It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by afoolbyanyothername
reply to post by jfj123
On the contrary, you are the one that is OVER simplifying what it actually may take to get a crop design off of a sheet of paper and onto a field of vision obscuring wheat.
A circle, square, triangle or other simple geometric design would probably be trivial to construct ... but we're not talking about trivial designs. We're seeing incredibly complex designs on a huge scale.
Lets start with basics ... a group of people walk into a field of mature chest high wheat in the middle of the night (ok, let them have flashlights) to start a design. Now, a question ... if you were in charge would you have everyone start work at a beginning point and work outwards ... or would you disperse your people and get them to start working on different segments of the design ?
If you have them initially disperse, how would you coordinate their work ... how would you make constant checks to see that EVERY one of them is adhering to the paper plan ?
How would you verify the accuracy and alignment of each individual segment so that they all met up perfectly ?
How would you even communicate with a group member who is working on a segment 100 metres away from you ?
This is almost like 2 tunnel boring teams on opposite sides of a mountain drilling a hole towards each other, working independently and still managing to meet up together dead centre.
Further, with members working independently and away from each other, how do they do the complex calculations required to create partial circles, various angles such as say, 38 degrees, 67 degrees, 42 degrees, etc when these angles are required to be made at that point of construction ?
How do they coordinate with each other ? Every segment of the construction HAS to be perfect for it to eventually line up with and meet the other segments to complete the design.
I'm sure I could come up with many more logistical nightmares
that they would have to contend with but the above points are more than sufficient to make it PERFECTLY clear to any logical and rational individual that a bunch of people working in a field from a design on a sheet of paper simply is NOT practical or feasible by any stretch of the imagination.
if they are not experts in ground surveying, don't have experience in night time construction, don't have some kind of efficient communication system, don't have continual and ongoing work reviews, etc, etc ... simply don't have a hope in hell of pulling it off.
And frankly, anyone that claims that a bunch of people using nothing more sophisticated than a rope and board can created these design monsters is purely and simply deluding themselves and needs to sit down and work out the logistics for themselves as if THEY were the group leader in charge of the design and anticipate EVERY potential problem and how YOU would overcome it.
Bet you can't do it .....
Originally posted by Gorman91
reply to post by jfj123
Nope. My logic is sound.
This is my method. No matter wat the black hole is or does, if it has an event horizon and an ergosphere, then what I want to do can work. This is the significant entity. Weather it puffes purple smoke or requires daily doses of ham is irrelevent. As long as it sucks up matter and light, affects time, and makes gravity valleys, then it's ok.
You have inspired me to make something.
Wish me luck.
[edit on 25-7-2009 by Gorman91]
Originally posted by jfj123
Originally posted by afoolbyanyothername
reply to post by jfj123
Yep but when you break it down, it's just a bunch of simple shapes. That's where you're getting confused. You're looking at the object as a whole but you should be looking at it as individual pieces.
It's like buildings a house. If you look at a skyscraper, it's seems impossible to build but that's not how it's looked at by the builders. It's look at in small chunks. Get one chunk done and move to the next. It's much more simple then you're making it out to be.
Yes, you can break down almost ANY complex pattern into smaller less detailed segments ... but where you've made a grave error in your assumption is that if you have multiple people working on different sections of the design e.g one is making a circle; another is marking out lines; another is making an angle ... the point is that EVERY part being worked on has to be laid out PERFECTLY in the wheat and in EXACTLY the position it needs to be so that when someone completes an adjacent section it joins your segment perfectly .. even the slightest error by you or him will magnify into a significant deviation by the time it comes to join your and his segments.
First, they could also use night vision goggles which would speed things up.
I wouldn't have a whole team. I'd probably pick 4 people. 2 people to work on the design and 2 spotters. Everyone with walkie talkies.
Night vision goggles aren't going to do you much good when you're standing in a field surrounded by chest high grass and your other team members are dispersed great distances throughout the field working on their part of the design AND also surrounded by chest high wheat.
A very impractical idea.
So you've mentioned gadgets such as every member has night vision goggles and walkie talkies ... so we're starting to see some significant out of personal pocket expense now being incurred by the group simply to tramp down some wheat in a pattern. Begins to seem like an expensive hobby to me !
The same way I would coordinate with people who were building a house for me.
So, tell me ... how many houses do you see being constructed at 3 in the morning and using NO electricity ? Must be a REALLY big house and covering 100's of square meters if it's comparable in size to some of these HUGE designs !
How would you verify the accuracy and alignment of each individual segment so that they all met up perfectly ?
Same as with a house.
Your house analogy is completely flawed and innapropriate.
A house is NOT constructed in the middle of the night in a field of wheat. The location where the house foundations are to be poured is usually cleared and levelled.
The same way I can have a dozen different guys building a house in different area's and have everything match up.
Again, you're arguing with a false analogy.
