It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
OP this thread is a circular argument that will never end.
there is nothing to prove out of it. You left christianity you get stronger.
I joined christianity I got stronger and more peaceful.
So to each his own. Everybodys story is different. Let souls believe, they will let you disbelieve.
peace.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
reply to post by NOTurTypical
You're assuming a logical fallacy.
I haven't given you enough information to come to that conclusion.
I haven't told you what questions I've had in the past and I haven't implied that there were no answers. I said that my questions went unanswered (not meaning that there were no answers) and that the answers I was given were illusive and not logical.
NEVER has a real Christian called me ignorant, a liar, a hypocrite and a narcissist.
If this is your typical approach in your proselytism, it's no wonder you're so angry and frustrated.
Of course that's also important, but more in the terms of salvation it's about having a personal relationship with the Lord. Jesus even says many will come to Him on the day of Judgment and list all the things they accomplished in His name and He'll say: "Depart from me you worker of iniquity, for I never knew you." gathering to do ministry, to praise and to worship as a body of believers is pretty fulfilling as well and I don't want to diminish that aspect of being a member of the Body of Christ.
Originally posted by Wang Tang
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
That's a nice quip I'll give you that, but logically speaking truth stands on it's own merits. Christianity is defined by the teachings of Christ. Even He said MANY would be wolves in sheeps clothing. There are numerous fakes, and I agree that it's discouraging, but Christianity is about a personal relationship with God that's made possible by the sacrificial work of Jesus Christ. It's a personal thing between yourself and God, so other's actions shouldn't matter. Jesus said there would be many that were false prophets, teachers, and witnesses.
If Christianity is all about a personal relationship with God then what is the point of church, what is the point of fellowship? I'm sure you don't intend to say coming together with other Christians is worthless, because from what I experienced in Christianity coming together with other Christians was the single most important thing in spiritual growth. You say others' actions don't matter, but they matter even more in Christianity. When a Christian who you spend a lot of time with is knowledgeable and strong in faith, you grow in spirit. And when a Christian you spend time with is ignorant and weak in faith, your spirit grows weak. Yes, the relationship with God is personal, but Christianity is not a personal path, and that is one of the reasons why I left Christianity. I wanted a personal relationship with God without distractions from other Christians.
Christ died for ALL men, so yes if it works for me, it will work for you. Are you claiming Christ is incapable of turning your life into a message but He is with certain people?? Christianity should never focus on what I can do or have done, but on what Christ has already done. And putting our trust in that.
Originally posted by Wang Tang
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
OP this thread is a circular argument that will never end.
there is nothing to prove out of it. You left christianity you get stronger.
I joined christianity I got stronger and more peaceful.
So to each his own. Everybodys story is different. Let souls believe, they will let you disbelieve.
peace.
This is funny. This thread is a circular argument? This thread is a thread about why people left Christianity. There is no argument to that, the argument only develops when Christians come into the thread and try to push their religion on people who left Christianity. You see, that is the problem with Christians, they assume that because Christianity works for them it should work for everybody. But you say "Everybody's story is different. Let souls believe, they will let you disbelieve." WELL then, I'm getting mixed messages from you. You say let people believe what they want and disbelieve what they want, yet you are posting in favor of Jesus in a thread about why people have left Jesus.
As I said before, I don't mind Christians posting on this thread, I just find it ironic that they do post.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
NO, using the argument that since your questions were not answered by the few Christians you asked them of then that meant your questions/objections had no answer at all.
Anyone who was logically seeking to find truth would at LEAST listen to the answers of a Christian who KNEW the answers to your question and weighing the two responses.
Says you, I find them unshakably logical.
Stop thinking then that just YOU are the audience of my message for finding truth about God, Jesus, and Christianity in this thread then
Originally posted by LeoVirgo
Do you really think Benevolent (or any other that has left it) did not question, did not ponder, sift it, weigh it and measure it?
Man has written down their ideas for thousands of years....God wrote Thees ideas in the very blueprint of life itself, it was here before us, here with us now, and will be here after.
