George Knapp Interviews UFO Whistle-Blower Colonel Philip Corso (ATS Exclusive), page 6
Pages: <<  3    4    5    6    7  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 116 times


reply posted on 14-8-2009 @ 09:41 AM by aliencatlady
reply to post by BO XIAN



I couldn't agree more! It's wise to try to debunk him, we wouldn't want to be dupes who swallow every story that comes along. But, there comes a point when pointing out inconsistencies is just nitpicking and leads to nowhere.

I, for one, believe him. I don't believe the recent Sanni Ceto post, however. He has far more credibility. I'm glad this interview has finally been posted online. I hope it leads to further revelations.


reply posted on 14-8-2009 @ 09:47 AM by lycopersicum
reply to post by lycopersicum

Did anyone not look at the picture i posted is it the same as antars ??

and the same one he metions with the dual lobes.

news.webshots.com...

dont know how to post just the picture but it is much higher res then antars look at it


reply posted on 14-8-2009 @ 11:52 AM by Pathos
Originally posted by spacevisitor
Pathos, I really wonder the following.
Why you on one hand posted all these remarks and those others in this thread in order to point everyone over and over again to the in your eyes lack of any solid evidence at all of what Col. Corso has said in that video while you self on the other hand started threads like these.

Dream Interpretation: Has Anyone Had This Dream Before?

reply to
post by Pathos



First Documented UFO Debunked

reply to post by Pathos



My comment is not towards you personally, but more towards your sayings in general. I do not mean any disrespect.

Sure.

(1) Dream Interpretation: Has Anyone Had This Dream Before?
Is a philosophical examination of personal exploration, which does not need facts to support any type of claim. Since I am not trying to prove anything to be real, I don't need facts to examine a philosophical issue. Dreams are a subjective experience, which can have many interpretations.

(2) First Documented UFO Debunked
When I opened this particular thread, I did present evidence that could be examined and measured. I gave everyone an aviation historical outline, and I also presented their counter parts found in UFO theology. I provided the picture of the sketch Kenneth drew, gave a link to the German Horton, presented dates, and also gave you three US military planes that can be looked up. I gave you stuff to examine.

Whats the difference between me and Mr. Corso's? I gave you stuff you can reference in a library, online, or in a military archive. Mr. Corso presented his audience with a story, which cannot be 100% verified by the public. You cannot go to a library or a viable source to research his claims. According to Mr. Corso's claims, no one kept record of what was going on in the 50s. So, how can he prove his case without evidence? You can't.

That's the difference.

------ EDIT

When I added that last line to my post, within this thread, I did so out of respect for Mr. Knapp.

[edit on 14-8-2009 by Pathos]



reply posted on 14-8-2009 @ 12:19 PM by antar
reply to post by lycopersicum



Yes it is the same. I believe it was given to Tom Dongo and he has the original. Now dont hold me to that I will have to verify it again. When I saw the original loads of info was being thrown at me very fast.


reply posted on 14-8-2009 @ 12:22 PM by antar
reply to post by SoulOrb



I have a photgraph of a live one standing behind a group of people in the background of the picture I posted on the first page of this thread.

It will accompany a new thread I am currently working on for ATS.


reply posted on 15-8-2009 @ 02:09 AM by MAC269
reply to post by mmiichael



Dear mmiichael

I have been wondering when we would here from you. For sure I was missing you.

Well there we have it yet another one. Naturally with no proof what so ever.

I find it interesting that a man with his caliber would out right lye about such a thing.

But then again the US air force did.


reply posted on 15-8-2009 @ 03:04 AM by mmiichael
Originally posted by MAC269
reply to
post by mmiichael



Dear mmiichael

I have been wondering when we would here from you. For sure I was missing you.

Well there we have it yet another one. Naturally with no proof what so ever.

I find it interesting that a man with his caliber would out right lye about such a thing.

But then again the US air force did.



