It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by memarf1
Yes, I would say that the constitution wasn't flawed but over time the language has become obsolete. The language is important because now the rock seems to have softened and lawyers and attorneys argue and manipulate it's meaning.
We need a meeting of the minds, we need to rewrite the constitution in the language of today making sure to make it immovable and understandable.
The new one needs to take into account new technology, new language, and new rights that our founders could never have imagined may exist, for example our right to an unadulterated internet.
Remember, the constitution provides for just such a meeting and rewrite, it not only provides it but we were at some point in our history encouraged to use that right.
Our current leaders are corrupt, but I argue that they too are victims of a corrupt system that forced otherwise ideological people with an intent to fix or change for the better and corrupted them. Very few start off corrupt, but I have heard it argued that after 1, or maybe for the stronger leaders 2, term in office they too are corrupted. They are not corrupted by their own mind, but by the system itself. The corruption of the game leads to the corruption of the players.
Yes, it is flawed, lets meet, lets exercise our constitutionally guaranteed rights, and lets fix it!
A MEETING OF THE MINDS 2009 OR 2010! BEFORE THINGS GET BLOODY!
Remember, even the most immovable stones erode with nothing more than time.
[edit on 1-10-2009 by memarf1]
We need a meeting of the minds, we need to rewrite the constitution in the language of today making sure to make it immovable and understandable.
Originally posted by STChas
reply to post by get ready already
To presume to be able to rewrite for clarity – or for any other reason – one of the two best examples of English prose ever written is cheeky at best. The only reason to wish a rewriting of the Constitution is to change its “negative liberties” (strict limits on governmental intrusion into the lives of Americans) into positive license for governmental intrusion, this is the hidden agenda of most who call for its revision.
The Constitution is not a ‘living’ document (A liberal’s wet dream), nor does it need to be revised, it needs to be STRICTLY adhered to without liberal perversion of its articles to include whatever politically correct ‘right’ or ‘limit’ some Columbia Law graduate thinks it should include. Applied at face value pre 16th Amendment, the Constitution would function exactly as it was designed.
The Constitution has been the victim of the Supreme Court and many, many interpretations. As such, it has lost its "plain language" quality that it had when it was written.
Originally posted by SGTChas
reply to post by getreadyalready
To presume to be able to rewrite for clarity – or for any other reason – one of the two best examples of English prose ever written is cheeky at best. The only reason to wish a rewriting of the Constitution is to change its “negative liberties” (strict limits on governmental intrusion into the lives of Americans) into positive license for governmental intrusion, this is the hidden agenda of most who call for its revision.
The Constitution is not a ‘living’ document (A liberal’s wet dream), nor does it need to be revised, it needs to be STRICTLY adhered to without liberal perversion of its articles to include whatever politically correct ‘right’ or ‘limit’ some Columbia Law graduate thinks it should include. Applied at face value pre 16th Amendment, the Constitution would function exactly as it was designed.
"We do therefore, in the name and behalf
of all the true SONS of LIBERTY in America,
Great Britain, Corsica, Ireland or wheresoever
they are dispersed throughout the world, dedicate
and solemnly devote this tree to be a
TREE of LIBERTY.----
May all our councils and deliberations
under its venerable branches be guided by wisdome,
and directed to the support and maintenance of that liberty,
which our forefathers sought out and found
under trees and and in the wilderness.
---May it long flourish, and may the SONS of LIBERTY
often repair hither, to confirm and strengthen each other.
--When they look towards the sacred ELM,
may they be penetrated with a sense of duty to themselves,
their country, and their posterity:
--And may they, like the house of David,
grow stronger and stronger,
while their enemies, like the house of Saul,
grow weaker and weaker. AMEN
To presume to be able to rewrite for clarity – or for any other reason – one of the two best examples of English prose ever written is cheeky at best.