Be gay all you want, just hush up about it!, page 2


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 112 times


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:30 AM by NoRegretsEver
reply to post by Helious



I wanted to present this in another way as I think I may see what is bothering you.

If I say cupcakes. Do you see cake and frosting? While others see cake, frosting, cooking temps, butter, and calories? What is bothering you is that you are conditioned to see the personal facts, and those that are flamboyant and not. You cannot choose to be comfortable with a non-flamboyant gay person, as they are in fact more comfortable with you.

When some talks about going to bed, do you think of a shower? A bed? Pajamas? This is a personal issue and nothing else.

Peace, NRE.


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:31 AM by Drezden
Originally posted by Jean Paul Zodeaux


There is no such thing as an "inequality of rights". All people have the same rights. If it is a right, it is universally so, and is inherently so, not some legal fabrication, but a natural phenomenon.

This is part of the problem with the whole "gay" issue. "Gay rights", much like "minority rights" is about civil rights, not natural unalienable rights, and more and more people are waking up to the difference and are getting a little tired of having civil rights shoved down their throats as if it some sacred cow. Beyond the inappropriate locker room talk that tends to come with "gay pride" - which seems to be the point the O.P. is making, there is the nonsense of "inequality of rights", but more to the point, you in your assertions pretty much lay out the contradiction of the whole gay marriage issue, and how that only serves to distract from the real question.

The real question is not why can't gays get married - they can and just simply have to hold their own sacred ceremony to do so and need no permission from the state to do so - the real question is why does any person, gay or straight need a license to get married? The legal definition of license is the grant of permission to do something that would otherwise be illegal to do. Is getting married illegal, and is this why people are expected to obtain a license in order to do so?

The gay marriage issue is not about gays getting married, it is about filing on tax returns, and "benefits", nothing more. To equate filing on tax returns with equal rights is so odious it stinks to high heaven, and every person has the right to contract. Every person should exert their unalienable right to contract to secure the best possible deal they can get, and none of this has anything to do with sexual proclivities. It has everything to do with victimology.



If you think the only benefit of a government recognized marriage that gay people want is filing their taxes then I understand a little better why you're confused on this issue. Gays do have their own marriages in Christian churches (as well as others), except the government won't recognize them. (Why is the government allowed to recognize some religious marriages, but not others?) There is principal, and there are more legal benefits than just taxes as well.


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:33 AM by davespanners
reply to post by Helious



Erm, so you assume I would only defend gay people because I'm gay? I'm not so the use of YOUR is a little odd

Forever eh? So I assume the fact that until not so long ago in the UK you could be put in Prison for having homosexual sex didn't happen in your world?
The fact that some hotels today still refuse to let gay people share a room doesn't happen?
The fact that in many countries in the world the age of consent of gay and straight people is different isn't real?
The fact that it is STILL illegal to be gay in many countries isn't true?
The fact that straight couples can marry and gay couples not doesn't exist?
The fact that there are tax benefits and inheritance issues that effect gay and straight people differently is no problem?
edit on 23-3-2011 by davespanners because: spelling



reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:33 AM by darrylss










reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:40 AM by chancemusky
reply to post by Helious



They dont hold the rally to flaunt it, they wouldnt if they HAD all the rights straights have. If they continued afterwards, I think that'd be stupid to do it.

BTW, i apologize, I believe I may have misunderstood you earlier.


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:40 AM by Jean Paul Zodeaux
reply to post by Drezden





If you think the only benefit of a government recognized marriage that gay people want is filing their taxes then I understand a little better why you're confused on this issue. Gays do have their own marriages in Christian churches (as well as others), except the government won't recognize them. (Why is the government allowed to recognize some religious marriages, but not others?) There is principal, and there are more legal benefits than just taxes as well.


It is clearly you who are confused, and you continue to demonstrate this confusion. Your insistence that government recognize a marriage is the problem. Why do you need government recognition of a marriage if not for the "legal benefits" you speak of. It ain't about marriage pal, it is about benefits, and if you are talking about government benefits, you are not talking about rights, but privileges. Government should not be in the business of doling out privileges, and would serve the people better by protecting the unalienable rights of people, but there are these damned movements continually attempting to frame issues in terms of what they can get from government beyond what government has any real authority to accomplish.

Politicians love to pander to this crap, and petty tyrants love to create an illusion that they can "give" these benefits, but in reality it is an excuse to aggregate power and disregard the universal and equal rights of all people. Nope, you have not convinced me that you are genuinely concerned about equal rights for all people, just what you can get from government.


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:46 AM by ladymerelda
reply to post by Helious



YES! finally someone says it! hahahha =)

really no one cares if your gay, just like no one cares if you straight, or both.
ive known so many gay people and none of them act like the people on tv.
no one has ever tried to shove anything down my throat (sorry probably not the best use of words)
i think gays should be allowed to marry. why because I DONT CARE DOESNT EFFECT ME!
i know I for one am sick of the MEDIA making it seem like we have to be sympathetic towards the gay community. why they are just like me, except they like the same sex, BIGDEAL!

once everyone (even race/religious/etc) just realizes we are the same. no one needs special treatment, the more you cry for special treatment the more people will dislike you.

just be yourself, be gay, be straight, be asexual. everyone should just shut up about it.

i am also sick of the people saying gay people will go to hell, and trying to change them. really? that is also ridiculous. simply because its a way of forcing religious values down someone's throat. i dont like that either.

be yourself. simple as that. if people dont like you, you dont need them around


reply posted on 23-3-2011 @ 12:49 AM by ladymerelda
reply to post by Jean Paul Zodeaux



well put!!!! I dont need a piece of paper, or a corrupt establishment to honor my love to know its real
I am married in my mind. its a state of thought. not a paper. not a tax incentive.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^