.nature shows us this, it shows how everything is connected through energy....
Why not just come on and say.....'I am Christian, and I respect anyone who has foudn this not to be the way for them, but if you want to ask me any questions about my faith, I am happy to answer. '
On the contrary, I wanted a reason to stay, as it was deeply tied to my security in life. It was actually a difficult journey since it was all I knew.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
I don't know any Christians who know the answers. Of all the people I asked my questions (probably in the hundreds) I was not satisfied with the answers. They were not logical nor were they the same from person to person. I suppose you think YOUR answers would be the RIGHT ones.
"Says you"? And look, I'm glad you find your answers logical. Good for you.
But you keep quoting me and responding to my particular posts.
You are using me, then, to get a message across to other people, apparently.
Why don't you just start a thread to get your message across?
THIS thread is about why people have left Christianity.
You have not contributed ONE BIT to the subject of the thread, rather, you have hijacked it to spread your message and challenge the people who ARE participating in it.
I just saw that your avatar says, "Silencing the Heretics". Now it makes more sense. Well, this is one Heretic that you will not silence!
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
For one, i don't believe you asked 'hundreds' of Christians, most likely you asked several.
Originally posted by LeoVirgo
reply to post by Benevolent Heretic
@ Typical....its one thing to make your point, its another to go on and on in a thread that simply asks...'why have you left Christianity'.
Have you left Christianity?
No, you have not, so how does this really pertain to you?
Can we not have a nice little thread out of everyone's way here at BTS for the ones that have twisted their minds out of the knot of a dark age belief to converse with each other?
Okay, let me try to express it another way: If the answer to question X is "P" and person Y is pondering answers "D" J" "F" "T" and "O" and never has "P" to ponder then person Y has a BIASED SAMPLE. Person Y can NEVER come to "P" when it's not in their list of things to ponder, sift, or weigh.
Of course your posts are welcome...but making a point and then going on and on...trying to make it sound as if one of the posters here has left Christianity because they dont understand it properly, because they dont have the 'right' answers....is so silly. Do you really think Benevolent (or any other that has left it) did not question, did not ponder, sift it, weigh it and measure it?
Its not hard to find the roots of Christianity....they are soaked deep in blood.
You have no idea what you're saying. Jesus said "I and the Father are ONE." Jesus was against HIMSELF? Jesus is the Father made flesh. Please explain to me how you came to your logical conclusion without even elementary facts of the scriptures. lol
Its not hard to find the nature of the God image that they followed in the OT....and what most Christians over look is that Jesus himself WAS AGAINST THIS IMAGE OF THE OT GOD.
I dont understand how anyone can read the Bible, as an adult, and not see the dark age rituals within. I dont see how after they read about the nature of Jesus, they fall for the idea that Jesus's teachings are of the same god image as the OT teachings.
As much as you see your faith being 'logical'....I find it horrid that you believe someone had to die for you.
You want to call it love, what Jesus did. Sure, it was love for the Spirit within him, he lived for the life of the Holy Spirit.....instead of his life of Earth. He walked a personal path and showed us how to do the same. I think Christianity takes Jesus's greatness of his true purpose away from him and soaks it in a dark Earthly ritual of blood sacrifice.
You're insane, I have stated twice now that I said IF you were lying.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
For one, i don't believe you asked 'hundreds' of Christians, most likely you asked several.
Not surprising since you have already called me a liar. Fortunately, I don't care what you believe. It doesn't change the facts.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
There is a GREAT difference between Catholicism and Christianity.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
I have stated twice now that I said IF you were lying.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
For one, i don't believe you asked 'hundreds' of Christians, most likely you asked several.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
You have not contributed ONE BIT to the subject of the thread, rather, you have hijacked it to spread your message and challenge the people who ARE participating in it.
Originally posted by Wang Tang
Oh I disagree, he/she has actually contributed quite a bit to this thread by showing me why I left Christianity in the first place.
Originally posted by LeoVirgo
God does not boast, is not jealous, is not rude, is not prideful, does not envy, is always kind, honest, and never fails.