Originally posted by drew1749
Okay I'm done. I was just curious about if there was any evidence stating that it could be fake.
Probably the biggest piece of evidence to suggest that it could all be fake is the complete lack of good evidence that it could be true. Basically,
all you have is a bunch of stories. Where is the scientific research? Where is the control?
You get some little kid saying he was Joe Jones in a former life, and everybody gets excited and they test him by asking him something about Joe
Jones. Some things he gets wrong, but if he says, "When I was Joe Jones I liked cherry pie," then everybody suddenly remembers how Old Joe loved
cherry pie. That's the kind of evidence you get.
It's never that Joe Jones buried in some other state a trash can full of gold coins locked with a secret combination lock, then died, then a little
kid shows up claiming to be Joe Jones and he goes straight to the trash can in the other state, digs it up, unlocks the combination, and gets the
gold. Why couldn't that happen? Yet it never does. It's always excuses.
Yeah, just ask for some good, positive proof. Not a lot of half-baked stories. Not a lot of claiming evidence after the fact. That ought to do it
for any debunking purposes.
edit on 22-10-2010 by Blue Shift because: grammar