Originally posted by articulus
Thanks for your answer, and thanks to KSigMason as well. I should clarify that I didn't believe that Peale is a "spiritual" successor (for lack of
a better phrase) to Pike, but I wondered whether the title and position in question were more likely to be occupied by someone with an established
body of Masonic literature, or whether it was, as you say, more of an administrative/managerial thing.
I would say administrative/managerial. Brother seale is in charge of the day-to-day administration of the Supreme Council. But obviously, Pike's
shoes are big ones to fill.
Henry C. Clausen sat in the Chair of Albert Pike for over a quarter of a century. As Grand Commander, he wrote and published many books on Masonry.
None of which, in my opinion, even remotely touch Pike, and often showing a lack of understanding on esoteric subjects, especially Magick, which
Clausen called "a pious fraud" (whereas Pike considered it important symbolically in Freemasonry).
Following on from that, is there anyone within Masonry today who is or might be looked at as a "modern Pike" from an
academic/literary/esoteric standpoint? My impression is that there is not currently such a figure, but I may be distracted by all of the attention and
credit that Pike is given.
I would say no. Some point to Manly P. Hall (now deceased), but with the exception of "Lost Keys of Freemasonry", I've never been particularly
impressed. Paul Foster Case was great, but his writings focused more on Hermeticism that Freemasonry per se.
Chris Hodapp gets a lot of attention, but his writings are basically worthless IMO. In his "Freemasonry For Dummies" he mentions Pike, Mackey,
Yarker, then says "they wrote a lot of crap". But anyone wishing to really read a lot of crap need only crack open Hodapp's book.
Rex Hutchens is probably the modern author closest to the spirit of Pike. His brilliant book "A Bridge To Light" is now given as a gift to all new
members of the Scottish Rite in the Mother Jurisdiction. His "Pillars of Wisdom" is also very good.