It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
I'll give Russia just as much sympathy as Israel on this matter.
Originally posted by Damian-007
They're all as bad as each other...!!
The Chechnyans are just as bad as the Russians when it Comes to mutilating the bodies. Thing is the Chechnyans do it while the Person is still alive and the Idiots film themselves doing it.
So, I don;t have sympathy for either side. I have no idea why Russia just doesn't get on with it and wipe the Chechnyans out, once and for all. Then peace can return. Russia does have the capability of Destroying the Chechnyans and I wonder sometimes why the Chechnyans just don't give up. Isn't eveyone after Peace? Let's face it, if the Chechnyans get what they want, then What? What are they going to do then? They'll still be Poor and live in Crap..
There will be no peace until one side is obliterated, simple as that..
Originally posted by 23432
Untill Russia gives up lands of All Caucasian Nations , this madness , this terrorism is not going to stop , unfortunately.
Originally posted by mckyle
Russia needs to get rid of the monster - Putin - and replace him with a lesser monster.
Putin's Russia - AKA - Stalin's Russia.
Gorbachev was their one moment of sanity.
Originally posted by broahes
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
I'll give Russia just as much sympathy as Israel on this matter.
So the innocent people that died as a result of this are somehow justified because of this story? Gotcha.. Glad to see the good side of the human spirit from time to time, ya know.. just to feel alive.
This story, as well as the bombing are both tragic, but whatever helps you sleep at night I guess...
Originally posted by maloy
I assume that it is an explainable psychological condition for people to try and justify the terrorist attacks and somehow reverse the blame on Russia and the victims - especially people outside of Russia unconnected with the Chechen conflict. However should a similar terrorist act happen in their country, then they will expect others to side with them and to offer them condolences rather than blaiming them.
Terrorist attacks are just that - terror against civilians. They are not justified in any way. They are certainly not legal. Whatever motives they have, pale in comparison to the terrible nature of their crime. It doesn't matter where the terrorist attacks happen - US, Russia, UK, Spain, Indonesia, China, Iraq, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Israel, etc. Even if they happen in the country whose leadership you don't support - if they target civilians they are no better than if they happened at your front door.
This hypocrisy is sickening.
Originally posted by December_Rain
Originally posted by mckyle
Russia needs to get rid of the monster - Putin - and replace him with a lesser monster.
Putin's Russia - AKA - Stalin's Russia.
Gorbachev was their one moment of sanity.
I disagree with you..Putin is so far the best person in power in Russia till date. He is everything a leader should be.
Originally posted by maloy
Gives them up to whom?
To Caucasians , obviously .
What do you mean All Caucasian Nations?
Russian Federation Citizens who are of Caucasian Stock and their respective nations
There are many peaceful regions and autonomous republics in the Caucasus that have no problem being part of the Russian Federation, and in fact benefit from it.
All though I agree that the status quo is good and mostly working . I would wager a 10 ruble that the Chuvash , if giving the chance , would want to stand up as slighty different then Russians .
This includes Krasnodar, Adygeya, Cherkessia, Stavropol, Kabardino Balkaria, North Ossetia-Alania, and most of Dagestan and Ingushetia.
I am an Adygean
And the Caucasus region isn't just populated by non-Russian ethnicities. The vast majority of the region is, and has been historically populated by Russians.
About the Russian existence in Caucasus , I would say that they have arrived at last milennia .
Historically speaking , Maikop Culture is Caucasian .
Don't mistake the entire Caucasus region because of the actions of a small faction of trouble makers.
I do not mistake them at all . They are all ' my people ' , the mountaineers .
Also if you didn't know - Chechnya did have a shot at independence.
I did know . In fact I knew Dudayev's Turkish Contacts too . Their so called shot at the independence was doomed for failure .
And the main reason was that it did not suit Moscows ambitions .
It was de facto independent from 1991 to 1994, and again from 1996 to 1999. It deterriorated into a anarchy and criminal state, with constant infighting by different warlords.
Surely , when Cahar Dudayev was taken out by a Russian Mig fired missile , somebody back in Kremlin was already sending out instructions to the warlords in the area .
If Dudayev was not assasinated , Chechens would of had their soverign state .
It economy was reduced to drugs and arms trafficking, kidnapping for ransome, and raiding neighbor regions and republics.
All true , unfortunately .
But not surprising at all .
War breeds chaos in any society .
Besides , it's a way of life for some Chechens and others .
