There is and link above about the two jets which one would win in BVR or in a dogfight if you say something you have to back it up with facts. I thin
the F-15 would because is has better weapons also its an unbeaten aircraft here is the F-15's armaments
1x20mm M61A cannon w/675 rounds,
8 AAMs AIM-120 AMRAAM and/or AIM-9 Sidewinder.