Originally posted by expat2368
Does not seem quite correct to just take a quick look and call fake.

Ok, I won't take a quick look and call it fake. I was calling fake at the first sound of that fake cricket soundtrack

Wow insane, I would cry fake if I hadn't seen the rest of the spirals, It does look a little too clean though. Who knows for sure? After seeing everything else I've seen I wouldn't be surprised if it's real.

Geez.....

That ol' hoax forum is just gonna get bigger & bigger!

Cheers
Maybe...maybe not

I live in western Canada and I can't find any mention of this anywhere else. I've emailed the author of the article asking if she knows where it was filmed, I'll post back if I get a reply.

and the worst thing abou the video, they had to add crickets

Ha. Definitely fake There are some pretty damn good new UFO videos at the moment but that definitely isn't one of them. It's a shame a website with a half decent URL would spread such rubbish.

The photo was mildly convincing but they really killed it with the tacky video. Watching the video you'll notice that the point of an actual spiral occurs for about 1 second or 2 amongst 3 seconds to begin with and then a good long period afterwards of some cheap afterburner effect.

So take into consideration that whoever took the photo, if it was a genuine photo, would have had plenty of time to take a second, third, and one PRIOR to the point where it's a "spiral".

But I don't need to tell you that, it's already declared a fake. Nice effort, but I hope they admit it a fake in the future, cos it's not even a half arsed attempt. But if it was/is meant to be a tacky fake all along - fair play.

Good fake/illusion = That silver object on the beach being examined/moved by men in suits. Or that video of a UFO being carried by a truck. Halfway: The airplane abduction "footage". Bad fake/illusion = Teh West0rn Canadia Spirla

[edit on 22-5-2010 by markymint]

The photos were interesting, the video ruined it for me.

Interesting though.

Project Blue Beam came to mind for a second.

[edit on 22-5-2010 by Skellon]

Yeah I live in Western Canada as well, and I heard/read/saw nothing about this either. That first picture looks bad, like norways retarded spiral-brother bad. The video looks too clean cut, besides if something flew through the atmosphere and then caused some sort of explosion that you could Hear, that maybe it would have affected satellites or have been caught by more then 4 people.

Sorry Phage, I forgot to refresh my page and didn't see you already posted the 2nd vid.

I've never flown before, for those of you that have does this look like it was filmed from an airplane?

It's not my intention to defend this video, but rather to defend the art of debunking videos. As fake as something looks, you need to find actual consistent reasons that show it's fake.

It looks fake, but I see nothing that immediately proves it to be a fake. Just a gut reaction. But the crickets aren't necessarily fake. If it's a recording of crickets, well, the recording was taken somewhere...

Saying the ground would be illuminated is also not necessarily true. It could easily be an object too far away to cause a noticeable change, given the angles.

The lack of witnesses is the best evidence that it's fake. Those photos indicate that it should have been visible to thousands of people. I bet if we looked into it, we'd find that the three "independent" photographers aren't so independent.

I think the biggest indication that the video is fake is that it is in a perfect place to catch the whole scene BEFORE the light even shows up.

If the videographer had THAT much luck setting up the video, I recommend he immediately play the lottery, because that much luck should pay off! lol