It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Bombeni
In fact at one point, I had a flashback and thought of some "conversations" I have had with certain people here at ATS;
Originally posted by FlyersFan
Sounds INTERESTING! I also am under the impression that you have to accept the evil in order to be possessed. Perhaps not?
Originally posted by Bombeni
In fact at one point, I had a flashback and thought of some "conversations" I have had with certain people here at ATS;
You mean that the people were saying the same as what the (alleged) demon was saying in the book? They thought they were channeling something good but it was really something evil???
September 4, 2000
By Schmerguls "schmerguls" (Sioux City, Ia USA) -
(TOP 1000 REVIEWER) This book is not well-written, is not carefully researched, and yet I give it five stars because of the subject which it discusses. The exorcism which occurred at Earling, Iowa, has been a subject of interest to me all my life. This book expands on the pamphlet Begone Satan, which was first published about 1936 and attracted extreme interest. Time had a full page article about the pamphlet. The pamphlet itself is not carefully written, and so this book, which sensationalizes what is found in Begone Satan and supplies all the X-rated language which Begone Satan omitted, is not to be relied on as being totally factual. A small example of the looseness with research in this book is that it states Sept. 20, 1928, when the first series of exorcisms came to an end, was a Friday. I at once knew this was wrong, since I was baptized by Father Steiger on Sept 20, 1928 (I was two days old) and I knew--and any perpetual calendar will quickly tell--that Sept. 20, 1928, was a Thursday. There are other inaccuracies, and much of the early part of the book is as the author imagined the events probably happened. But the fact is that a series of exorcisms were carried out at Earling in 1928, and the devil manifested himself there in ways that seem fantastic but that are not explainable unless he exists. This may not be a very fashionable view, but of course the devil's greatest wish is that people believe he not exist. The book is an easy read, and introduces one to a fascinating event. The sad part is that there is no really scholarly study of the case available to the public.
A Very Unsettling Story, March 7, 2003
By A Customer
I read this book a couple months ago and it still haunts me. Although parts of this book may have been sensationalized for readability, for the most part I believe it is factual.
Originally posted by Wertdagf
Lol do you think this sort of stuff would happen less if the books that were written about them sold less?
To bad this stuff doesnt actualy exist. stuff like this and magic gave simple ignorant people a hope that they could some day gain power. Its all a path we must walk in our own time. good luck.
Originally posted by eradown
I read the book years ago. I have no idea how the writer was able to obtain so many intimate details about the father. The father was not the sort who would have kept a diary or confided in others. The daughter was too confused to have remembered many details about the father. The Catholic church would have carefully recorded the exorcism of course. I have a feeling the true of the family must have been more awful than the writer could relay. Most of the children of trashy drunks do not need exorcisms.
Originally posted by Bombeni
Originally posted by eradown
I read the book years ago. I have no idea how the writer was able to obtain so many intimate details about the father. The father was not the sort who would have kept a diary or confided in others. The daughter was too confused to have remembered many details about the father. The Catholic church would have carefully recorded the exorcism of course. I have a feeling the true of the family must have been more awful than the writer could relay. Most of the children of trashy drunks do not need exorcisms.
Actually the daughter was quite lucid during many periods of her life and would have been able to relay the many things that happened in her childhood. When she wasn't under obvious possession she was like anyone else, and they say she was very intelligent and honest.
Originally posted by Wertdagf
Lol do you think this sort of stuff would happen less if the books that were written about them sold less?
Originally posted by eradown
demons are fond of distraction.
Originally posted by eradown
reply to post by Bombeni
I was thinking the Catholic church does have the ability to find out a great deal of information up to a point. Still they would need someone who was sharp enough to separate gossip from truth. The book implies the father's family fell apart after they came to America ,but all too often demons are connected to families via multi generational grudge curses. The bad luck they experienced in America might have been tied to why they left Germany in the first place. I could see why the Catholic church washed their hands of that mess ,but the Catholic church would have known about the paranormal history of those Germans. There might be room for another interesting book dealing with this exorcism if it turns out the pocession was a continuation of multi generational curse of some sort.
[edit on 17-8-2009 by eradown]