While Chechnya was "de facto independent", it attacked Russian territories of North Ossetia in 1992 and 1993, and Dagestan
in 1999.
They still are trying and as soon as they get Dagestan , it is over for Rodina .unfortunately
The problem is that when Chechnya was self-ruled, those who came to power were radicalist militants. They wanted to spread the struggle for independence to neighboring republics, regardless of the fact that those republics wanted nothing to do with them.
Right to self determination is supreme .
I mean all Caucasian Nations would been EU members today , only if they had the same treatment of eastern European nations who once were in USSR like the Caucasian nations .
What is good for the goose is also good for the gander too .
If Chechnya is given full independence, the same radicalist Islamists will come to power.
this is true in the short term .
In that case it will not solve any problems for Russia, not by a long shot.
It is not Russia's problem first and upmost . It is the problem of other Caucasian nations to start with .
They will have to solve the so called problem . Unless if you are saying that they are the problem , surely , it is in the interest of non militant Caucasians to come to an understanding with their militant neighbours .
The rebels in Chechnya would not be content with indepence. They want a Jihad struggle throughout the Caucasus, and they are doing it for money - received from sponsors in the Middle East.
Also true . The only force to stop these wahabist warmongerers is to deploy the local sufi & nakhsibendi traditions .
Not Moscow's militia .
If Russia lets Chechnya loose, then it will become a "you give them a finger and they take the whole arm" sort of thing. It will not stop the terrorism and insurgency, just as it hadn't in 1991-1994 or 1996-1999.
Non Russians , if they decide to leave the RF , should have the choice .
Like how it is in EU .
Make no mistake - Russia is not dealing with your typical separatists here. These are Islamists, who see their objectives in a far bigger scope than just Chechnya. According to the current leader Doku Umarov himself, their goal is to create chaos in all of the Caucasus. These militants see themselves as a part of larger global struggle, which includes groups like the Taliban, Al Quida, and Iraq insurgents as their allies.
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
Well since you put it that way... Maybe we should petition NATO to commence immediate sanctions against the Russian Government for Acts of Terror against the children of Chechniya.
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
After all, the article explains that the bombing of Moscow was in retaliation for the Government sponsored murder of 4 Chechiniyan Teenagers - and that in COLD BLOOD....
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
Before spamming your ignorant agendas based upon a choice to remain blind of EVERYTHING involved, get a clue, and learn how to read.
Originally posted by 23432
To Caucasians , obviously
Originally posted by 23432
All though I agree that the status quo is good and mostly working . I would wager a 10 ruble that the Chuvash , if giving the chance , would want to stand up as slighty different then Russians .
Originally posted by 23432
I am an Adygean
Originally posted by 23432
About the Russian existence in Caucasus , I would say that they have arrived at last milennia.
Originally posted by 23432
I do not mistake them at all . They are all ' my people ' , the mountaineers .
Originally posted by 23432
I did know . In fact I knew Dudayev's Turkish Contacts too . Their so called shot at the independence was doomed for failure .
And the main reason was that it did not suit Moscows ambitions .
Originally posted by 23432
Surely , when Cahar Dudayev was taken out by a Russian Mig fired missile , somebody back in Kremlin was already sending out instructions to the warlords in the area .
Originally posted by 23432
If Dudayev was not assasinated , Chechens would of had their soverign state .
Originally posted by 23432
Besides , it's a way of life for some Chechens and others .
Originally posted by 23432
I mean all Caucasian Nations would been EU members today
Originally posted by 23432
only if they had the same treatment of eastern European nations who once were in USSR like the Caucasian nations .
Originally posted by 23432
It is not Russia's problem first and upmost . It is the problem of other Caucasian nations to start with .
Originally posted by 23432
Non Russians , if they decide to leave the RF , should have the choice .
Like how it is in EU ..
Originally posted by 23432
Caucasus region should be turned into a Benelux countries like structure and Russia should instigate the process .
Originally posted by 23432
Russia should make a deal with Turkics and Persians and let Caucasus become independent and weapons free .
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
Originally posted by broahes
Originally posted by DarkspARCS
I'll give Russia just as much sympathy as Israel on this matter.
So the innocent people that died as a result of this are somehow justified because of this story? Gotcha.. Glad to see the good side of the human spirit from time to time, ya know.. just to feel alive.
This story, as well as the bombing are both tragic, but whatever helps you sleep at night I guess...
people like yourself really don't know how to read I guess.
Right now you look like and idiot, I suggest reading and entire post before posting comments based on ignorance