A question for all the "2012" non-believers, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 17 times
Topic started on 25-1-2011 @ 03:09 PM by ThreeDeuce
Why weren't you attempting to disprove 2012 BEFORE the Y2K scare?

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but I do assume that the Mayan Calendar was around before the year 2000.
If that is so, why weren't you voiceing your strong opinions against this before hand?

Answer: There seems to have been a global shift in conciousness that drove people to research ancient civilizations, and 2012 prophecy is part that has been uncovered.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Let me also point out, 2012 prophecy is NOT ONLY based on the ending of the Mayan Calendar.

Sumerian Texts also talk about about 2012 as "Changing of the World, as we know it".
And, before you completely disregard teachings of Sumer, remember these writings encompass many stories that fill out our Chrisitan Bible.

Also, Hopi Indian prophecy points to 2012. Even though they do not believe the world will end, they say that people who are unable to adapt to change will be doomed.

So, along with the Mayan Calendar, that makes THREE prolifent societies that warn us about this day upcoming.

QUESTION: So, why do you blatantly disregard the only major date that all three of these ancient and wise civilizations warn us about?

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So, you want to discredit all of 2012 theory because of your own personal theory that the end of their calendar means NOTHING...........

I won't even point out how small minded of an idea this is. But, to refute this logic, lets look at the rest of the Calendar.

The Mayan Calendar is comprised of Three Distinct parts.

1. Tzolkin
2. Haab
3. Long Count

It is the ending of the long count in which people discredit all of 2012 theory.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Fist is the Tzolkin, which is 260 days. So, does this calendar mean anything?
Mayan Shamans say that this 260 days is the gestation period of a Human.

This means the Tzolkin calendar counts the time from fertilization to birth, roughly.
So, the first calendar counts something distinct and important.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Second is the Haab, which is 365 days. We all can see this means something.
The Haab tracks a full solar year, which is a full cycle of Solar Birth.

This means the Haab is what Mayan civilization depended on to determine when to plant, when to harvest, and many many other aspects of their life. They lived by the Haab.
So, both the first and second calendars are important and life saving........

But, of course (by your brilliant deductions) the third must count nothing, and be unimportant

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Third is the Long Count, which ends December 21, 2012 (by some people's calculations).

I contend that the Mayans thought this was a very important calendar.

Why would they have a third calendar that counted nothing?

I propose that this is gestation of the human species, perhaps a step that we take in our evolution.
Or, this is a time of great destruction and peril.

Is it pure coincidence that astral projectionists can not see past this date during meditation?

The Mayans never say that the world is going to end, but if there was not going to be a change, then why make such a long calendar and why do you make sure that generations to follow pay attention to your calendar?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Or, its just easier to believe that everything means nothing, and you can stick your ostrich head back in its hole. That is easier after-all.


reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 03:26 PM by BadBoYeed
reply to post by Jedite



their long count calendar ends when the sun is aligned with the galactic plane.....it just so happens that that event coincides with a date on our calendar.....what are the odds


reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 03:40 PM by Jedite
reply to post by BadBoYeed



Very good actually, considering we've cannibalized lots of things from other civilizations. Holidays, Religions, Gods, etc etc... Even a lot of people with Mayan ancestry say we're interpreting the calendar wrong.


reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 03:45 PM by ThreeDeuce
The Mayan Calendar, especially the Long Count, is cyclical.

This means that after it ends, it begins again.

This "cycle" belief was a large part of Mayan Beliefs.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

They believed that our World was destroyed four times in the past.

The date on which they say the last world was destroyed and the current world was formed was August 11, 3114 BCE.

This date was at the last completion of 13 baktuns. The next 13 baktun completion cycle is the 2012 date.

Even though they do not say it is upon this completion of the 13th baktun that our world will end, and another will begin, does it take much logic to look at their past cycles and infer that they thought the same would happen?

If said events happened on the 13th baktun last time, surely they would have believed that similar events would happen this time. Because, the Mayans believed that even all of the days that we go through are cycles of past baktuns repeated over and over; this was the core of their cyclical beliefs.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here is a better description of Mayan Cyclical beliefs:

Quote from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_calendar"



This conceptual view, in which the "cyclical nature" of time is highlighted, was a pre-eminent one, and many rituals were concerned with the completion and re-occurrences of various cycles. As the particular calendric configurations were once again repeated, so too were the "supernatural" influences with which they were associated. Thus it was held that particular calendar configurations had a specific "character" to them, which would influence events on days exhibiting that configuration. Divinations could then be made from the auguries associated with a certain configuration, since events taking place on some future date would be subject to the same influences as its corresponding previous cycle dates. Events and ceremonies would be timed to coincide with auspicious dates, and avoid inauspicious ones.[7]



reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 04:07 PM by Jedite
Originally posted by ThreeDeuce
Originally posted by Jedite
I dont believe in it, because time, the calender, the dates are a totally modern invention.


