It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by FredT
The record of people recieveng psychological treatment is mixed at best. How can you be sure that treatment was effective. From a therapy standpoint yes it has to be tailored to the individual, even if money was no object, how could we ever be sure the individual was treated. You are also making an assumption that these are individuals that want treatment as well. How many do not? How many are simply sociopaths for the lack of a better word and the deaths simply do not bother them. How do rehab a Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, Ted Bundy, Larry Singleton, et al? No amount of good thoughts and finding our happy place was ever going to convince me that these people are safe.
Originally posted by Durden
Whereas you doubt offenders of serious crimes can be treated, I doubt they can't. I think the importance of a slight doubt in a question like this one can't be stressed enough. When in doubt, don't kill. Keep the offender away from the streets, yes, no doubt. But don't murder them in the name of the law. It does more harm than good to a civilized society.
Originally posted by FredT
How does it do more harm? The no death penalty stance is a recent development in our civilization. But has been an accepted practice for thousands of years. Has it harmed civilization? Even the most civilized for thier times had the death penalty. In hindsight we can look to our past and lable actions barbaric, by our current standards, but who knows how future will view our society. When impaneled for a jury you can only convict if you feel there is no resonable doubt. Yes there have been abuses of the system in the past, and I fully support the Barry Scheck Innocence project (I don't know how he sleeps at night). IMHO it should be mandatory, but after that, then they should face the penalty they deserve.
Originally posted by mako0956
Can some be rehabilitated? Sure, some, but not all.
Originally posted by Skadi_the_Evil_Elf
Try my "proper treatment plan for prisoners": take two 9 mm shots to the back of the head, and call me in the morning....
physically nauseated
Originally posted by Skadi_the_Evil_Elf
Civilization was BUILT on the death penalty, you seem to not get this fact.
Thje very first code of laws, the Code of Hammaraubi, stated clearly the death penalty was crucial to society. Eye for an Eye, and a Life for a Life.
So, your question, does the death penalty belong in a civilized society is clearly answered: YES. Civilization was built upon it, and every civilization since the very first has had the death penalty.
Originally posted by Durden
Abolishing such punishments is part of evolution of society. You seem to not get that fact.
Originally posted by Durden
The way you chose to ask this question is really significant for your argument on this issue. What you should be asking is Have we been successful in rehabilitating these individuals?
Originally posted by FredT
Historically the dropping of the death penalty is a recent development. The recent trends are hardly evolutionary. In 100 years maybe, but far all we know its a passing fad.
Originally posted by FredT
What exactly are you basing this on? Slavery and torture are one thing. Punisment for violating the accepted laws of sociey are another.
Historically the dropping of the death penalty is a recent development. The recent trends are hardly evolutionary. In 100 years maybe, but far all we know its a passing fad.
Even with say a 90% sucsces rate in rehabing these killers is 10% an acceptable? Would you be willing to run the half-way house for these killers? Would you want them in your neighborhood, knowing that 10% of them would relapse?????
Originally posted by MachineGunKelly
.....does the death penalty work? Well if you kill a predator so it cannot kill again, then yes it does....
Originally posted by Durden
let your society and its government commit the very offence committed by the criminal you want to punish. IMO, this (capital punishment) will and does cause society more harm than good.
Originally posted by FredT
We get back to this again.... How does capital punisment harm society?