It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by whatukno
reply to post by thewholepicture
I can understand that you are unhappy with the way that this government is run, you aren't alone. But you have to be specific at what you are unhappy with, and you have to understand what you can really do about it. You aren't powerless in this country.
The TEA Party movement showed what real political power the people have. The unfortunate part is, that the TEA Party movement was hijacked by the Republican party and FOX News. What this country really needs is an Independent movement of people in the middle who don't have extremist views.
This country doesn't need a revolution, it needs an enema.
The things you are complaining about like the Gulf of Tonkin is old news, while it may have been wrong, not much you are going to do about it now.
The Patriot Act, well, much of the teeth of that act has been removed. Say the government spies on your phone calls, well, not only is that information not legally admissible in court, but you can also sue the phone company that provides your service for a lot of money.
The Fed, well, that's not unconstitutional. Is the Fed shady? No doubt. Do they do things that compromise our countries interests? That's debatable, but it's not unconstitutional for the fed to be in existence.
I am not saying don't be angry, I am just saying be angry about the right things. You don't need to declare your independence from this nation in order to enact real change, it has taken a long time for us to get to this point in our countries existence, and it is going to take a long time to get back to where we should be. Don't expect overnight change, you will just be disappointed.
Originally posted by whatukno
reply to post by ownbestenemy
The problem I see is, people who write these "declaration of independence" or use the original Declaration of Independence, are basically saying they are revolting against the government and have the intention of taking up arms against the government.
Thats why I think these people should be watched.
Those who would willingly and purposely kill their fellow countrymen should be locked up, those who would threaten to kill their fellow countrymen should be watched.
We who would like to make the government be accountable to The Declaration of Independance would be taking arms against the government. This statement is beyond unbelieveable as in the DoI it clearly states we the people have the right to overturn a corrupted and or tyronous government. Exactly how would I be taking arms to my government asking them to uphold the DoI? In a peaceful manner? You are a person who would take a peaceful americans true intents and manipulate the. intensions into a treasonous manner, " I the american citizen call you a "trader of the american patriot common citizen"
peace to your soul you need it.
Having a dissenting opinion of the government is fine. If your only solution is the violent overthrow of that government, I cannot agree with that opinion, nor can I condone that opinion.
Originally posted by whatukno
reply to post by thewholepicture
do you believe we are a completely free society?
No, we aren't in a completely free society, that is Anarchy and we live in a Republic.
do you believe putting me on a watch list because I practiced freedom of speech is constitutional under our bill of rights?
Typically the people that haul out these "Declarations of Independence" are people who want to violently overthrow the government in order to install a more fascist government based on what they think freedom is, usually after talking to these people for a while, you get the general idea that they don't want freedom at all but some sort of fascism where only a select few people have rights and the majority are subjected to a harsh reality where freedom is a long forgotten notion.
If you ask them questions like, what amendments would you repeal, they often will come back with the removal of the 13th and 14th Amendment, see to these people, they want slavery legal again, which obviously doesn't mean freedom for some folks now does it?
Some people also believe that the Declaration of Independence is their personal licence to kill their fellow Americans, they forget while many in Washington are indeed corrupt, they still are Americans and just because they are corrupt doesn't give anyone the right to kill them.
Originally posted by lbndhr
I t
I believe, no wait, I know you are ONE OF THEM...and you and know on my "watch list" I believe you are one of those people who would report me for my awareness of THE MAN and have me plucked out, TRADER
Originally posted by JaxonRoberts
Originally posted by lbndhr
I t
I believe, no wait, I know you are ONE OF THEM...and you and know on my "watch list" I believe you are one of those people who would report me for my awareness of THE MAN and have me plucked out, TRADER
Let me guess... You are a product of the Public Education System, and English Class bored you... And it also looks like you decided you had enough of that "book lurnin" at about the 9th grade level... Grammar & Spelling FAIL...
Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.
Originally posted by whatukno
reply to post by lbndhr
Here's the problem I have here.
There is a major difference between being a Trader, and being a Traitor.
A Trader, basically deals in free market enterprise, so, that is no insult to an American.
Now, if you are accusing me of being a Traitor, that's a serious charge, by Constitutional definition, as listed in Article III Section 3:
Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.
www.archives.gov...
I certainly am not.
The fact remains, that the United States is not a free country, it's a Republic, not an Anarchy, we do have laws, and those laws unless overturned by the Supreme Court, or repealed by Congress are considered Constitutional and should be followed.
The real Traitors, are those that would overthrow this Constitutionally elected government by violent means and install a fascist regime lacking in any liberty for select groups of people. These groups are quite active in the United States, claiming that this government needs to be overthrown, and only people whom THEY choose should be installed.
Maybe you have noticed these groups in action, they are the ones pushing for laws against immigrants, they are the ones that protest mosques being built, they are the ones that are fighting against gay rights, they are the ones that truly hate liberty and freedom.
The problem with these people is the ultra nationalism they represent, the "US first" attitude, where they believe that this is a white Christian nation, and that our lawmakers must pass laws that are decidedly pro white and pro Christian.