So, time, calendar and dates are totally modern?



-----------------------------------------------------------------

The Julian Calendar was evented 46 years Before Christs Existence.

The Hindu Calendar derived from books written approximately 100 years BCE.

The Gregorian Calendar (current calendar) was invented in 1582

------------------------------------------------------------------

Perhaps 2050 year old calendars are a "totally modern invention" in your mind, but in my this says "ancient knowledge"

I won't even point out that the Mayan calendar was created approximately 2800 years ago, 1800 BCE, because surely this date is "modern" also.



The Gregorian Calendar (current calendar) was invented in 1582.

Being that's the one we follow yes fairly modern. So we retrospect our perspective back onto others, just like we wrongly assume that, surely the ancient's couldn't be as smart as us or as advanced as us. I'm just saying we dont know if it ends, if it repeats, if anything happens.

I know people will believe what they want to believe no matter how much proof or non-proof is brought to the table. So why not just let them believe it? Who really cares if people think the world is going to end, or we're going to ascend or some great change will come. Like I said before, we'll all get to the end of the race eventually one way or another.


reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 04:13 PM by TheWalkingFox
Originally posted by ThreeDeuce

Why weren't you attempting to disprove 2012 BEFORE the Y2K scare?


Why would I try to disprove something no one is actually attempting to prove?

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but I do assume that the Mayan Calendar was around before the year 2000.
If that is so, why weren't you voiceing your strong opinions against this before hand?

Answer: There seems to have been a global shift in conciousness that drove people to research ancient civilizations, and 2012 prophecy is part that has been uncovered.


My theory? It's because after Y2K failed to destroy the world, all the chicken littles that need there to be a doomsday crisis over the horizon latched onto this 2012 business. And when 2013 rolls around, I'm sure they're going to find another near-future date for the "big one," and will panic accordingly


And, before you completely disregard teachings of Sumer, remember these writings encompass many stories that fill out our Chrisitan Bible.


And this is supposed to lend credibility?

Also, Hopi Indian prophecy points to 2012. Even though they do not believe the world will end, they say that people who are unable to adapt to change will be doomed.


A prophecy made in the 1960's, and published into books, to capitalize on the starry-eyed hippies who thought that if an Indian says it, it must be true. Truth is, we just like pranking white people, and if you can make a buck off of it, what the heck, right?

So, along with the Mayan Calendar, that makes THREE prolifent societies that warn us about this day upcoming.


Prolifent? What's that mean? Are you combining "prolific" with "proficient"? And, well, not to dis the Hopi, but I'd hardly put them on the same scale as the Sumerians or Maya.

QUESTION: So, why do you blatantly disregard the only major date that all three of these ancient and wise civilizations warn us about?


Because so far only the Maya mention that date (Sitchen does not count as Sumerian research, and I just explained hte Hiopi thing) and they don't give any "warnings." Unless it's like the calendar you can buy at the store that tells you "End of the year, buy a new calendar"

So, you want to discredit all of 2012 theory because of your own personal theory that the end of their calendar means NOTHING...........


It means it's time to get a new calendar. Doesn't sound that dramatic, but have you seen these things? They're big handcarved rocks. And the math involved! Getting a new Mayan calendar will be a lot of work!

I won't even point out how small minded of an idea this is. But, to refute this logic, lets look at the rest of the Calendar.


Not believing in something that has no evidence isn't small-minded. It's "intelligence."

The Mayan Calendar is comprised of Three Distinct parts.

1. Tzolkin
2. Haab
3. Long Count

It is the ending of the long count in which people discredit all of 2012 theory.


"Theory" has an actual scientific meaning. The word you want is "guess."

Fist is the Tzolkin, which is 260 days. So, does this calendar mean anything?
Mayan Shamans say that this 260 days is the gestation period of a Human.

This means the Tzolkin calendar counts the time from fertilization to birth, roughly.
So, the first calendar counts something distinct and important.


