Originally posted by talisman
Originally posted by kdial1
reply to post by talisman
I am confused as to what you are getting at?
The Texas footage was posted on youtube June 18th 2008.
The German one was posted a few days ago...
So how was the footage from Texas made to discredit the German footage when it was made before the German footage?
-Kdial1
I don't think I was clear. That is my fault.
The texas video in question almost looks like there are two different makers.
On the one hand it looks very convincing, then it goes to obvious no denying it type of fake. (this happens after the blur)
The thought ran across my mind that someone was trying to descredit footage by doing so.
Perhaps it is disinfo, I don't know. For now I will leave it as fake, but that switch in the video is somewhat unusual.
I don't understand what you are trying to say...
...is the "German" video supposedly made October 4, 2009 real? Is the Texas video (which is obviously the same footage edited differently) from
2008 real? Or are they both fake and made to discredit some third "real" event?
If both the Texas version of this footage and the German version were both made to discredit some other "real" event, then where is the footage from
the real event?
As for the dates on the German footage, how do we know for certain that it didn't come first?
Well, the people who posted the video said it was made by some guy named Max on October 4, 2009. If you want to doubt that the people who posted it
to YouTube were telling the truth about the date, then wouldn't that cast doubt on the whole video?
But, like I said above, if you think this video and the Texas video are both made to discredit another event, then why have we never heard of the
other event?
[edit on 10/8/2009 by Soylent Green Is People]