Best weapons to own when TSHTF?, page 3
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 1 times


reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 06:32 PM by zlots331
I know there are many who fear some type of scenario where society breaks down and mass confusion ensues with gangs of zombies attacking you and yours.

When I think of weapons I would primarily think of something that would help me survive and take game for food. One of the main impressions I always get when I read posts like this is that you should stock up on weapons whose sole purpose is to kill people, not game.

Sorry, but if you start shooting at me I will shoot back and I have handled firearms all my life. My semi-automatic .22 long rifle with a 14 shot magazine and scope is quite effective in a variety of situations. You can take down anything from a rabbit to a deer with very little effort, it's just a matter of shot placement and is quite lethal at considerable distances. Or if you insist, a proper head shot will take down any person who may actually be a threat. And I agree that you can set aside a ton of .22 ammo. The machete and a good hunting knife are excellent suggestions and I wouldn't want to be without either. I also have a .410 shotgun that takes a either shot or slugs but is a bit heavier than the .22 so if I was looking for portability I would probably pick the .22.

Outside of that thought, I would think the most effective weapon I could have would be to be in the right place geographically. If you are in the middle of NYC when things go down I don't care how many weapons you have. You won't have a chance, even if you try to escape you would end up running a gauntlet to get out.

Learn as much as you can about wood-crafts and actually practice them. You can only learn so much out of a book. And not just a class with a bunch of people in it. Go out on your own and practice surviving with as little equipment as possible. You'd be surprised how quickly you can learn when only you are there to figure it out. When I was a few years younger I would regularly take off on improvised camping trips with nothing more than my hunting knife, some light rope, a piece of plastic, limited clothing that I could take off or put on in layers depending on conditions, a baggie with nuts and dried fruit, some sturdy shoes and a lightweight poncho. No gun, no matches, no problem.

Ditch the AK-47 and go learn how to start a fire, dress a deer, and smoke fish. I will be as far away as possible, by myself, living out my life as a happy "camper".

Of course the ultimate weapon would be to actively prevent the disaster in the first place. No disaster, no problem.


reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 06:39 PM by thecrow001
reply to post by zlots331



i like your idea but wouldnt you rather get a group together who know all of these things you say e.g hunting, first aid, bush craft and combat ect to help out people in your community. stength in numbers and all that.



reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 06:53 PM by Zosynspiracy
reply to post by zlots331



50 years ago I'd say you were spot on. But there is no way in hell that would be the case nowadays. The deer and animal populations would be decimated in a matter of weeks with thousands of people flocking to the "woods". There are only pockets of areas in the US that could support any type of Red Dawn/Rambo situation but it wouldn't last. We have 300+ million people in this country. You think you'd be the only run taking to the wilderness? Let's face it, if there was any major outbreak of national civil war where the people were battling the military or police it would be over quickly and the number of dead would be huge. That's just the way it is unfortunately nowadays. Unless some aspects of the police and military defected and fought each other the "people" would be decimated and lots would die and rather quickly. Knowing how to dress a deer and catch a fish is pointless.


reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 07:20 PM by seangkt
reply to post by Zosynspiracy



The thread is silly but it is fun.
And in the moment to be completely realistic I don't think it would matter what it is anyone had as long as it can be used as a weapon it would be good. There are people who are better shots with bows on this planet than 90% of people who shoot guns have.

So honestly whatever you're good with would work in reality it all comes down to how you use it and who you are against of course.


reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 07:26 PM by dooper
reply to post by BrainPower



It's kind of funny. In Special Forces, we had our own unique knives, two types, and I still have both. And they issued us a tomahawk, complete with web gear fitting.

The tomahawk is unbelievably useful. That back spike can open a can or a head faster than you can believe. Much more effective than the horseman's axe which it is partially modeled after, I can fully appreciate why a lot of our frontiersmen had a tomahawk.

I usually carried a machete tilted slightly toward my left side where I could draw it out quickly, and you don't have to squirm and twist to get to it.

