The Video The US Army Doesn't Want You To See*Warning*, page 3


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 202 times


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:05 AM by ApacheJoe
reply to post by TheCoffinman



Well you better suck it up and watch it! you helped pay for it!


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:17 AM by Subconsciously Correct
As a current member of the United States Army, I would like to post something: This is horrifying and painful to watch, probably more-so for me than most of you who have commented, BUT to stereotype ALL of us based on that is not what I believe is the appropriate response.

I, myself, am in a huge dilemma. I joined at the young age of 17 years old. I thought the "war on terror" was just that. I was a naive kid who was not very spiritual at the time, and I thought with my impulses. I was a product of my environment (no excuse, but hear me out) and I signed the dotted line without much thought. I did not pick a combat job because I am not interested in combat, but I also realized there was a chance of it no matter what (again, this is back when I was a young kid with impulse-driven thought). I am not saying those who believe in this war are wrong. I am just saying I gobbled up what the media told me and blindly followed my impulses without studying the war itself.

Then I got to college and joined ROTC. I used to be a heavy drinker and decided to turn around my grades and get involved in something. I have never done anything really besides attend national guard drills here in country one weekend a month, and since brothers in arms are close, I decided to join the program. The program itself is good and there are a lot of really good people who would not want to do anything such as displayed on that video.

My problem is this: Over the summer I begun to change my beliefs. Things happened (not military related) that opened my eyes to the world around me. I see it in a different way now. I never knew if I could kill someone even back when I joined, and I know now that I just cannot do it and I will not do it. My problem is I joined ROTC and contracted before discovering my spiritual beliefs and changing my daily habits. I have been paid several thousand dollars, and I have 2 choices here

1. Quit ROTC and owe several thousand dollars. I can ETS (not re-sign my contract) next January since it will be the end of my 6-year enlistment. or 2. Stay in with the chance of getting sent overseas and be an officer in charge of several soldiers. To do this, I would have to sign up for 8 years national guard or 4 years active duty.

This is a very hard decision for me because of the money problem. I honestly do not know what to do. I used to think of this war differently, but now I feel like we are all fighting an unnecessary war. I respect all my brothers in arms I interact with every day, but I am having a hard time visualizing myself in a situation where I am obligated to go over there and participate in this. I am not a fighter, and I know this now. I have changed since I joined, and this is honestly the first time I have opened up with this (I know this is risky with IP tracking, ect, but I am going to have to mention it sometime to someone).

Also, I used to want to "defend this country" which I think is honorable, but now I believe we are all equal. There are those in other countries that have committed brutal crimes, but there are those here who have as well. I don't want to "defend" anything anymore. I want world peace. I want to stand next to anyone from anywhere and embrace feelings of love and harmony. I can't go over there and tell these people how they are going to live their lives. I wish you all wouldn't stereotype all of us. I changed a lot since joining, and I never had any intention of doing anything as depicted in those videos from the get-go. That's the reason I never picked a combat job. I honestly just want to become a psychologist as I have planned on and get out of this situation, but it is not an easy decision.

Last, I want to say I respect those who do sign the dotted line to defend their country. This is not a backlash at any of them. I hang out with fellow soldiers everyday and I respect and admire most of them. It is for some, and it is not for others. I am finding out that it is not for me, yet here I am


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:25 AM by SailorinAZ
reply to post by rainfall



People in the military are simply reflection of their society. Meaning, the same people who exist in the civilian world are in the military. However, believe it or not, people in the military are our cream of the crop. The majority of criminals, crack pots, slackers, etc are weeded out before even getting to boot camp. It is very sad if you think about it. When you take young men, testosterone, imminent death, violence, and a charismatic deviant, you will get all sorts of awful results. Just as in the civilian world, the military has police, prisons, and criminals. Simply need to put it all in perspective.


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:36 AM by randyvs
reply to post by OutKast Searcher





You had no problem listening to the descriptions of raping and burning an innocent 14 year old girl...prostituting a 15 year old till she killed herself...but the puppy is where you drew the line???

I didn't say I had no problem. Don't put words in my mouth .
I'll spit 'em back in your face.
Well now you made a mistake, allowing your retort to include me. Just because I mentioned the puppy, as a point I had to stop watching and
identify the cruelty to little animals as sign of pedopholia. That instead of being a clue to you about how I feel about the rest of the things on the vid .
You take advantage of the fact I started and stopped where I chose ?
I 'm gonna give you an out right here an ask you.

Do you have a problem with anything I said?

[edit on 3-3-2010 by randyvs]



reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:43 AM by Solomons
reply to post by poedxsoldiervet



I think you meant to say the Taliban asked for evidence linking Osama to 9/11 and they would hand him over. Since no such evidence exists America made no deal and invaded.


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:47 AM by randyvs
reply to post by LadySkadi




very easy to instigate outrage with a one-sided, shocking, disgusting or horrific you-tube video.

Good point Skadi. A point taken too. Stated well.

[edit on 3-3-2010 by randyvs]


reply posted on 3-3-2010 @ 11:48 AM by poedxsoldiervet
Originally posted by Solomons
reply to
post by poedxsoldiervet



I think you meant to say the Taliban asked for evidence linking Osama to 9/11 and they would hand him over. Since no such evidence exists America made no deal and invaded.


Of course the Taliban wanted evidence, Osama himself said they planned the attack after the US was on ground, what the truthers fail to remember is he has released hundreds of hours of videos claiming responsibility. It is funny how people ignore truths and spin them whatever way they want them to say.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>    ^^TOP^^