Fake for sure! I speak spanish and when they were pointing out the UFO they said it in a way that seemed extremely acted out. Almost sarcastic. They need better actors, though the CGI was good. It's a cool video least to say.

Originally posted by game over man
What did you do to analyze the video?

What are you talking about, he is referring to the Audio track, not the video.

You guys act like fisherman don't get their cameras wet.

Huh? How does this affect anything here?

Also there most not be any wind present.

Hmm?

Also uploading videos to youtube doesn't change the quality of the video.

Are you joking??? Youtube absolutely destroys the visual quality of whats uploaded. The audio may suffer less and you wouldn't know, but the video quality is shocking even for HD stuff.

But the AUDIO is clearly 2 separate tracks combined and left at stereo. How would a video camera pick up stereo for one part of an event yet only record another part in mono?

And how many fisherman carry around video cameras with stereo recording capabilities? I don't know that answer, so Im genuinely asking, I know you can get stereo capable recording cams, but I'd expect they'd be more for amateur film makers, and not the dude at work recording a day on the ocean with the fishes...

Not convinced.

My only argument if it was real, then why not major news?

However the debunking is not very good, imo.

My questions: Where was this shot? What time of day? What was the weather like? ect. ect.

People claiming it's cgi are just as accurate as those claiming it's real. There is no evidence for either.

However the audio track doesn't lie

Also the sound doesn't sound off to me considering it is on youtube and they are fisherman, and they are in a boat on the water.

You didn't read the post you replied to.

I think the boat and helicopter (check out the orange cloth get blown @33 seconds) are real.

Everything else seems iffy.... the best lies are the ones with enough truth mixed in to legitimize the other false elements.

Originally posted by johnmhinds
It's cgi.

Unless someone has developed a supersonic helicopter that can appear in front of you almost instantly.

You can't even see it on the horizon when you see the planes fly past for the first time. And it appears right next to the boat in only a couple of seconds.

The helicopter actually does appear on the horizon at 0:16 seconds if you look closely. I have looked over this a bunch and it does appear to be legit.

If it was CGI the pixels of the water and helicopter would not match that of the video quality itself

This was a very interesting video and yet at the moment the UFO hit the water something went wrong for me. After countless replays of the moment the UFOs did the separation (one seemingly zipping off to the right and the other slamming into the water) something went wrong for me.

At least it seemed to be some sort of separation but the UFO flying off to the right could have been compression artifacts and there was no separation at all. Without a better quality video it is difficult to determine that aspect.

The UFO that accelerated into the water did so at such a speed it was almost faster than the eye could follow. The kinetic energies involved must have been immense, and for me that was the problem.

The plume of water seemed much too small for such a phenomenal rate of speed so, reluctantly I have to go with a well made hoax because such acceleration I would have expected the plume of water to have been akin to a depth charge going off.

Still, a fascinating video and one that got me going on a wander with my laptop asking for other opinions lol

Guys, I speak Galician (the language spoken here) and Spanish and I can assure you from the "acting" and slang this guy is using this is completely FAKE! It is very unnatural, almost idiotic! I think it´s meant to be as a joke!
It is something that non Galician speakers would not pick up....the subtleties of the language.... "Me cago en diola"!! ha ha .
Also you can notice the UFO & jets are both CGI. (The helicopter may be real though)
there are real UFO videos out there, this isn´t one I´m afraid...

Just a quick question or two if that's OK?

Oh first I loved the Video, it actually got my adrenalin running, if it is a viral for a coming movie, I cant wait, as for being real or CGI ? I don't know, don't really care to be honest because the truth will out in the end, always does, it's called patience.

Anyhow
All the "experts" making comments on the sound, do any of you have any idea as to what type of Camera? is a camcorder? or one of those new fishing shows that are popping up on TV now about the lives of fishermen?

The "experts "on aircraft chasing UFO's , can I please talk to you for my research please? I want to know how they run something like that, and especially those who know what a USO looks like when they tilt like the one in the Video before diving into the water, I really need your evidence.

Thank you for your time, if this even gets read I will be so amazed, seeing how it seems a lot are jumping from post number 3 to the last page and post to give their 2 cents.

The "experts " on Human behaviour in a very exciting and mind numbing event, that throws itself in your face when one second your fishing and talking about every day stuff, and then trying to figure out WTF is happening because all of a sudden all around you is total chaos, but your supposed to act like ??? what ???

And finally for those "experts "who claim jets travel in pairs, but there where four, but I saw five of them, and the helicopter was bright browny bronze and are not used that far from land, how far from land was the boat again? I missed the part that said it was out in the open ocean miles from anywhere, for all any one knows they could have been 100 ft from shore fishing a shoal.

Now for all any of us here knows, just say for one second all what we see is real, the way the World is right now, your countries radar detects several air craft heading towards your coastline, and wont respond to radio calls, what do you do? nobody knows for certain how many jets where involved, so the timing thing is purely speculative, the helicopter, who knows who owns the helicopter? often there is talk about unidentified helicopters here, but this one because it cant be identified is a problem now?

Oh and why is it all of a sudden in this thread, are all the "experts" new members who I cant ever recall seeing around before? see we had all these " experts" why havn't we ever used them before?

Perhaps jets fly by and released a dumby bomb while on manuvers and to warn off a boat in the wrong area and someone added the ufo in for #s and giggles

How can you really tell what's fake and what's real if your not a pro. To me that looked impressive but once you start thinking about the quick bank of the fighters and return fly over...well. The helicopter was looking for something too, maybe it scrambled at the same time as the fighters.
Whatever is going on in this video is