Originally posted by HunkaHunka
reply to post by whaaa
Until everyone over 50 today dies off, this will continue.
I disagree. There are many people over 50 today who strongly object to torture, and I know quite a few. Just because seniors are somewhat more
likely to be Republicans doesn't make all of us monsters. I am surprised at you. You're not usually so extreme in your judgments.
What older people do remember, though, are World War II, Korea, and Vietnam as well as 9/11 and Iraq and Afghanistan.
Throughout the 20th century there have been many, many Americans tortured by foreign governments who used techniques that would make Guantanamo look
like kindergarten. Many of them never made it back. There are still a lot of countries that don't blink at torturing now.
That doesn't make it ok for America to do the same. As Gandhi said, "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind."
But that doesn't change the fact that war is horrible at its best, and people do unconscionable things in wartime. Nothing can make it pretty or
clean. America has its hands dirty as do all combatants in a war.
It has been established that Cheney & Co. crossed the line on the matter of torture and there should be repercussions.
But rightly or wrongly some people believe you have to fight fire with fire, and they have wartime experiences to back up that belief.