No such thing as............., page 2
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 24-2-2003 @ 09:52 AM by MidnightDStroyer
Originally posted by Truth2 Timothy 3:16
"" (all) scripture, inspired of god, is profitable to teach, to instruct in justice ""
what you have just said is like saying this...
God put his commands in a athiest book.
your saying the commands in the book are ok but the rest is not.
truly hypocritical and insane at best.

You really *do* have a knack for misinterpreting nearly *everything* someone says, don't you?

The point is that:
1) God is perfect, men are not.
2) Anything made by men is subject to mistakes & misunderstanding when translated or communicated from one person to another. It's commonly known as the normal factor of "human error"...People make mistakes occasionally...There's nothing shameful about this fact, because it's a natural factor of human beings.
Which leads to the *real* point:
God's Commandments are His perfect instructions for humankind but anything written by men can *not* be taken as being perfect, even if done under inspiration *becase* of the "human error" factor. Therefore the reader of mens' writings must always be able to account for a certain "margin of error" or the chance of "misinterpretation" being inserted by the author, most likely inserted unintentionally. God is the *only* author whose writings will *not* contain that natural factor of human error.
Since only God is perfect, only God's writings are not subject to the "human error" factor, therefore *only* the Commandments He wrote with His own Hand are perfect. Everything written by human beings is subject to human error.

For example, there are quite a few passages in the Bible that seem to speak of alien encounters (Ezekeil, being one notable example)...But since the authors had no concept or liguistic terminolgy to properly *describe* what they saw, they wrote it in the terms that they understood *at their time*. More modern day interpretations of those passages *does* contain the terminolgy to describe what the original author had written...But even then, the modern interpretations could be just as mistaken about the actual *truth* as the original author was when he wrote it...The human author couldn't properly describe what he saw & modern people can't properly interpret what he wrote.
...That's just *one* example of how the "human error" haunts us at all times & places...


[Edited on 24-2-2003 by MidnightDStroyer]


reply posted on 26-2-2003 @ 12:47 PM by arc
truth

the bible was not written by God - it was written by men. Lots and lots of men over a long period of time. All writing about different events and different ideas of God from the view point of their own time and place.

Humans who can misinterpret messages, be influenced by their own prejudices and ideals.

If the bible was not a combination of all these things, a mixture of politics, fragments of beliefs and a history of the jewish nation; but in fact written purely by Jesus, then I might take what it says a little more as proof. A bit like the Quran - which was written by Mohammed only.

Moses lived hundreds of years before Jesus - how can Jesus have given the commandments to Moses? From what I have read of the bible - the God that Moses followed and the God that Jesus taught of are not only two different Gods, but actually conflict each other in their views.

I'm not sure if you read the bible and believe it word for word, or whether you have a bit more intelligence and read between the lines. Maybe applying some knowledge of how it was written and the circumstances of the Jewish people at each period in time might aid your understanding of a truly great book.

And dare I say it but remember Moses and Jesus didn't have much interest in the world in a global sense - their world was that of the Jewish people in the middle east at that particular time. And when Heaven was mentioned it was as a living state - the idealised society the people strived for. It's truly shocking how much words and meanings can be twisted to justify almost any point of view


reply posted on 26-2-2003 @ 02:21 PM by MidnightDStroyer
Originally posted by Truth Moses (successors) carried on the word of god through moses speaking to god.

Have you ever played the "Telephone Game"? Anywhere between God's mouth (so to speak) to the actual authors that wrote the scriptures is *also* subject to misinterpretation & human error. The only way to completely eliminate the possibility of such errors is for God's spoken words to be turned directly into written words...Only the Ten Commandments does that and that's only because God Himself inscribed them.

Originally posted by Truth God can not let error slip into his book, his only book he gave through the writings of the prophets.

Error *has* slipped into the scriptures because they were written by *men*...Otherwise, why are there so many "translations" & "revisions" of it in existence? God didn't write the Bible like He did the Commandments...*Men* wrote the Bible. As such, the Bible is subject to individual interpretation & the beliefs & biases of those who wrote it.

