Debate: Marshal Law-Will the troops open up on their own citizens?, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times
Topic started on 31-5-2009 @ 03:05 PM by kiwifoot
Check this out YouTube vid:




Did you know this?

Law Enforcement and Federal Agencies can train for FREE in the Urban Warfare Center®. Weapons and safety gear will be provided as needed.


I just had to ask the question, do you think US troops, police and other federal officers would shoot on the public?

We have seen of late many threads discussing excessive (or maybe not depending on your view) police actions. Do you see this carrying on over to shooting at the public if there was serious civil unrest?

Do you think the military and police have it in them, or will the human side of these guys just say no? Will training from places like the UWC just turn these guys into cold blooded killers when put in this scenario?


reply posted on 31-5-2009 @ 03:16 PM by Wally Hope
Well I don't see why not, it has happened before.

Here is just one very well known example...

www.youtube.com...

It really doesn't take a lot to demonize a group of people, and during a protest like this (some called it a riot) individual thought and logic tend to disappear and crowd mentality takes over, for the protesters and the cops. Or national guard as in this example.

So if they declare martial law, and people get restless and start protesting, and the cops/soldiers have been fed lies from their officers to demonize the protesters, it could easily happen. In fact that's already been done. All people have been demonized as potential criminals in the minds of the cops, we're all guilty, we just haven't all been caught yet.

'Four dead in Ohio'


reply posted on 31-5-2009 @ 05:05 PM by Hastobemoretolife
reply to post by mattifikation



Then they would also know that they would lose horribly too. With the free flow of information in this country it wouldn't take long for the supply lines to be cut off. We have way to many ex military that could mobilize and command a make shift companies( or the whatever the right term is).

The logistics of that scale are impossible and besides the second the free flow of info gets cut off all hell would break lose. Just like an Admiral in the Japanese military said, invading America would be a very bad decision there is a gun behind every blade of grass.

The troops(of any nationality) would quickly fold and retreat once they realize they are out numbered. The American troops would switch sides it wouldn't take long for battle tested soldiers to figure out that what is going on is not right.

Edit to add -

The PTB are only Human they are just as prone to stupidity as everybody else on this planet, they aren't Gods, or immortals, they are humans. You should quit giving them more credit than they deserve.

[edit on 31-5-2009 by Hastobemoretolife]


reply posted on 31-5-2009 @ 06:00 PM by mattifikation
The troops in Iraq have yet to figure out that what they're doing isn't right. And that's with their own families screaming it in their face. You grossly underestimate the power of brainwashing to control the masses.

You seem to be under the impression that the PTB would fight us directly. No, not for a second. They'd pitch us against each other, in this pathetic Right vs. Left game they've got us all playing.

As for the precious free flow of information, do you not think there's a system in place to handle that? Just one scenario out of a hundred possibilities: They could stage a "terrorist attack" that leaves the country in a black out. Information stops flowing *instantly.* Local law enforcement would get word from the government that it was a terrorist attack, and spread the word through the community.

The population would be too dumb and gullible to blame the government. They'd blame the "terrorists." The very, very few people who would put up an armed resistance would be blamed for ongoing violence. Just like in Katrina, the government would use that as an excuse to round up everyone's guns. The sheeple wouldn't fight back, they'd give in and surrender their guns.

Listen to me on that point. That part is NOT speculation. In Katrina, NOBODY resisted. Not the troops. Not the civilians. Nobody. Only the criminals who used their guns for violence. The innocent were disarmed. It was an exercise. They KNOW how to get people to surrender their arms WITHOUT firing a shot.

The fact of the matter is, guns are only useful if the righteous are willing to use them. The powers that be know this. They know how not to show their hand. They know how to dupe the masses. When soldiers finally roll into the towns, they'll be welcomed by the vast, unarmed majority with open arms.

And then, when TPTB come out into the open and take their throne of power, the few militia groups remaining and willing to fight will be the "enemy," and the very people they fight to protect will be the ones to rise up against them.

[edit on 31-5-2009 by mattifikation]


reply posted on 31-5-2009 @ 06:10 PM by Hastobemoretolife
reply to post by mattifikation



Katrina was a very different situation. You also discount the fact the NOLA was almost completely evacuated except for the people that refused to leave or couldn't afford too.

If it is going to pit us against each other and it comes to a fire fight then it will be a multiple front war. The logistics are impossible to figure out. All they have is simulations, simulations and real life are completely different.

There are probably about a 100 million gun owners a few million will turn in their weapons, but the one that wouldn't would fight.

The troops fighting in Iraq think it is a good purpose no matter what their family says because their family isn't there and they are providing for their family. The troops can't just refuse to disobey orders the only way for that to happen is for them to in act a large scale mutiny.

The second operations get underway to disarm the citizens word of mouth flows quickly. Like I said the logistics are impossible. It would be a huge cluster# with nobody knowing the outcome.

It isn't cut and dry. Besides Iraq isn't America. Very different scenarios. There are 300+ million people in America 170+ million of which are adults. There isn't an army on earth that control that many people.

And to further prove my point look at Afghanistan, Iraq, Vietnam, Korea, etc.



reply posted on 31-5-2009 @ 06:23 PM by mattifikation
How was Katrina a different situation? Do you think that they'll just wake up one day, and say "Alright men, Roll out. We're taking all the guns!" They aren't stupid. They've been outsmarting America as a whole for decades, and by some accounts, the entire world.

They will create a disaster first. A huge one. It will make it so that Katrina is not a different situation. It will create lawlessness and disorder. People will be begging for the military to clean up the mess, not fighting them off. Logistics will be left to the local level to figure out, with local police leading the charge to disarm us all. Most civilians are probably just dumb enough to help, rather than resist that effort.

Logistics could be kept small by localizing the efforts. Door to door, collecting garbage trucks full of guns that would get smashed down right there on the spot by the trucks' compactors. It wouldn't be nearly the logistical undertaking that you're making it out to be. Hell, it would barely be more difficult than properly carrying out garbage collection night.

There's actually only estimated to be about 80 million gun owners, in a country of 300 million. Most of those folks are just hunters and wouldn't actively fight - just like the Katrina victims didn't fight to preserve their rights.

You brought up a good point about those victims. They were the ones who stayed. They defied evacuation orders. They defied a massive hurricane. But they handed in their guns like brain dead sheep. What's that tell you about the ones who *aren't* defiant?

Soldiers would barely need to be used. They'd probably only be used for support roles to the local police and deputies that would do the vast majority of the dirty work.
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>    ^^TOP^^



Sno-Trains..A short History..(with short video)
  Posted 14 days ago with 16 member flags
Pictures: Civil War Sub H.L. Hunley Finally Revealed
  Posted 8 days ago with 5 member flags
Neuroscience the new face of warfare: experts
  Posted 4 days ago with 5 member flags
Congress Passes Bill That Opens US Skies To Unmanned Drones
  Posted 3 days ago with 4 member flags
The Latest in Terminator Tech
  Posted 2 days ago with 3 member flags
U.S. Navy to test 32 megajoule EM Railgun in the coming weeks
  Posted 1 days ago with 3 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Hollow Earth Theory New Evidence.
  General Conspiracies, Posted 16 hours ago, 111 replies
Anonymous show your face!
  Rant, Posted 12 hours ago, 65 replies
I saw a cat turn into a bag..
  The Gray Area, Posted 16 hours ago, 42 replies