Originally posted by
reply to post by TheWill
I couldn't even begin to say how we got here or where we came from but i do have one thing that is driving me crazy and that is if you go by evolution
how did man get the EGO?
It seems (just my opinion) is the biggest problem for mankind is the EGO.
If we go with evolution how did this come about to progress at such a rate that man will cut off his nose to spite his face so to speak for the sake
of his EGO?
If we go with God then why would God give man an EGO knowing that it is self destructive and his creation is doomed from the beginning and how could
he not see the outcome of his creation if he is all knowing? so why create something to see it destroy itself?
I am just a simple person trying to understand and never asked to be here and given a choice i would prefer to have never existed but i am here not of
my own free will so if God gave man free will how is it that i don't have a choice to be here or not from the very beginning? Why are we forced to
enter this existence?
If we go back to evolution when and why did the same cells that created man just stop and when and why did fish stop coming out of the water turning
into apes and when and why did apes stop becoming man?
Any ideas??
Dear laslidealist,
It certainly can be daunting to look at the issue of existence as we are flooded with opinions based on the outcomes people want. A common argument is
that if there are differing views than nothing can be known, that is an attempt to heard people to not have decisive views and makes them easier to
manipulate. The truth exists whether or not we know it, the issue is to try and understand what we can.
24 hours a day you are aware of one thing, that you are having an experience of existence. You are aware of your own being. You may not have asked to
exist; but, maybe existence is unavoidable. Before we can ask why, we need to establish the groundwork of what we do know. You know you are a
self-aware being which experiences pleasure and pain and an unlimited number of other emotions. That has consequences.
Whether this universe is a representation (some quantum physicists are saying we live in a fractal universe and this is all just a representation of
the quantum) or completely material, you still experience it. The next question that philosophy has attempted to answer is whether or not others exist
as self aware being, this is especially difficult to answer if you believe everything is an illusion.
We have two choices, "reality" is physical or it is a representation. In either case we experience it as real. We react to it. Descartes is a good
place to start if you wish to look at the base principals of existence and his writings can be found on-line. Look inside your heart, do you feel as
if you are the only sentience that exists? Probably not, few do. The exact nature of the material is beyond because we can only observe a very small
amount of what is around us.
Why do you presume that God wants to destroy everything or that he created it for that effect. Lets look at the effect of our existence within this
reality, it causes us to change and grow. Growth can be unsettling as our nature is to want to rest, to avoid pain and increase pleasure; but, this
does not promote learning or growth. We can choose to be evolving beings, learning and building upon what we do know or to just ignore the nature of
our reality.
Rather than focus on creation (be in spiritual or natural) we have to focus on are sentience, self-awareness. As we go along that path, and it takes
more than a post to do this, we may come up with answers that make us feel uncomfortable. The truth for everyone of us is that one day we became aware
of ourselves and that in and of itself leaves a lot to consider.
I am not saying this next part is the truth, it is however a possible answer. Sentience exists, you exist. We begin as purely emotional beings, over
time we learn symbols and language that allows us to begin to make sense of our emotions and control them. By controlling our responses we can begin
to examine the nature of our reality rather than just respond to pain and pleasure, we can make independent responses to the world around us.
What if God were the totality of all life's awareness? The bible says God split himself into three. I find that interesting, why split himself? My
answer is that in order to see the limits of what is possible he created others to find all the possible answers, to see the limits. To find the
limits means the limits of pain, pleasure, boredom and every other emotion we are capable of having. This is the exact opposite of thinking we were
created just to have pleasure.
The creation of the bible does not begin with human beings, it begins with the word. Most people assume this means the name Jesus and it may; but, it
does not matter, existence began when God moved from being alone and emotion to the creation of words and the ability to create, ;he chose to create
others. You asked for an ideas and that is what I attempted to give, ideas. I should say that what I am proposing is not an original idea, it has been
written about. The author of the Exorcist, William Peter Blatty, used to discuss it.
The essence of the two opposing spiritual beliefs is that we evolve as individuals due to our trials and successes OR that after this life we all
become one, no variation (Eastern Mystery Religions). What if it was a choice, what if that were the choice you get and the choice is determined by
the choices you make in life, to manage your emotions and learn or to just want to have comfort. What if God created you so that you could make an
informed decision to exist and that meant you had to take some time living the consequences of your choices on earth so that you could make them for
eternity? That would explain the need for ego and the need for challenge. Be well.
UPDATE:
The first thing God had Adam do was to name all the animals. I mention this because we have language, it is part of the answer, the nature of language
and how it allows us to conceive of and understand our existence. The more precise our language the better we can consider alternatives. I ask the
question of why we even have language, plenty of animals exist without it.
edit on 18-1-2011 by AQuestion because: An additional thought on the
subject.