One knife on the inside of my left leg, and one on my chest with my web gear. No matter what condition I found myself in, one was always at hand.

The closest thing I can find is a tomahawk by Cold Steel.




[edit on 17-5-2009 by dooper]


reply posted on 17-5-2009 @ 09:26 PM by nenothtu
reply to post by Zosynspiracy



I was under the impression that this thread was about viable weaponry in a SHTF scenario where resupply was not coming. You appear to have limited it to a "civil war" type scenario. Let's run with that, shall we?

In your scenario, the government cracks down on the rebels, and kills everyone. At least that's the impression I get from your posts. If that's the case, that 300 million population suddenly got less formiddable, being dead in the streets, and all that.

WHO is going to kill off all the wildlife, then?

WHO is going to 'rush out of the cities' for the countryside, then?

WHO is going to make more bullets for the guns, then?

Ad infinitum.

In that case, I don't think 'living off the land' is all that impractical. Unless, of course, the 'survivor' happens to be one of those that thinks steak comes from grocery stores, and isn't sure what a cow is. There are lots of those types around.

I'd try to hang on to my AK, though. Ever tried to kill a deer with a pointy stick? The main problem is you have to chase it down first...

nenothtu out

[edit on 2009/5/17 by nenothtu]


reply posted on 18-5-2009 @ 09:31 PM by Jessicaviv
reply to post by BrainPower



I once heard it said that "you don't have to have the best gun.... you just have to kill the one who does.."

Now a peaceful gal, but as long as military might be in your area rounding us up for death camps, I think I'll take what they've got.



reply posted on 19-5-2009 @ 05:17 AM by DataWraith
reply to post by BrainPower



It doesn't matter the calibre your gun has, or the length of your sword or the sharpness of your knife ,the VERY BEST weapon to have when TSHTF is 'yourname' mate, its the most powerful weapon one can have in any event is your brain, keep your cool and use your intellect to your best advantage.

Like the saying goes " Keep your head while those around you lose theirs".

Who's got the best weapon in this situation, A guy has a dozen weapons in the middle of a town, but nowhere to hunt and is totally clueless. Or the guy who knows how to hunt, start fires and how to set up a tent and live off the land.?
Who's chances do you fancy in surviving a week or a month or a year?
And please don't tell me the guy with guns will shoot you and take your food, as he'll run out of ammo fending off the other people with guns and no clue.



[edit on 19/5/09 by DataWraith]


reply posted on 19-5-2009 @ 06:31 PM by CharlesMartel
Originally posted by Miraj
reply to
post by infolurker



Yeah, an AR isnt the wisest choice at this point for that reason.. .22 has very little stopping power, but any slightly experienced shooter will have next to no recoil from it. So it's easy to put round after round into a person and not worry about missing.

But you need a more powerful (more than the AR, it's really not that powerful either) weapon when they get up too close. A shot gun, 9MM, AK, or any other similar weapon is a good choice for this. All of them have readily available ammo (Well usually anyways)


If you know how to use it, a .22 can get you something bigger.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^



Hello again preppers and survivalist. Life changing reality.
  Posted 9 days ago with 31 member flags
Get some Magnoplasm Paste for your first-aid kit.
  Posted 17 days ago with 26 member flags
Hobby or Second Income Homemade Soaps, Sundry, and Remedy Recipes
  Posted 14 days ago with 19 member flags
Americans Buy 10,800,000+ Guns in 2011
  Posted 17 days ago with 9 member flags
Do Not Drink From The Tap!
  Posted 8 days ago with 9 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Greetings from a Dying Man
  Introductions, Posted 10 hours ago, 89 replies
Alien Grey caught in photo ?
  Aliens and UFOs, Posted 12 hours ago, 70 replies
Pass Me My Rifle
  World War Three, Posted 16 hours ago, 58 replies
Iran sent pink drone to Obama
  World War Three, Posted 17 hours ago, 40 replies