reply to post by Cecilofs
I hear what you are saying. All of the pathogens can be controlled in a methodical application of composting discipline.
The problem I have is the "methodical" and "discipline" parts. I worked on ranches where we raised horses, and composted the excrement. But if
you have a lot of practice with composting animal crap, you know that there is a great degree of variability in each pile. Weather conditions,
stomach contents, etc, mean that each pile needs to be worked differently. And when you make a mistake with grazers, the problem is simply having
some poo that needs to be composted all over again.
But with omnivores, it is far more complicated, and the poo is much more variable. I have experience with pigs. Pig poo is the most difficult
livestock poo to deal with, because it has such a high concentration of nitrogen (horse hit is a distant second). Nitrogen will kill the composting
organisms, and worse (as has been learnt in industrial pig operations) can leach into to the groundwater. My understanding is that human poop, even
under the best conditions, is almost as bad as pig, and takes 2 YEARS of composting to fully transform. That means that it will be twice as expensive
as fertilizer, as any livestock poop.
You can probably do it on a personal scale, with an individual who is a true believer. But the idea of even getting a whole village to compost their
crap safely and completely, is not believeable to me.
Have you ever used a latrine with a group of other people for a week or more? I got back recently from a hunting trip with 5 others, and we had to
move the latrine every third day. And we had a nice seat and everything. But your composting will be as weak as the weakest member of your team.
Hep C may not seem like a real threat, but what about dysentery?