Man made or not, they are amazing and beautiful.

Originally posted by cripmeister
Nice find!

I think it's safe to say that all crop circles are man made unless proved otherwise.

It's already been proven that most crop circles are NOT man made. Use google.

i have a way to end the discussion once and for all. All we need is a U.S Air Force Global Hawk and have it stay up in the air for about 5 days. we would know then if it was alien or human. An alien would postpone the crop circle till nothing was watching. A human wouldnt know that a global hawk is watching.

Originally posted by RiotComing I would argue that we have tons more evidence of ET activity than we do of people coming in with boards strapped to their feet!

see that's the caveat to this argument that makes the outcome so successful.

the ONLY two options presented in the average debate as to the source of these designs are:

A) they were created by E.T.s using E.T. technology.

B) they were created by humans mulling around on the ground with string and boards / and or plastic piping.



Nobody every throws in the possibility that it's HUMANS with ADVANCED technology using electromagnetic / microwave directed energy to create these based on graphic templates.

it's like as soon as it involves evidence (circumstantial or not) UFOs or uncommonly found publicly known technology.. it must be from an alien race outside of Earth.


pshhhh.

what would be more beneficial?
an ET race teasing us with half-messages leading us to argue about them rather than figure them out...

a bunch of people spending all night or multiple nights spending time and energy..staying up extremely late at night to do so.. risking being tired in the morning..risking their jobs.. in a depressed economy.. multiple times a month.. just to watch the internet have them talked about?

or

Human agencies using advanced satellite or HAARP technology to send these images from their desktop to the crop fields with a few mouse clicks...
to create a back-story for aliens when they present fake aliens to the public... while simultaneously illustrating technologically significant mathematical concepts.. and astronomical events that affect us in the future..

oh let's see which one would be most beneficial to a long term plan...
as this is obviously a long term investment of time, energy and human endeavor.



but yeah.. keep arguing over whether you're convinced it's dudes with boards or real aliens.. don't even think it all through.. don't even consider other plausible possibilities.. just keep arguing over those TWO ONLY OPTIONS..

it's fun to watch you all bonking your heads together gnashing your teeth at your perceived convictions.

bravo...
as you were...

-

I Guess some people just want to believe that they are alien made.let them believe it.thats what they want to believe.even if they saw humans make a crop circle in real time they would then say that these humans are reptilians

good find op

i think that some people want to believe so hard that their judgement is clouded.no matter what the evidence is their mind is fixed.

If aliens exist why is it that everyone believes they think we can understand what they are displaying for us?

Wouldn't it be the equivelent of me putting up a written sign (for monkeys) in the forest, explaining where they can get all the free bananas they can eat?

i think the prospect that some people out there are doing this to generate money and fame is much more disturbing than the alien idea.

this may very well be just a bloody waste of time for everyone. I hope no one buys any media related to these crop circles.

So has anyone actually shown how they claim to make these intricate crop circles?

Still looking for that evidence as you may...

Key word : intricate, not a sloppy circle 2 drunk guys actually could make...

why the hell there are no videos showing a group of people doing these crop circles ...

really ... SOMEBODY in this world should have a video ... I just cannot believe that a group of people can go in a STEALTH mode and do everything they want ...

Like many here, I too saw the Discovery show which had students from MIT design and create their own crop circle... they even so far as too put ionized material about the area to make the circle "authentic". And, they did it in one evening.

Crop circles, for the most, would have to be done by man. Why? Because they have competitions! It's all documented! On a different note, one has to consider the whole crop circle phenomenon has been around for at least a few hundred years, and at its earliest, was attributed to demons.

Even though I believe / feel that some circles are spiritual in nature (and NOT alien), I agree with the original poster on this one... it is way too similar to other circles. Can anyone show two different circles that have so many similar details as the ones the OP demonstrated?

*sigh*

It's just like what the alien said on Ben 10 "no wonder aliens try to communicate with your livestock."

Has the alien 'holding the ball' cropcircle been proved genuine?
If so, these circles could be the ones it was talking about.
'Beware the bearers of FALSE gifts & their BROKEN PROMISES.'

lol actually that sounds more like Obama at this point of time.

So you want people to prove that your theory, which isn't based on any evidence, is wrong with evidence?

Maybe it being built on three different nights was part of the message. The crop has been analyzed and it seems to be a three part message and each message pertains to the three stages it took to make. The point wasn't to see the crop as a whole. It was as if someone was helping us to see it in three parts.

And you say the farmer should have caught some proof because he should have had the sense to set up a camera. First, maybe he doesn't have one. i don't. Not everyone does. Second, if it was over about 9 days then that about 4 or 5 days between each stage. I would give up looking for miscreants in my field if I was expecting them to return. Third, you act as if it proves that it's not alien made because there is no proof it was made under paranormal circumstances due to the lack of video evidence, but the same can be said if it was man made.

Originally posted by Visiting ESB

Originally posted by cripmeister
Nice find!

I think it's safe to say that all crop circles are man made unless proved otherwise.

It's already been proven that most crop circles are NOT man made. Use google.

i haven't seen an ounce of proof of a single crop circle being not man made. Odd details sure, but not one bit of proof.

As for proof of a crop circle being man made, I submit the hundreds of admitted crop circle creators and the blatant advertising crop circles.

In all likelihood all are man made. Best case (for your argument), most are man made, a few are not.

The crop circle you mention is actually one of the best cases for circles not being created by human hands, i've gone into it multiple times in multiple threads.