H Mac,

Don't like to use the term liar, and Corso did have a co-author ghost writer named Birnes.

But sorry to be the bearer of bad news. Long time UFO writer researcher Brad Sparks went through the Corso book with a fine tooth comb and checked the accuracy of dates, names, events.

Conclusion - the Corso book is an unqualified fraud. Even the endorsement Corso managed to cajole out of Senator Strom Thurmond was withdrawn.

Linked to earlier in this thread but ignored, anyone with any interest in all this must read Sparks's deconstruction of Corso's fairy tale.

www.ufologie.net...

Bestselling Book Exposed as a Hoax!

By Brad C. Sparks

EXCLUSIVE EXPOSE! Colonel Philip Corso and William Birnes


The only thing "extraterrestrial" in Philip Corso's book "The Day After Roswell" (Pocket Books/Simon & Schuster, 1997), is the height of his tall tales, certainly the tallest Roswell tales to date. His thesis of course (for those of you blessed with not hearing this rubbish before) is that many of our high-tech advances such as microcircuits (and the transistor before IC's), lasers, fiber optics, microwave ovens, Star Wars SDI weapons, etc., all actually came from "reverse engineering" the alien technology found in the crashed UFO near Roswell, New Mexico, in July 1947 -- a feat largely made possible by Corso himself when he purportedly divvied up the alien goodies while working at Army R&D in the early 60's. But in his haste to cash in on Roswellmania he has made some fantastic blunders of history that completely expose him as a fraud in the most embarrassing way.

Corso just can't resist putting himself at the center stage of great events of history, courted by the big names such as Robert Kennedy and his "old friend" J. Edgar Hoover (Corso's "other book" is called "I Walked With Giants"), and he is ever the powerful hero. (pp. 2, 37, 84, 156, 191, 206-209, 255) But he trips on his way up the ladder to the stage. Corso has apparently made a cynical calculation that he'll be able to make his bundle and retreat before anyone can develop a sufficient publicity base to expose him, so there was no need to research his lies to get them perfect.

[...]

... last but not least Corso is the hero of the Planet Earth's desperate but successful "war" against the ETs (or EBE's, Extraterrestrial Biological Entities, the term he cribbed from the fraudulent MJ-12 documents) (pp. 5, 142, 249-250, 260, 269). This supposed war against UFOs led to Reagan and Gorbachev meeting and ending the Cold War (pp. 262-263, 266, 268). We had negotiated a "surrender" treaty with the aliens (were there alien negotiators in the State Dept. too?) until we were able to reverse engineer enough Roswell weapons to fight back (pp. 268, passim).

As Corso modestly boasts, "Sometimes, once in a very long while, you get the chance to save your country, your planet, and even your species at the same time." (p. 273) Corso gives whole new meaning to the term "delusions of grandeur."

Corso's notion that many of our high-tech innovations were really back-engineered from extraterrestrials is a new twist on the Ancient Astronauts theory. Instead of saying man was too stupid to invent pyramids or the wheel on his own and had to get the ideas from space visitors, Corso has updated the concept and says we got the microwave oven (p. 178) and laptop computers (pp. 170-173) from aliens. I guess all those millions of scientists and engineers we've cranked out over the years have largely been a waste -- they were dummies who had to get clued in by ET's.

Now that we've established that Corso fabricates entire screenplays and dialogues involving himself inside CIA headquarters and elsewhere that never happened and never could have happened, there really is no need to go into the rest of his confabulations about his heroic role in getting U.S. industry to "reverse engineer" microchips, fiber optics, lasers, Kevlar, etc., from his make-believe Roswell spacecraft. That would be chasing phantoms, trying to prove a negative -- that something doesn't exist -- which is inherently very difficult if not actually impossible. The dramatic stories that we can easily check prove Corso to be a rank literary hoaxer.



Mike






[edit on 15-8-2009 by mmiichael]
Pages: <<  3    4    5    6    7  >>    ^^TOP^^