Distinct, yes (and it does so inaccurately, since it's ten days off a full nine-month gestation, and actual gestation length varies from pregnancy to pregnancy). Important? I dunno, it's just counting days that someone is pregnant. Meaningful from the religious perspective of the Maya? Sure, but not world-shattering.

Second is the Haab, which is 365 days. We all can see this means something.
The Haab tracks a full solar year, which is a full cycle of Solar Birth.

This means the Haab is what Mayan civilization depended on to determine when to plant, when to harvest, and many many other aspects of their life. They lived by the Haab.
So, both the first and second calendars are important and life saving........


Well, the sun doesn't go out at the end of the Haab, does it?

But, of course (by your brilliant deductions) the third must count nothing, and be unimportant


It's a measurement of how long it takes to get from point A to point A again. Just as the other two do.

Third is the Long Count, which ends December 21, 2012 (by some people's calculations).


By some people's calculations is the catch, there. Namely the "some."

I contend that the Mayans thought this was a very important calendar.


They also thought that building towns around arsenic-laced water holes prone to cave-ins was a good idea. I mean c'mon, if you can see the future, you could at least understand the notion of toxic metals, or good urban planning, right?

Why would they have a third calendar that counted nothing?


Why do we have a month that only has 28 (sometimes 29) days? Leap years must be a period of significant importance, right? Nah. It's just because of how the math works out.

I propose that this is gestation of the human species, perhaps a step that we take in our evolution.
Or, this is a time of great destruction and peril.


Evolution doesn't work that way.
I propose that when 2013 rolls around, we get a new rock slab and start carving. Bring your abacus, you'll need it.

Is it pure coincidence that astral projectionists can not see past this date during meditation?



2012 is also the year unicorns go extinct, ZOMG!

The Mayans never say that the world is going to end, but if there was not going to be a change, then why make such a long calendar and why do you make sure that generations to follow pay attention to your calendar?


Because that's the way the math worked out. I'm sure if someone had the patience, they could have devised a Longer Count calendar, too, just by following the cyclical math already present. I mean hey, if you had just invented the concept of zero, wouldn't you want to take it our for a spin?

As for making sure future generations pay attention... Did you ever have to sit through your grandparents telling you a long, rambling story about "when I was your age?" Yeah, it was important to them, so they're like, it's important to you, too, so listen up sonny.

That said, the Maya actually lost knowledge of this calender system not too long after the priesthood collapsed.

Or, its just easier to believe that everything means nothing, and you can stick your ostrich head back in its hole. That is easier after-all.


Well, here's the thing.

If Kulkulkan is going to show up in 2012 and remake the universe, I kind of doubt there's anything I can do about it one way or another. If it's true, then he's going to do it whether I believe or not, right? Believing in it does me no good, since I can't really stop a Mayan creator deity.

However, if it's NOT true, then I can either spend the remaining two years worrying about something that won't happen and feel really dumb when 2013 comes around. or I can spend the remaining to years just doing what I would have done anyway.

It's kind of Pascal's Wager in reverse. it's more of a benefit to not bother, since if it's true, I lose nothing by not bothering, and if it's false, i lose by bothering. See?


reply posted on 25-1-2011 @ 04:20 PM by TheWalkingFox
reply to post by simples



They're mostly in Tabasco and Chiapas, with significant populations in Yucatan, Campeche, Quintana Roo, the Cayo and Toledo districts of Belieze, and Western Guatemala (especially the departments of Baja Verapaz, Quiché, Totonicapan, Huehuetenango, Quetzaltenango, and San Marcos)

They're not cranking out pyramids anymore, but they're still there
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>    ^^TOP^^



May 20/21, 2012: the true meaning.
  Posted 8 days ago with 25 member flags
Cool Eclipse pictures (Earth, Moon, Sun, Pleiades)
  Posted 8 days ago with 24 member flags
Why the 2012 Phenomenon is Real!
  Posted 11 days ago with 21 member flags
World Message: Beginning May 26 thru Dec 21
  Posted 10 days ago with 14 member flags
newly discovered mayan calendars go beyond 2012
  Posted 18 days ago with 12 member flags
OMG: 2012 KP24 Incoming! Are we Doomed?
  Posted 3 days ago with 10 member flags
Nebula or Nibiru (May 28 2012)
  Posted 1 days ago with 10 member flags
Secret rogue planet may be hiding behind Neptune
  Posted 14 days ago with 7 member flags