Originally posted by Blane2012
Here you display an unreasonable desire to pretend that humans would simply sit there and allow a glacier, approaching at one inch per year, to
completely wipe out their civilization.
Not quite sure I follow you, Harte. My proposition was that humans would in fact be active during an Ice Age, but would not nor be able to have proper
knowledge to develop in an advanced sense as a collective whole. Although, your point probably went over my head.
My post was in response to what you (and others here) have been saying about civilizations existing prior to the last Ice Age.
To my mind, I have no doubt at all that an Ice age would have caused problems. But I also have no doubt at all that an Ice Age, which basically
impacted only the top half of the Northern Hemisphere, certainly wouldn't have reduced humans to a level of breaking stones for tools, which is what
we see in the (fairly) recent past.
For example, your post:
Originally posted by Blane2012
It's ridiculous to think that homo-sapiens have been walking the earth for an estimated 200,000 years (Mitochondrial Eve) and just recently we
started building advanced culture, regardless of what science tells us. As I stated in my original post, there's also no way of knowing how
intelligent the breeds of the genus homo were before us. 1 million years ago an advanced form of human could of been partying it up, even better than
we can.
If you want to believe, on faith alone, that humans rose to reasonably "high" levels at such early dates, then that's simply a belief you want to
hold. But your explanation for the only evidence we have - stone tools, nomadic and hunter-gatherer existence - that "the Ice Age wiped out all the
evidence" is simply logically unsustainable.
You should note that we actually have evidence from the time period involved, and from earlier time periods. Where are the remains of this
cfivilization you want to have existed, when we see wooden spears and stone implements in place even before the last Ice Age?
IOW, in reference to another post, if they could make rifles before the Ice Age, it's almost a certainty that the still could afterwards.
Clearer?
Harte