The Americans have suffered the same incident on numerous occasions, it clearly shows the Afghan population (or parts of it) cannot be trusted. I'm sorry to be so callous, but if a military force is going to participate in an occupation then operate in an "occupation manner"

Boer War and the British occupation of Egypt only delegated "policing roles" to trusted sectors of society - not random citizens.

What words are they to ease the pain of lost loved ones? Sadly none. Only hope can prevail. Sympathies to the families.

to be honest has anyone even pondered as to why this man did this act of random "extreme" violence ?

i´ll use the term "we" ,

"we" go there and keep the opium growing ,
"we" mess up the presidential elections and just bully them like they are some sort of second class people for 20+ years ,

"we", not them to us....


tip of the hat to thouse that lost loved ones.

If the Afghanis were smart they'd infiltrate and do this more often. God bless the British soldiers that died. But the West has no business making war on the Afghan people. I admire the Afghan people for standing up to the US and other countries and protecting their culture. Most of the tribes and people just want to be left alone.

What I find disgusting is that the west and Americans and others view the Taliban as archaic, barbaric, savages. We look down on their culture in utter disgust for the so called evilness that it represents. But did Native Americans treat women or each other any better? Did the Mayans? The Aztecs or countless cultures across the span of the last 1000 years? I mean come on. If Americans witnessed half of the atrocities Aztec and Mayan civilizations perpetuated against their own people and enemies they'd throw up. Yet we admire their culture hundreds of years later. What's the difference between human sacrifice and cutting off someone's head for sharia law?

---

---

Need to get the majority of soldiers out of there asap. They now have a fraudulent president (so the entire 'aim' of creating democracy failed a long time ago), it's wasting a lot of money and lives. You don't need thousands of soldiers to secure an oil pipeline or poppies or whatever else it is the government really wants, and you will never kill every single person opposed to you and willing to do harm (the "taliban" are just a small group of these - impossible to root out).

Originally posted by AR154
Need to get the majority of soldiers out of there asap. They now have a fraudulent president (so the entire 'aim' of creating democracy failed a long time ago), it's wasting a lot of money and lives. You don't need thousands of soldiers to secure an oil pipeline or poppies or whatever else it is the government really wants, and you will never kill every single person opposed to you and willing to do harm (the "taliban" are just a small group of these - impossible to root out).

funny thing how you people NEVER learn
from mistakes...

more troops will make no difference in guerilla
warfare



your troops should get out,
the sooner the better

---

---

Good god how stupid ARE these soldiers, first there was the incident in the Gulf with the Navy and now Five..yes FIVE soldiers being shot at by a cop. Im under the assumption they were armed as all combat forces should be when out on tour in the area, if not then serious questions need to be raised.

The fact their stance was withdrawn goes to show how the lack of concentration and judgement of threat in the Middle East arena is clearly evident, you'd have thought after the lessons learnt in Northern Ireland that Vigilance would be maintained at ALL times.

In the last words of Ned Kelly....

Ahh such is life

Five more deaths at the hands of the international drugs trade.

Sad really.

---

---

I salute the policeman that did this, it is called bravery

Murdering your defenseless, supposed "allies" during debrief. Gee, how brave.

[edit on 4/11/2009 by C0bzz]