all. There are no answers. This is the whole point. We do not know at all. We do not know where we are, we do not know who we are, we do not know what we are. We do not know what the future is, we do not know what the past is. We are trying to look good—but we do not know. We are trying through the force of experience to achieve a summation that glamorizes us, but we do not know what anything is. That is the point. This Realization does not move us to go within at all. It moves us, shattered, into the present pattern of relations at Infinity. No matter what arises in the configuration of our experience, we still do not know what anything is. All the accumulations of our experience move us into moods, attitudes, presumptions, but we still do not know at all. Where is this place? Where is it? Where is it? Where is it, exactly? I mean, really? We haven't the slightest idea. Nobody has any idea. No matter who may claim your worship, nobody knows. Some people may look better than others, but still, nobody knows. DEVOTEE: Bubba, this description of our existence implies extreme vulnerability. BUBBA: On the basis of this logic, in which we do not know what anything is, in which we are not in control, it is clear that we are not even created by anything Objective and Absolute. We are in a Condition of absolute, unqualified Mystery. That Condition is what obliges us in our attention and our feeling. That is what it is to be a man or a woman: to be rested upon Infinity without any consolations whatsoever. There is no Truth within. There is no Truth in the past, and there is no Truth in the future. Having no consolations, we exist in this moment, floating in space, wherever that is, totally sublimed, beyond consolation or belief, without the slightest fraction of abstract verbal consideration to console us, without the slightest fleshy prominence standing out against Infinity to make us happy. That is our Condition, you see. That is the Truth of it. That is it. That is all there is to it. And it is not an answer. There are no answers in it. All your struggling for information, for answers, is just more of the same old foolishness. It is open- ended. You go to your death without knowledge. Thus, you also go to your life without knowing. Nevertheless, there is an obvious Law: Everything does change. Everything prominent passes. Everything that appears is temporary. And, therefore, the Law of the universe is change itself, the sacrifice of everything present. Having realized that there is no knowledge, having seen that everything changes, how shall we live? Even though nothing comes from it, the ultimate pleasure to which we may sacrifice ourselves is at best someone else's pleasure. What if you were to sit down to dinner and eat a lobster? You might enjoy yourself, but it would be dead. And if it had been able during its lifetime to conceive of this meal as the ultimate moment toward which it was progressing through sacrifice, even so, the moment of being eaten is totally unavailable to its consciousness. Thus, there is no moment toward which you move by sacrifice. Sacrifice is simply the Law, the disposition of love. Sacrifice is inherently happy, inherently free. It has no answers. That is all I can tell you. It is not that I can tell you concretely that something will happen. Yes, things will happen, but they will also pass. Yes, you will survive your death, I can guarantee you that. But you will survive it in another form that also dies. Everything will change. Thus, it is not in time that we have the Eternal Vision. It is in the moment, in our disposition, in our love, in our sacrifice, by throwing everything away and being totally willing to be dead. You are not only free in this moment, you are also profoundly happy, and ridiculous. No one is here to give you any answers. There is no Creator Deity in charge of you, like a parent. There is no such Person, no God, like that, nor any Spiritual Master like that. I am here to instigate this love, or sacrifice, in you, and there is no answer, no result. The act itself is the happiness. If you can begin to become fully sympathetic to this argument that I bring to you, then you will simply be happy and completely bereft of answers. If you can sacrifice to me, then there is something else to be Realized—but I do not want to tell you about it. I have died in my own lifetime. It has been so many years ago, it is like my familiarity with some of you, almost half of my life. But there was a time—actually I do not know whether you can understand this or not, because it occurred before I was born, in the process through which I became born—in which there was Realization beyond time and space. I have animated that Realization throughout the stupid adventure of my life. To you my life may be inspiring, but to me it is stupid. To me, to be submitted to this kind of argument, this working out of living forms, is a torment, and completely terrifying. I do not think you are so sensitive to it, because you still like to indulge yourselves. To me it is all terrifying, every single moment of it, unless there is the Intuition of God and of Eternal Life, the motive of sacrifice and of present happiness, not the tendency toward future happiness. The moment of sacrifice is itself happiness. It is simply free. There is neither knowledge nor content in that moment. That is it. That is the absolute summation of God-knowledge. No one, including me, will ever tell you anything better. That is it. Now, work it out, and die. Having said that, I know damned well that billions of years from now I will be sitting here explaining this to you. I will. I am not coming back, because I will never leave. I cannot. I would wish it, I would want it, I would love it if there were some "Independent, Absolute, Alternative Reality" that would absorb me and that I could go to at the point of death. But you see, I cannot leave. I am submitted to the mechanics of things just like you, except that I am the body altogether, whereas all of you are ambiguous, inward, and reluctant. So will be sitting here in some form or other, in some place or other, with even you individuals, for billions upon billions of years, just as I have sat with you already, for billions of years, the very same people, and others as well. We have argued this matter for countless years, beyond earth, before the great explosion that produced the material universe and into the total future of it. DEVOTEE: Bubba, you are communicating a consideration here to people who have not totally assumed it. But in the future we will be able to assume it. BUBBA: It would seem that way, wouldn't it? But since I can never leave, it stands to reason that you can never change. Certainly you will all become better, but that betterness will be the ordinariness of that new time. DEVOTEE: But in the practical sense of our ordinary life. . . . BUBBA: In your ordinary life it is simply a matter. of whether you are happy or not. Are you happy? Will you give it up? Will you be mad? Will you be without information, without answers? Will you be faced on Infinity? Just as you are right now? It is completely mad, you see. DEVOTEE: But there is a sense. . . . BUBBA: The sense that you are happy is your own self-possession. There is not even that. There is simply this mysterious affair that is always happy, without cause. That is it, not all your presumptions that you are happy, that you are giving it up, that you are in love. It is all the same old absolute Magnificence. It is not the same as a moment of deja vu, as if it had already happened. It has never happened, and it always has happened, this moment. Select any moment, and I am still telling you this. What a ridiculous matter! What a plan!

