It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by tauristercus
I'm sorry to say this but you're trying to argue your point against time travel but apparently don't have the foggiest notion of what Einstein, Lorentz and others have determined regarding the relatavistic effects that kick in when an object reaches significant speeds comparable to light speed.
If you did have at least some basic knowledge of these effects, you would have known why your Nascar example was flawed as a denunciation of time dilation as a result of velocity.
Instead of relying on "common sense" as you put it, try doing a bit of basis research on what actually DOES happen under extreme velocities and how it affects the flow of time.
How can speed change time. Speed will only determine how far you will get with that speed within time.
If light travels at 300 000 km a second. That means light will travel from 0 to 300 000 km in 1 second. And to get back it would have to use 1 second.
Because it would have to travel from 300 000 km and back to 0 (start).
If you think that was a hard equation. Try it with to different sources of speeds.
1. That travels with 150 000 km a second.
2. That travels with 300 000 km a second.
See if they don't come back at exactly the same time lol.
And if you like a challenge try it with communication. Where they communicate with each other and Earth.
I bet even then they all would have the same time when they get back home.
Originally posted by spy66
Ok lets do it the hard way.
Ship A:
Ship A travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds.
Ship B:
Ship B travels at 150 000 km in 1 seconds.
The timer is on Earth. The rules are that each ship is going to stop at 1 Earth second.
That means that ship (A) must travel for 1 second on his timer. If he knows that he travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds he cant stop. That would be cheating.
Why?
Well he has only traveled for 0.00025 seconds
Do i need to go on?
[edit on 27.06.08 by spy66]
Originally posted by tauristercus
Originally posted by spy66
Ok lets do it the hard way.
Ship A:
Ship A travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds.
Ship B:
Ship B travels at 150 000 km in 1 seconds.
The timer is on Earth. The rules are that each ship is going to stop at 1 Earth second.
That means that ship (A) must travel for 1 second on his timer. If he knows that he travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds he cant stop. That would be cheating.
Why?
Well he has only traveled for 0.00025 seconds
Do i need to go on?
[edit on 27.06.08 by spy66]
Errrrr, I'm lost now ... what is it you're trying to say ?
Are you saying that ship A MUST travel for the equivalent of 1 second on the ships clock ?
If so, then ship A will have travelled 1,200,000,000 kms (1.2 billion kms) by the time his ship clock has ticked off 1 second ... but in the meantime, 4000 seconds (66.7 mins) will have gone by on Earth.
Are you still NOT getting this concept of time dilation ?
Originally posted by spy66
Originally posted by tauristercus
Originally posted by spy66
Ok lets do it the hard way.
Ship A:
Ship A travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds.
Ship B:
Ship B travels at 150 000 km in 1 seconds.
The timer is on Earth. The rules are that each ship is going to stop at 1 Earth second.
That means that ship (A) must travel for 1 second on his timer. If he knows that he travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds he cant stop. That would be cheating.
Why?
Well he has only traveled for 0.00025 seconds
Do i need to go on?
[edit on 27.06.08 by spy66]
Errrrr, I'm lost now ... what is it you're trying to say ?
Are you saying that ship A MUST travel for the equivalent of 1 second on the ships clock ?
If so, then ship A will have travelled 1,200,000,000 kms (1.2 billion kms) by the time his ship clock has ticked off 1 second ... but in the meantime, 4000 seconds (66.7 mins) will have gone by on Earth.
Are you still NOT getting this concept of time dilation ?
No.
If the ship stops after 1 earth second. He might be very very far away. But that is the clue with speed. You get very far away fast. But dont confuse the distance with time.
What does 0.00025 seconds mean?
Well it means 0.00025 of 1 second. 1 Earth second.
Right?
No i dont confuse the concept of dilation.
What this means is: If something gets pushed to the speed of light it will get compressed by the engine. It wont expand.
But if something travels at the speed of light nothing would happen. You just travel at the speed of light.
Originally posted by tauristercus
Originally posted by spy66
Ok lets do it the hard way.
Ship A:
Ship A travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds.
Ship B:
Ship B travels at 150 000 km in 1 seconds.
The timer is on Earth. The rules are that each ship is going to stop at 1 Earth second.
That means that ship (A) must travel for 1 second on his timer. If he knows that he travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds he cant stop. That would be cheating.
Why?
Well he has only traveled for 0.00025 seconds
Do i need to go on?
[edit on 27.06.08 by spy66]
Errrrr, I'm lost now ... what is it you're trying to say ?
Are you saying that ship A MUST travel for the equivalent of 1 second on the ships clock ?
If so, then ship A will have travelled 1,200,000,000 kms (1.2 billion kms) by the time his ship clock has ticked off 1 second ... but in the meantime, 4000 seconds (66.7 mins) will have gone by on Earth.
Are you still NOT getting this concept of time dilation ?
Originally posted by tauristercus
Originally posted by spy66
Originally posted by tauristercus
Originally posted by spy66
Ok lets do it the hard way.
Ship A:
Ship A travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds.
Ship B:
Ship B travels at 150 000 km in 1 seconds.
The timer is on Earth. The rules are that each ship is going to stop at 1 Earth second.
That means that ship (A) must travel for 1 second on his timer. If he knows that he travels 300 000 km in 0.00025 seconds he cant stop. That would be cheating.
Why?
Well he has only traveled for 0.00025 seconds
Do i need to go on?
[edit on 27.06.08 by spy66]
Errrrr, I'm lost now ... what is it you're trying to say ?
Are you saying that ship A MUST travel for the equivalent of 1 second on the ships clock ?
If so, then ship A will have travelled 1,200,000,000 kms (1.2 billion kms) by the time his ship clock has ticked off 1 second ... but in the meantime, 4000 seconds (66.7 mins) will have gone by on Earth.
Are you still NOT getting this concept of time dilation ?
No.
If the ship stops after 1 earth second. He might be very very far away. But that is the clue with speed. You get very far away fast. But dont confuse the distance with time.
What does 0.00025 seconds mean?
Well it means 0.00025 of 1 second. 1 Earth second.
Right?
Whilst travelling at (almost) the speed of light, 0.00025 seconds is the amount of time that passes onboard the ship FOR EVERY second that passes on Earth ... time SLOWS DOWN CONSIDERABLY for those onboard.
No i dont confuse the concept of dilation.
What this means is: If something gets pushed to the speed of light it will get compressed by the engine. It wont expand.
NO, NO, NO !!!!!
The engine does NOT compress the ship at all ... the apparent length of the ship as MEASURED BY THOSE ON EARTH appears to contract (shrink) ... but those onboard don't notice anything different ... life goes on as normal for them.
Time dilation AND length contraction are BOTH consequences of travelling at relatavistic (near light) speeds.
But if something travels at the speed of light nothing would happen. You just travel at the speed of light.
WRONG !!!
At (almost) light speed, time dilation/contraction plays a HUGE and SIGNIFICANT role.
Originally posted by readerone
live long at the speed of light .
Originally posted by RyanLA123
The moral of the story and today's science lesson is, what is time? What are you twisting or dillating to begin with? You have knowing to grasp on to or warp and twist. If someone were to travel in time forward or back, you would have to put everything in the universe in it's place exactly as it was at that time. EXAMPLE, well I have a time machine lets go back in time, but before I do I need to put this star system here, or that galaxy AND EVERYTHING IN IT THERE. Playing god is not possible. It's kicking over the anthill trying your hardest not to hurt anyone, but knowing the ants will rebuild their hill, hopefully better and with more common sense. Or, in plain words, slapping you over the head and saying what's wrong with you.