It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Grünbaum addressed a famous and simple question: “Why is there something rather than nothing?” He called it the Primordial Existential Question, or PEQ for short. (Philosophers are up there with NASA officials when it comes to a weakness for acronyms.) Stated in that form, the question can be traced at least back to Leibniz in his 1697 essay “On the Ultimate Origin of Things,” although it’s been recently championed by Oxford philosopher Richard Swinburne.
The correct answer to this question is stated right off the bat in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
Originally posted by clever024
nothing, nothingness cannot be percieved. its void, empty. everywhere you look there is "something" wether it be a molecule or a planet something exists.
Originally posted by spy66
Yes, nothingness is something. But nothing is nothing. It cant be something if it is nothing.
Nothing is used to describe something you dont know, don't have or can't see " like something specific".
Originally posted by 547000
reply to post by Korg Trinity
How can you have -5 of something in your hand?
Originally posted by Wut?!?
Mr_Awesome beat me to it, but here is my take on it anyway:
The verb to be, "is", implies existence. "This is nothing" or "Nothing is" makes no sense: it should be "This isn't".
If "it" is, then "it" exists. But "it" can't be nothing. Therefore "it" is something.
The question is false, because it implies existence, therefore it excludes "nothing".
Originally posted by Korg Trinity
Originally posted by 547000
reply to post by Korg Trinity
How can you have -5 of something in your hand?
You’re thinking too literally.
On a graph plot there is a +5 peak and a -5 peak in a wave like manor. The total value we are working with is Zero. Yet there are points where a value of +5 exists.
This is the nature of reality.
In effect Zero can never exist due to quantum fluctuations at the most fundamental levels of reality. It is this random chaos that forms order and what we perceive as something.
Do you follow?
Korg.
edit on 9-9-2010 by Korg Trinity because: Spelling
Originally posted by 547000
Negative quantities don't exist in reality either. That is why positive integers are called natural numbers. You can associate directions with vector or something like that but neither zero of a quantity or negative quantities actually exist. Think about what quantity means. This is why math took so long to develop up to complex numbers. It was only by accepting these abstractions that the theory of numbers progressed.