The evidence of human error is & always has been right in front of your eyes, but you still refuse to even acknowledge the possibility of human error popping into the various religions & their scriptures. In your view, one particular religion organized by man is the only one that does *not* have any errors in it but still keep pointing out the errors in others...What makes *your* religion to be the only one *without* error?
God is perfect...Man & religion is not. All of the religions known these days contains *some* truth, but it's hiding behind the cumulative errors & falsities introduced by human failures. The real trick is to find out what truths *are* there & to reason out the falicies...Unfortunately, you don't seem to be able to be capable of looking at your own religion with as much forethought & reason as you do all the other religions.

If you can't be capable of questioning God, then how can He teach you any true wisdom? Questions must be asked if a person is to receive any answers. If you can't put a question to anything, then truly you can learn nothing. If there's no questions, then there's no understanding.

Originally posted by Truth God wrote the commands, god also inspired the bible to be writen. If its not the work of god why would he allow his commands to be in it?

Take this as an analogy: Let's say that you teach a dog to do two tricks...You *tell* him how to do those tricks & he learns them both to your own satisfaction. But you run into a problem...The dog *does* the both tricks perfectly every time you tell him to perform them. But he keeps teaching other dogs to do the second trick wrong!

Here's the connection: God taught us what to do, between His own Words & with His own Son...But the various emotions & reasoning powers of different people have caused the religions to go astray of what God taught us. The trick we did *right* was to copy the Word of God as He inscribed them on the tablets with no interpretation (only the translations from one language to another and even *that* alone may be open to interpretation by the translators themselves)...Everything else has been messed up due to individual impressions of various people, based upon the other "tricks" that God taught other people to do* & that they told us about.


reply posted on 27-2-2003 @ 03:59 AM by Truth
"" do you think we got him thinking ""

ar, there are things ive witnessed that makes my faith very strong, and your points are
not even seeping into my head.

before i got this internet i thought like MD, through miracles iive learned this, and you will never believe me because
god has allowed you not to see this.


I will (never) deny the church of god or jesus. youll understand at the deathbed when you see my life in review then youll know why i have
this faith.


1. God wrote the bible through the prophets. you claim otherwise but i know that he did this.

2. Jesus wrote the commands. Moses spoke of jesus, the prophets spoke of the christ who will die for the sins of his people in daniel, isaiah, ect..


jesus existed before the world began, he says so in the nt many times.

I am studying scripture very hard, and do not see a difference between jesus and the god of the ot. infact jesus said i did not come
to erase the old law but to fullfill it.

believe what you want, but dont sit here and tell me who wrote scripture and who god is.


these words on this screen are mere words to me, ive seen stuff i cannot explain, man did not reveal this to me...


"" For flesh and blood did not reveal this to you but my father in heaven did ""


same goes with me, before i had this internet filled with falsehood of all kinds
what revealed this to me is something youll only see at the seat. and until then youll deny what im saying because
you haave been taught by men on a computer.


watch this year very closely, watch for miracles.

what im writing on here i dont just believe but i (know) to be true and i cannot deny this even
if i (wanted) to.


Ill hold this view until i (die) nomatter what i hear from men, because what revealed this to me was not the words of men but
stuff you just havent seen in my life.


peace and love.
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>    ^^TOP^^



"God is an Imaginary Friend" Athiest Billboards in Denver-
  Posted 17 days ago with 31 member flags
Why are these 10 figures just like Jesus Christ??
  Posted 4 days ago with 14 member flags
I am an imposter in Church
  Posted 3 days ago with 11 member flags
Christians Waking Up? Voluntary \'De-Baptism\' Rising in Europe
  Posted 18 days ago with 7 member flags
What Kind of Christianity Is This?
  Posted 15 days ago with 7 member flags
The Great Flood Was Caused By A Comet?
  Posted 10 days ago with 7 member flags
Advert claiming cure through prayer is banned
  Posted 4 days ago with 7 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Alien Grey caught in photo ?
  Aliens and UFOs, Posted 7 hours ago, 58 replies
Pass Me My Rifle
  World War Three, Posted 12 hours ago, 54 replies
Santorum wants more fracking!!!
  US Political Madness, Posted 16 hours ago, 53 replies