Billy Bragg, Tax Protest on Facebook, page 1
Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 6 times
Topic started on 19-1-2010 @ 01:30 AM by thoughtsfull
The singer, Billy Bragg has started stated he will withhold income tax payments to the government from the 31st January to protest Bank Bonuses

More details of the story can be found here:
news.sky.com...

He has also started a facebook group Nobonus4RBS which currently has 4,500 members

Billy Bragg wrote:
I have written to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Alistair Darling, to inform him that I am no longer prepared to fund the excessive bonuses of RBS investment bankers. Unless he acts to limit them to £25,000, I shall be withholding my tax payment on 31st January.


In one blog on the Telegraph, Tracy Corrigan, columnist and assistant editor of the Daily Telegraph portrays Billy Bragg's bonus protest as the right idea using the wrong tactics

This time round, I feel considerable sympathy for his chosen cause. It beggars belief that the bankers who drove the economy to its knees and had to be rescued by the state now have the gall to argue that market forces dictate they should continue to receive massive payouts.

However, Mr Bragg’s Facebook campaign NoBons4RBS is too narrow. His proposed remedy – that Royal Bank of Scotland bonuses be restricted to £25,000 – is far too specific. And I don’t like his suggested tactic of withholding tax payments. Other than that, it’s a great idea.


More details can be found on the link below:
blogs.telegraph.co.uk...

It will be interesting to see if this facebook group, and the protest grows..


[edit on 19/1/10 by thoughtsfull]


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 02:03 AM by thoughtsfull
reply to post by grantbeed


Well, given the media attention this is now getting.. a nice prime spot on the Beeb this morning I would say that he is going to get a lot of support.

I am struggling to understand all the levies this government is starting to suggest.. Victims levies on Car parking offences, Littering levies on Sweets, crisps and drinks, all sneaky ways to increase their revenue, and will continue unabated unless people stand up to them.

So what will they propose to put a levy on next?

Historically, like most countries, Britian has a history of tax protests.. from the peasants revolt (the Great Rising of 1381, related to the 3rd poll tax) to the Poll Tax riots of the 90s. Even the civil war was rooted in opposition to the tax "Ship Money"

The amount of money thrown at these bankers, and the expectation that we are paying for their lavish lifestlye will just result in deeper resentment. I can't help but agree that what Billy is doing is right, but also feel his focus is to narrow.



reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 03:06 AM by liquidsmoke206
reply to post by thoughtsfull





However, Mr Bragg’s Facebook campaign NoBons4RBS is too narrow. His proposed remedy – that Royal Bank of Scotland bonuses be restricted to £25,000 – is far too specific. And I don’t like his suggested tactic of withholding tax payments. Other than that, it’s a great idea.



Other than that? What else is there other than that?

reply to post by grantsbeed



the Bankers who are making these bonuses and the Polititions who are Claiming ridiculous stuff on their Expenses should all be Publicly Executed. this surely would have been the case a not so long ago.


Now, now... we cant just go around executing everyone we deem a scumbag.
not so long ago? When were we executing people in public for getting ridiculous payouts?


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 03:32 AM by thoughtsfull
reply to post by liquidsmoke206


Well, I think it is too specific to RBS and the bonus culture.. the sneaky so & so's will find a way around a simple cap on their bonuses..

The bonuses are a few of the holes in the leaky bucket that is our financial system.. since we are the ones that are going to have to fill that bucket (via taxes) I for one am really keen to see all the holes fixed.


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 04:17 AM by liquidsmoke206
reply to post by thoughtsfull


billy brag is one man attacking one hole in the bucket, what do you expect?
do you see another hole? wanna stop it? show some initiative and pull a billy brag.

don't be "furniture."


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 05:17 AM by thoughtsfull
reply to post by liquidsmoke206


LOL, thanks for making me smile... and that link was cool, thanks.

I really do not know what else to say except the institutions need to find the will to change.

I am one of those PM process bods that fixes coporate leaky buckets, deploys processes to meet new legislation, merge coporates etc.. and have been offered roles in these institutions with the aim of fixing some of the issues.

But I've not felt the will is there to change, if the will is not behind change, how do these institutions change? this is the {} part of my job that means without the will what fixes I could do would be a waste of time..

So what Billy is doing is admirable and gets my full support.. But I am not sure how we can fix a lot of the holes without a radical rethink of the entire system.

I can, hand on heart say that I am up for trying to fix the system.. but I recognise that without the will to change I am wasting my time, this is leaving me scratching my head as to how we can help them.


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 05:29 AM by Karlhungis
reply to post by endisnighe




You know, someone here should spread this to their Facebook page and start the same thing here in the US.


Well, obviously that is entirely up to you. I don't necessarily think that posting your intention to stop paying taxes on a social networking site that holds all of your personal information and is monitored by the government as such a great idea.

If I was going to stop paying my taxes, I would do it in private or at least a more anonymous manner.


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 10:04 AM by endisnighe
reply to post by Karlhungis


Well, what is funny, I have several facebook pages. I use to use them to do social things and play Mafia Wars.

When one decides to make a stand, does one really not think it needs to be done where everything is out there?

Sooner of later, one must stand up and be counted, so to speak.


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 02:30 PM by liquidsmoke206
reply to post by thoughtsfull


I think you and brag are on the same page. But your waiting for the system to change, and brag is actually tryin to derail the system. You want the system to have the will to change, and brag wants to impose his own will for change.


reply posted on 19-1-2010 @ 04:24 PM by thoughtsfull
Originally posted by liquidsmoke206
reply to post by thoughtsfull


I think you and brag are on the same page. But your waiting for the system to change, and brag is actually tryin to derail the system. You want the system to have the will to change, and brag wants to impose his own will for change.


Thank you for the fresh insight.. Perhaps I've been kidding myself that I tried to help, and all I have done is give them advice, and then walked away rather than take up the challenge.

thank you

Pages:     ^^TOP^^



USDA Forces Whole Foods To Accept Monsanto
  Posted 12 days ago with 100 member flags
Greece wipes out Citizens Debt!! Tells Bankers to suck it
  Posted 13 days ago with 78 member flags
Obama on the verge of a deal with the banks
  Posted 18 days ago with 23 member flags
Bankers requesting that Greece become their debt slaves
  Posted 16 days ago with 15 member flags
We’re on the brink, warns Greece ahead of summit
  Posted 14 days ago with 15 member flags
Heard a rumor on a disreputable anarchist forum....
  Posted 16 days ago with 12 member flags
The Real Story Behind the Greece Debt Default
  Posted 12 days ago with 11 member flags