The argument for a Punt being relatively close to Egypt can be made.
We known that some of Punt's treasures were carried over land by way of Nmay and Irem (through the modern Sudan). We also here of the children of the chiefs of Punt that were raised at the Egyptian court alongside the children of Kush (Nubia) and Irem.
For the more Southern locations:
"There is still some debate regarding the precise location of Punt, which was once identified with the region of modern Somalia. A strong argument has now been made for its location in either southern Sudan or the Eritrean region of Ethiopia, where the indigenous plants and animals equate most closely with those depicted in the Egyptian reliefs and paintings.Ian Shaw from the Oxford History of Ancient Egypt
ABOVE: Myrrh trees being dug up and brought to Egypt. From Hatshepsut's temple at Deir el-Bahari.
One more tantalising bit of information regarding Punt can be gained again from the Deir el-Bahri scenes.
depictions of the unusual Puntite settlements, comprising conical reed-built huts set on poles above the ground, and entered via ladders.
I wonder why this type of dwelling was favoured? Does this suggest flooding (Punt being closer to the Nile?), or wild animals (placing Punt further South and West)?
Nobody can know for sure, but here is an image depicting the dwellings described:
I find it sad that the story of Punt is told by their neighbours, on walls and tombs of trading partners. However the fact that their dwellings seem to be made of wood and palm may point to the reason why so little has been found of them.
I like to think they celebrated life in a way the Egyptians couldn't, placing importance not on the afterlife, but the here and now.
Think about it, if it wasn't for the Egyptian's total obsession with death, tombs and the afterlife, how much about them would we know today?
I hope this thread has been at least interesting, if not too informing from the lack of real evidence out there.
All the best ATS, Kiwifoot!
SOURCES
Queen Hatshepsut's expedition to the Land of Punt: The first oceanographic cruise? by Sayed Z. El-Sayed
The Wonderful Land of Punt
by Jimmy Dunn
Ancient African History: The Land of Punt
Sailing into antiquity - Boston.com
Wikipedia: Land of Punt
Inscriptions from the Tomb of Harkhuf
Hatshepsut´s Mortuary Temple RECOMMENDED READING
[edit on 13-1-2010 by kiwifoot]