They're not nightmares for people who've done it a few times and have a basic understanding of the math involved.
Basic math knowledge is all that's required ? Really ??
So YOU would have NO trouble using a rope and some poles and create any EXACT desired angle ? 38 degrees ? 59 degrees ? how about 72 degrees ?
I know somewhat more than "basic" math and even I would have no end of difficulty determining the above angles in the daylight ... let alone in the dark of night ... but wait, I could always make use of my expensive night vision goggles !
that they would have to contend with but the above points are more than sufficient to make it PERFECTLY clear to any logical and rational individual that a bunch of people working in a field from a design on a sheet of paper simply is NOT practical or feasible by any stretch of the imagination.
It happens every day in the building industry. It's both feasible and practical.
You're right ... every DAY in the building industry.
If it's that easy, then why do we never see house construction going on in the middle of the night ?
Simple reason ... because it introduces too many extra variables that don't happen during the day.
Again ... flawed analogy.
Bet you can't do it .....
Sure I could. You could to with just a little training and a bit of common sense.
You're just deluding yourself.
Even constructing in a wheat field an extremely simple geometric shape such as a four sided object comprising 4 unequal length sides and 4 unequal interior angles would probably stump the vast majority of people ... and thats a VERY simple shape.
Originally posted by irishchic
I'm enjoying this thread for many reasons...
I will only add,and you can take it as you'd like that it's obvious few actually have spent TIME in a corn or wheat field,LOL!
I live surrounded on all sides by them and can assure you that navigating through them day or night can be a daunting experience.
It would NOT be a "30 minute job" no matter what or who was doing the creating.
Originally posted by afoolbyanyothername
Yes, you can break down almost ANY complex pattern into smaller less detailed segments ... but where you've made a grave error in your assumption is that if you have multiple people working on different sections of the design e.g one is making a circle; another is marking out lines; another is making an angle ... the point is that EVERY part being worked on has to be laid out PERFECTLY
in the wheat and in EXACTLY
the position it needs to be so that when someone completes an adjacent section it joins your segment perfectly ..
even the slightest error by you or him will magnify into a significant deviation by the time it comes to join your and his segments.
Night vision goggles aren't going to do you much good when you're standing in a field surrounded by chest high grass and your other team members are dispersed great distances throughout the field working on their part of the design AND also surrounded by chest high wheat.
A very impractical idea.
So you've mentioned gadgets such as every member has night vision goggles and walkie talkies ... so we're starting to see some significant out of personal pocket expense now being incurred by the group simply to tramp down some wheat in a pattern.
Begins to seem like an expensive hobby to me !
So, tell me ... how many houses do you see being constructed at 3 in the morning and using NO electricity ?
Must be a REALLY big house and covering 100's of square meters if it's comparable in size to some of these HUGE designs !
Your house analogy is completely flawed and innapropriate.
A house is NOT constructed in the middle of the night in a field of wheat. The location where the house foundations are to be poured is usually cleared and levelled.
The same way I can have a dozen different guys building a house in different area's and have everything match up.
again, you're arguing with a false analogy.
they're not nightmares for people who've done it a few times and have a basic understanding of the math involved.
Basic math knowledge is all that's required ? Really ??
So YOU would have NO trouble using a rope and some poles and create any EXACT desired angle ? 38 degrees ? 59 degrees ? how about 72 degrees ?
I know somewhat more than "basic" math and even I would have no end of difficulty determining the above angles in the daylight ... let alone in the dark of night ... but wait, I could always make use of my expensive night vision goggles !
It happens every day in the building industry. It's both feasible and practical.
You're right ... every DAY in the building industry.
If it's that easy, then why do we never see house construction going on in the middle of the night ?
Simple reason ... because it introduces too many extra variables that don't happen during the day.
Again ... flawed analogy.
You're just deluding yourself.
Even constructing in a wheat field an extremely simple geometric shape such as a four sided object comprising 4 unequal length sides and 4 unequal interior angles would probably stump the vast majority of people ... and thats a VERY simple shape.
So YOU would have NO trouble using a rope and some poles and create any EXACT desired angle ? 38 degrees ? 59 degrees ? how about 72 degrees ?
After laying it out on paper, it wouldn't be that hard.
Originally posted by afoolbyanyothername
reply to post by jfj123
So YOU would have NO trouble using a rope and some poles and create any EXACT desired angle ? 38 degrees ? 59 degrees ? how about 72 degrees ?
After laying it out on paper, it wouldn't be that hard.
Ok, I'll bite ... I'm really intrigued how you would transfer the following from paper onto a wheat field. I'm not being cynical or having a go at you but rather would consider the lesson educational and interesting. So could you please give an explanation (doesn't have to be extensive) as to how you would create an EXACT (there's that word again) angle of 38 degrees between 2 lines utilizing poles and rope.
You're permitted to do this in daylight so leave your night vision goggles home.