What on Earth are you talking about?
The idea that hiroshima/nagasaki didnt occur is one of the dumbest idea's ive heard.
First, they are inhabited today.
So? For very WEAK bombs, infact CRUDE and WEAK is that a surprise?
People still live at Chernobyl too you know.
The relative size of the Chernobyl release when compared with the release due to a hypothetical ground burst of a bomb similar to the Fat Man device
dropped on Nagasaki. A ground burst creates considerably more fallout than the air bursts used at Hiroshima or Nagasaki. Isotope
Ratio between the release due to the bomb and the Chernobyl accident
Also, if you had of actually been to any of these places, ie Nagasaki, you’d see that there’s been a HELL of a lot of soil/land added on top, ie a
few meters. Theres a viewing window down a canal that shows the ground AS IT WAS when the bomb went off.. its quite deep, under the top layer.
Second, both cities have active volcanoes within miles of the cities that just so happened to be erupting during the alleged blasts.
Volcano’s erupted during the bombs? Can you offer evidence of this?
Ive done a quick search and didn’t find anything...
Infact I did a search to list all volcano's in Japan, and there was nothing around Hiroshima.
Third, there are scant photographs of the cities before the explosions. If no one knew what they looked like before, one could assume anything
could they not?
There’s a lot of FOOTAGE and photos out there actually. Just search!?
Heres one straight from google.
Fourth, there was a complete media blackout in reporting on the damage with no Americans being allowed into the cities with the exception of
military photographers and reporters which totaled 2.
Actually, there’s many a book/dvd out there at the moment ( to which I have in my possession ) which shows footage from the days/weeks after the
bomb. There’s many a military man, photographer and even journo’s going with them.
But, you must remember A nuclear bomb had just been dropped, and the entire country was only weeks prior in a ruthless bloodlust war. Why would we let
anyone just walk around?
Fifth, Manzanar where most of the photo composites were most likely taken upon the camps destruction. If you look at any of the photos from
Hiroshima, most only show the mountains and not the harbors except for directly over head shots. Manzanar detainment camp looks exactly like
Umm, no. Theres a massive amount of photo collage’s of the entire city, every block of it on offer. Have you looked?
Manzanar is most widely known as the site of one of ten camps where over 110,000 Japanese Americans were imprisoned during World War II. Located at
the foot of the Sierra Nevada in California's Owens Valley between the towns of Lone Pine to the south and Independence to the north, it is
approximately 230 miles (370 km) northeast of Los Angeles. Manzanar (which means “apple orchard” in Spanish) was identified by the United States
National Park Service as the best-preserved of the former camp sites, and was designated the Manzanar National Historic Site.
It was not the best preserved camp as nothing stands but replicas. Also California and Japan share very similar landscapes having at one time been
right next to each other a long long time ago before the earths first growth spurt.
Hiroshima was an industrial Mecca in Japan. Industrial targets are the first taken out, not the last. Also, it is evident that bomb runs were done on
the city which was destroyed by fire and not by the "blast". This is found in the testimony's of the men and women who had spotted 3 lonely bombers
therefore, they did not sound the air raid siren on "that day". This indicates they had been performing bombing runs before August 6th, which again
would be true as it was an industrial city. Again remember, the city was destroyed by fire, not the "bomb"
Hiroshima was not an Industrial Mecca, Nagasaki was MORE industrial, and it wasn’t a Mecca. Hiroshima had a port and a base, it wasn’t
The reports. Have you ever read any of the eye witness accounts? I've collected about 14 of them so far. View them here Witness Testimony
I mean no disrespect to anyone, but these reports are too elaborate for simple folk going about their day to recall, especially after the shock of
what just happened.
I know the Japanese are very intelligent people, but the depth of these reports and the details recalled are to much for me. I've seen people killed
and it messes you up so bad you can't remember anything, unless you are trained to deal with such situations (which I was not). Your mind is
protecting you in shock.
All of them use the same terminology. They remember the days air scents and how the light of the sun glistened off of the water and how everything was
so perfect until 8:05, like they knew that day would be different so they took it all in first....give me a break.
For example, No one remembers what happened in a car wreck after impact because they are in shock, if they are even alive. They will remember bracing
for the crash, not the crash itself or it's after math. They will awake in the ER saying "what happened?", not "I remember the smell of the tires
as I slowly lifted my head to see the faces of the on coming car and the fear in the eyes of it's passengers"...Doesn't work that way.
Things may go into slow motion, but you remember nothing of the crash itself, just the bracing for it. It works the same way for any traumatic event
in which people die. Life wasn't sweeter that day as to recall such vivid detail and sorrowful pain, rather to them, it was a day like any other and
people in shock don't remember things so well.
So, your saying all these people shouldn’t remember it?
Most of the people who survived were FAR from the city centre, meaning they saw the ‘bright’ flash, they saw the ‘mushroom cloud’ they saw the
flames, smoke.. what makes you think they would all see different things?
Also, they had lived through how many years of war? They aren’t like the weak minded people of today. They were able to look at the events and
Eighth. The death tolls from regular bombing runs far exceeded the death toll of the "Atom" bomb, but no one is crying for them. At the
Dresden, 200,000 people were killed in one night. Conventional bombing runs on Japan killed more people then the "Bomb", but they are never even
According to official German report Tagesbefehl (Order of the Day) no. 47 ("TB47") issued on 22 March the number of dead recovered by that date
was 20,204, including 6,865 who were cremated on the Altmarkt square, and the total number of deaths was expected to be about 25,000
Another report on 3 April put the number of corpses recovered at 22,096. The municipal cemetery office recorded 21,271 victims of the raids were
buried in the city cemeteries, of which 17,295 were placed in the Heidefriedhof cemetery (a total that included the ashes of those cremated on the
Altmarkt). Due to the number of dead and lack of labour for collection of bodies for burial and cremation, those found in shelters were cremated where
they lay by flamethrowers. These numbers were probably supplemented by a number of additional private burials in other places. A further 1,858
bodies of victims were found during the rebuilding of Dresden between the end of the war and 1966. Since 1989 despite the extensive excavation for
new buildings no war-related bodies have been found. The number of people registered with the authorities as missing was 35,000; around 10,000 of
those were later found to be alive.
The only person spouting 150,000 – 200,000 was the Nazi propaganda minister.
Ninth. What country has someone attack them, then after the matter, the victims blame humanity for the aggression? You will never hear a
Japanese person say, "F---" America those Bastards killed my whole family". Nope, you will hear. "May Humanity learn from this lesson" and
"Humanity saw such devastation, may I live to remind all our brothers and sisters nuclear weapons should never be used again". Did we tame them as
if animals? I think not.
When I was in Hiroshima, for the anniversary of the bombing, I asked local Japanese why American flags fly so proudly in their shops
‘’ America so big, so strong, Japan so small, so weak ‘’
I think them being bombed showed their actual place on the world.
Incase your interested heres a write up with photos I took during my trip through Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 2008