edit on 20-4-2011 by RRokkyy because: (no reason given)

posted on Apr, 20 2011 @ 10:10 PM
reply to post by Thill

The article could have been a damn cooking recipe for all I care , the important part are the facts that it tries to convey to the reader , which is that mainstream science has a huge problem in explaining a basic thing like how a magnet works..

The article was misrepresented in the OP. The OP eluded to many things in the first few posts that were far more outrageous than his following posts. This being the Deconstructing DIsInfo forum, I pointed out faults of the OP.

I am sorry if people feel I am trying to kill this thread. I felt the way that it was represented did not fit with the forum. I've made my peace.

Continue discussion of magnets.

posted on Apr, 21 2011 @ 02:29 PM
Stanford's Dr. Bill Tiller has done some amazing theoretical work with identifying the source of magnetism.

We already know as a force it's coupled with electricity, but seems to have no particle equivalent to the electron. Dr. Tiller is proposing that a particle he calls the "magnon" exists on the other side of the speed of light barrier, which he figures as representing a time-space domain, the inverse of Einstein's familiar space-time from our 3D perspectives. It's extremely fascinating work and is actually geared towards eventually explaining consciousness itself as a highly-dimensional interaction between virtually everything else.

posted on Apr, 21 2011 @ 02:53 PM

Well, it's obviously some kind of physical link certain atomic structures have with a 5th dimension beyond out immediate ability to make sense of. It's mass "falling" toward a little cone in the fabric of spacetime, except that this kind of cone is like an ice cream cone with a rounded "scoop" surface on one end and a point on the other. Points can go into scoops. But scoops can't go into scoops (they roll off each other) and points can't go into points (the points act as scoops to each other).

North is this way, and South is the opposite. The "bigger" the cone, the stronger it is.

It's no different than falling toward anything in our three dimensions because of a warp in spacetime -- check your Einstein -- except it's in a fifth. And the mass never really gets to where it's falling, because the pulling point (phantom mass) is in another dimension it can't reach. So it doesn't look like it's falling, but it definitely wants to. So it just reacts to other "fields" (dimensional votex configurations) nearby by either nesting into the force cones, or rolling off them, point or scoop. Not tremendously complex, but difficult to imagine because IT'S ANOTHER DIMENSION!

I'll see if I can come up with a diagram for you. If I'm not too lazy. Remember. Intersecting/interacting trans-dimensional ice cream cones.

edit on 21-4-2011 by Blue Shift because: (no reason given)

posted on Apr, 22 2011 @ 06:27 AM
reply to post by grizzle2

Started new thread because I figured out how to save the world, apologies.
edit on 22-4-2011 by kennyb72 because: second thoughts

top topics

<< 1  2   >>

log in