Japan doing 180 on US, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 8 times
Topic started on 11-9-2009 @ 11:46 AM by TheCoffinman
www.telegraph.co.uk...

Yukio Hatoyama, the leader of the Democratic Party of Japan, has caused alarm in Washington after publishing an article blaming the US for the ills of capitalism, the global economy and "the destruction of human dignity".

He also intends to examine an agreement that permits US warships to dock at Japanese ports, in violation of the nation's non-nuclear principles. Mr Hatoyama says he will also look again at the $6 billion cost faced by Japan to transfer thousands of US troops from their base in Okinawa to the Pacific island of Guam amid a wide-ranging review of the American military presence on Japanese soil.


whoa... whats up with this. if i were japanese id be all for it. i wonder what will come of this? what do you think?



mod edit, to add external quote code

[edit on 11-9-2009 by DontTreadOnMe]


reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 12:42 PM by mpriebe81
reply to post by Kram09



I couldn't agree with you more Kram!
It's pretty pathetic that, 60 years after WWII, some people tend to think
that Japan should still sit idly by and let the US call the shots in their own country.

"We bombed them back to the stone age" ....hmmm. And then we apparently turned them into a superpower because we helped rebuild what we had just obliterated. Interesting....so the Japanese people apparently played no part in becoming the nation that it is today? Quite the theory there.

Meanwhile, Japan is the 2nd largest holder of US debt.
They kinda got a trump card there, might want to rethink that brilliant theory of yours.


reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 12:55 PM by niteboy82
The following is my opinion as a member participating in this discussion.

reply to
post by burdman30ott6



After the new Prime Minsiter has considered this, I'm sure our nation will be willing to accept his appology for sticking his foot in his mouth, provided he offers it with a satisfactory amount of contriteness and supplication.


After reading that, I have absolutely zero sympathy left for the United States and its received hatred by any portion of this world.

How dare we as Americans even treat countries like this and how in the world have we become so arrogant? I am thoroughly disgusted beyond belief.

I fully support the actions of the Japanese Prime Minister in his commitment to his country that he represents instead of remaining under the thumb of imperialistic America.



As an ATS Staff Member, I will not moderate in threads such as this where I have participated as a member.



reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 12:55 PM by fraterormus
Let's not forget the anger the Russians still have towards the Nihonese/Japanese for atrocities committed against them by an Imperialistic Japan not that long ago.

However, in all fairness, the United States has a more severe Trade Embargo against Nihon/Japan than we do any other nation in the world. Free Market/Open Market my duck-billed platypus! Nihon/Japan has played nice and even stopped exporting to the US long before limits were reached, just to let US Companies catch up, and to ensure that the US didn't get all uppity and even more economically protectionist and impose tighter restrictions on Trade.

On top of it, Nihon/Japan does have a strict prohibition against Nuclear Arms. We should be respectful of the duly elected laws of other democratic Nations. When in Rome...and all that sticky jazz. If we can't respect the democratic process of another democratic Nation, then the US really doesn't have a leg to stand on!

We did rebuild their Infrastructure after WWII, but that doesn't mean they must forever be obedient and subservient to the United States. They are an independent Sovereign Nation, not a US Protectorate. We shouldn't be treating them as our lapdog and need to remember that they aren't the 51st State of the Union. We can't tell them what to do and we need to respect the decisions they democratically decide for themselves.

If they say "When we passed a law stating No Nukes in Nihon/Japan, that meant Period! End of Story! So take your Nuclear Armed Vessels elsewhere American Scum!" then so be it. That is entirely their prerogative.

As far as the comment about the US being responsible for "the destruction of human dignity" well, the US does partially have to own up to that as the US government was responsible (and still is) for severe Human Rights Violations while defecating on every Treaty we have signed since Versaille. However, I can't help but respond "Have you seen Nihonese/Japanese Television lately?" Seriously, I think saying that the US is responsible for the destruction of human dignity is the pot calling the kettle black. Nihonese/Japanese Television does a good enough job at destroying human dignity! (And you thought Fox TV was bad!)


reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 01:19 PM by pluckynoonez
reply to post by TheCoffinman



I think you didn't quote material that wasn't, clearly, your words.

Yukio Hatoyama, the leader of the Democratic Party of Japan, has caused alarm in Washington after publishing an article blaming the US for the ills of capitalism, the global economy and "the destruction of human dignity". He also intends to examine an agreement that permits US warships to dock at Japanese ports, in violation of the nation's non-nuclear principles. Mr Hatoyama says he will also look again at the $6 billion cost faced by Japan to transfer thousands of US troops from their base in Okinawa to the Pacific island of Guam amid a wide-ranging review of the American military presence on Japanese soil.




reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 01:26 PM by vor78
reply to post by TheCoffinman



It seems to me that they should be pretty happy with the deal they have. Japan has the second largest economy in the world and its people enjoy a standard of living that compares favorably to those in any other country.

Under the circumstances, I think they have little to complain about. Few nations throughout history have been nearly as fortunate in the aftermath of a total military defeat as the Japanese and Germans have been. Their freedom today didn't come without a few strings attached, but that's a small price that they have paid for their efforts in instigating a world war.

That said, if they wish to end many of their ties to the United States, so be it. They can deal with the still-angry 800lb gorilla to their west all by themselves.


reply posted on 11-9-2009 @ 01:28 PM by mpriebe81
reply to post by Doc Velocity



That's a cute little phrase there, "Japanese apologist".
On the contrary though, I agree that the Japanese deserved what they got in WWII, and hundreds of thousands(mostly Japanese) would likely have died if the US had kept island hopping towards the Japanese mainland instead of dropping the bomb.

However, to insinuate that the US is solely responsible for what Japan has become is ridiculous and completely inaccurate. I understand that we helped rebuild their infrastructure and gave them a leg up so to speak, but the Japanese took the opportunity and ran with it, and kudos to them for what they have evolved into.

I noticed that you didn't even bother to posit a reply to my main point, which is that Japan is the 2nd largest holder of US debt at the moment. It's kind of a big deal, no? If they turned around and dumped it all we would be in an even worse economic situation than we currently are. Perhaps we would better serve ourselves AND the Japanese by letting them do what they want, sovereign nation that they are.

You can make references to past Japanese brutalities all you want, every nation on the planet has spilled blood at one point or another. By no means am I attempting to minimize what Japan has done in the past. However, if we're going to talk brutality on a mass scale, we shouldn't forget to add the US, Israel, the UK, Russia, Zimbabwe, Borneo, China, etc etc etc to the list.
No one nation is blameless.
BUT we are in the here and now, and Japan should probably be the least of our concerns. Let them do as they will IMHO.
Pages: <<  1    2  >>    ^^TOP^^