reply to post by Byrd
Hello Byrd,
Thank you for your detailed and insightful reply.
Byrd: Scott, I think your references on shamanism are incomplete.
SC: Undoubtedly – this is a fairly new line of inquiry for me. Much to learn and even more to understand.
SC: In shamanism, certain themes are prevalent such as the ascension to the spirit world of the Gods, upon a ladder.
Byrd: Not true in Egypt, and not true in ancient forms of shamanism. It is found in neoshamanism (which emerges after 1970.)
SC: I am not so sure of your confidence in this. In the Pyramid Texts (dating to c.4,300bce) we find the following Utterances:
Utterance 478:
As for any spirit or god who will help me when I ascend to the sky on the ladder of the God; my bones are assembled for me, my limbs are
gathered together for me, and I leap up to the sky in the presence of the god of the Lord of the ladder.
A ladder is knotted together by Re before Osiris, a ladder is knotted together by Horus before his father Osiris when he goes to his
spirit, one of them being on this side and one of them being on that, while I am between them.
(Emphasis mine)
I do realise, of course, that the ‘ascent’ by the shaman can take many forms – a sky ladder, rope ladder, vine, spiral staircase, rainbow, or
even a stepped mountain. Many ways but clearly also a ‘ladder’.
Byrd: Shamans don't deal with gods... priests do. Shamans deal with spirits: en.wikipedia.org...
SC: Okay – I understand this and perhaps the term ‘Shaman-Priest(s)’ might be a better definition although even this may sound like an
anthropological contradiction. Shamans interact or interface with ‘invisible entities’, an experiential practice the impact of which may well
have been fundamental to and contributed to the origins of many ancient religions.
It seems to me that ‘organised religion’ (in the modern sense) may have lost 'sight' of its shamanistic roots and become ‘divorced’ from the
very ‘real’ ‘religious enlightenment’ experienced by the shaman-priest in their altered states of consciousness. Modern religion in this
sense is 2-dimensional, possibly having lost its true origins, indeed, even making the natural human desire to seek such origins a felony. In
‘primitive’ cultures/civilisations that are more in touch with nature such detachment from the source of their ‘religious experience’ is less
likely to occur.
SC: A common feature of the initiation process of the shaman often involves the initiate undergoing an out-of-body-experience in which the
shaman senses that they are being attacked and that their limbs are being torn apart, their body dismembered and reassembled before they can ascend
the ladder to commune with the spirit world.
Byrd: Ladders are a fairly modern tradition.
SC: Ladders (to ascend to the Gods) are mentioned numerous times in the PTs (see example above). The PTs – as you know – are c.4,300 years old.
Hardly modern.
Byrd: In many cultures that I've studied, the shaman "rides" to the otherworld on sound or motion (dancing) and travels on or with birds
(this is a belief of the Costa Rican (and Central American) shamans which continues today and is reflected in their tribal art of birds and other folk
practices.) They also report flying to other worlds on smoke, rainbows, or riding on animals. It was common for Native American shamans to see the
process as climbing a mountain. Travel below was accomplished by descending through hollow trees, caves, tunnels, and tubelike structures.
SC: Agreed.
Byrd: Sacred-Texts has a lot of old material on shamans that you may wish to read. You will notice, though, that none of the texts mention
ladders: www.sacred-texts.com...
SC: Thank you for the link.
SC: This 'experience' (state of consciousness) is very reminiscent of the Ancient Egyptian story of Osiris in which Osiris is attacked,
dismembered only to be put together again by his consort, Isis, before journeying on to the Afterworld to be with the Gods.
Byrd: Dismemberment isn't part of the process for the shaman as a usual course of affairs. While it may occur in an initiatory phase
(deoxy.org...),
SC: Regardless of WHERE/WHEN it occurs, it remains an indisputable fact that the ‘dismemberment experience’ DOES occur and the initiate is
‘reassembled’ in this altered state of consciousness – paralleling very well the 'myth' of Osiris.
|Byrd: ….only a very inept shaman would let himself be attacked or harmed while journeying elsewhere.
SC: It is my understanding that the dismemberment experience is essential to the 'journey' through the netherworld, a place full of all manner of
obstacles, demons, fires and other obstructions such as described in the AE
'Book of What is in the Duat'. Only when the shaman has been
'reassembled' is s/he 'born again' and equipped with the wherewithal to deal with the ordeal of traversing the extremely tricky and often
dangerous 'spirit realm' – in short, to overcome what is in the Duat. This is to say that without this 'rebirth' it is not possible for the
Shaman to make the journey into the netherworld. And by bringing forth such knowledge and awareness into this realm – to the King – can the King
then properly prepare himself for his own perilous journey into the Duat upon death. And because the shaman went before and brought back the
essential knowledge – spells, passwords and so forth – can the King feel confident in this life of reaching the Afterlife.
Byrd: The Inuit shaman often sees him (or her)self as a skeleton: en.wikipedia.org...
SC: Indeed – hence why the bones must be reassembled. Anthropologist, Felicitas Goodman, has studied the various ecstatic body postures of Shamans
from present hunter-gatherer cultures around the world and notes that:
”The very precise angle [37*] was a hallmark of spirit-journey postures performed by hunters [like the birdman of Lascaux], especially for
journeying to the sky world... This same posture turned up twelve thousand years later in Egypt in a drawing of Osiris [who] underwent a typical
shamanic initiation in which his body was dismembered and the reassembled by his sister [consort] before he made his spirit journey to the Upper
World”
Even although the 'Birdman' is obviously dead (charged down by the bison) and Osiris is dead (mummified) both, nevertheless, clearly display
prominent erections. Such an ithyphallic state is frequently experienced by shamans entering the trance state. Felicitas Goodman concludes:
”Osiris was a shaman... the figure [above] seems to point to the fact that shamanism in this form once predominated the Mediterranean, from
southern France all the way to Egypt. What is remarkable is that these elements were preserved in northern Africa over such an enormous time span
[12,000 years], especially in light of the fact that we are dealing with two different cultural types. The shaman of Lascaux was without doubt a
hunter, like everyone during that period. Osiris, on the other hand, changed into a god of the much more recent agriculturalists on the Nile without,
however, losing his original character. Nor indeed did the Egyptians lose the knowledge about the correct posture, expecially about the proper angle
of ascending to the sky world.”
Continued....