It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by ElectricUniverse
Yet atheism is the absence of all spirituality. Atheism is not only the disbelief in any deities, but the disbelief in spirituality.
Originally posted by ElectricUniverse
Communists believe in Atheism. Communism in itself is an atheist belief. There is no indirect connection. Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin, castro, and every true Socialist/Communist is/was an atheist.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
You guys are on the defensive and as I have said and reading Licht's post we are not trying to say religious people are better than Atheist. What we are trying to say is you just can't come to the conclusions of the study without already having an agenda at hand.
The vast majority in prison are there for very non-religious reasons and to suggest that if they have an ounce of religion in them then that is proof that religion is a factor in their behavior that got them into prison is an extremely bias thought, and shows a study that doesn't take factors like economic, culture, location, family continuity, mental stability, drugs, education and so on into the equation. All we get is religious vs atheist and I didn't even see a factoring in actual population percentages of each to actually tell if there is really even case at all.
The correlation of over 0.6 in favor of secularism is strong entirely because the U.S. is strong outlier. With the U.S. removed there is no significant correlation because incarceration rates are consistently low in the rest of the countries sampled, although the lowest incarceration levels are found among some of the most secular democracies.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
The problem is as Schrecken Licht also sees is you can't just pick something such as being religious, or being black, and make an all encompassing statement as the OP, and his study suggests.
You guys are on the defensive and as I have said and reading Licht's post we are not trying to say religious people are better than Atheist. What we are trying to say is you just can't come to the conclusions of the study without already having an agenda at hand.
The vast majority in prison are there for very non-religious reasons and to suggest that if they have an ounce of religion in them then that is proof that religion is a factor in their behavior that got them into prison is an extremely bias thought, and shows a study that doesn't take factors like economic, culture, location, family continuity, mental stability, drugs, education and so on into the equation. All we get is religious vs atheist and I didn't even see a factoring in actual population percentages of each to actually tell if there is really even case at all.
Why not do a study with a comparison of those who are in prison for crimes commited in the name of god compared to crimes commited totally from human desires?
Originally posted by Astyanax
Why not do a study with a comparison of those who are in prison for crimes commited in the name of god compared to crimes commited totally from human desires?
What in the world would be the point of that?
Originally posted by Astyanax
If you correct for other factors that influence the experiment, why not? Did you read the 'successful societies' study? All that was investigated by the researchers.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
I find prison as a extremely poor choice for either side of the argument since other factors are much more in play in affecting their behavior that caused them to end up in prison.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
There is nothing to correct here... you look at the results and find correlations…you let the results lead the way.
I’ll give you just one confounding with this study (of many). Our prisons have a higher percentage of minorities, and based on culture, minorities tend to have a very high religious percentage of their population, economics plays into this too since many churches help the local population, the poor will see more involvement with the Church. So the study is using our prisons with a very high ratio of poor minorities in them to prove their point.