Originally posted by WhatTheory

Originally posted by miasria
so where does one draw the line regarding who should and shouldn't receive the miranda right?

Umm.....U.S. citizens. Why is this so difficult to understand?

What's next? Hey, after we read them their miranda rights, lets put them on government welfare, give them a brick of government cheese and put them up in public housing until their trial.

Good Lord, what is wrong with you sheeple? Please stop and try thinking for yourself instead of spewing and allowing yourself to be brainwashed by liberal/fascist policies.

Originally posted by cautiouslypessimistic
Wow, turning this into a libs/conservative thread. Well played. Seems like someone has an agenda to me.

Given the fact that we've wrongfully accused innocent people of being terrorists, and after all this Guantanamo nonsense...I'm going to go ahead as token liberal to say- this is a good idea.

Originally posted by miasria
now i don't trust my government.

Originally posted by WhatTheory

Originally posted by cautiouslypessimistic
Wow, turning this into a libs/conservative thread. Well played. Seems like someone has an agenda to me.

Wow, and not comprehending what you read is your problem.

Did you happen to notice the quote I responded to?
It was:

Given the fact that we've wrongfully accused innocent people of being terrorists, and after all this Guantanamo nonsense...I'm going to go ahead as token liberal to say- this is a good idea.

Did you see where the poster mentioned they are liberal? Instead of making accusations, please try to comprehend what you read. Unless you are the one with the agenda which is why you overlook the obvious.

[edit on 6/11/2009 by WhatTheory]

Originally posted by cautiouslypessimistic
Thats great, someone referred to themself as a liberal.

You then went on to insult them for being liberal. That is turning into a libs/conservs argument. Sorry if you can't comprehend that(another person falling into the seperation).

Originally posted by WhatTheory

Originally posted by cautiouslypessimistic
Thats great, someone referred to themself as a liberal.

You then went on to insult them for being liberal. That is turning into a libs/conservs argument. Sorry if you can't comprehend that(another person falling into the seperation).

Umm....I did not insult them. Hypersensitive much? Another typical liberal trait.

Saying, "You react and make decisions based on emotion instead of logic and the law." is not an insult. It is a fact especially in this particular case. Sorry if the truth hurts. Good grief!

Originally posted by WhatTheory

Originally posted by miasria
now i don't trust my government.

I don't trust the government either, but what on Earth does that have to do with reading miranda rights to enemy combatents being captured during war?

Miranda rights are for U.S. citizens only.
Since you are giving the terrorists these rights, along with government welfare and public housing, why don't you also give them all the rights in the U.S. Constitution. Especially the right to bear arms so they can shoot their captives.

Originally posted by WhatTheory

Originally posted by cautiouslypessimistic
Thats great, someone referred to themself as a liberal.

You then went on to insult them for being liberal. That is turning into a libs/conservs argument. Sorry if you can't comprehend that(another person falling into the seperation).

Umm....I did not insult them. Hypersensitive much? Another typical liberal trait.

Saying, "You react and make decisions based on emotion instead of logic and the law." is not an insult. It is a fact especially in this particular case. Sorry if the truth hurts. Good grief!

Originally posted by debz325
We have tortured in every war we have ever fought,why should this one be any different?Do you think the people that jumped from world trade center felt tortured as they plunged to there death?I could maybe understand your point of view if we were fighting a civilized people but we are not.