reply to post by bodrul
Ok, points are made and are quite clear. I apologies ahead if i repeat some of arguments for sake of complete reply.
Hitler claimed his people were descendants of a superior race (and they had supporters world wide even the United states, ....
People from Israel Believe they are a superior Race and like the Nazis have people around the world that support that (example majority people in the
Well, yes there are people in Israel who do believe that they are chosen (by God) race. Personally i always ask them - chosen to do what? Since in the
army for example i was "chosen" for kitchen duty several times - and really hated it, it was not a good thing to be chosen to do. But it does not
matter, what matter is the start of your own line:
from Israel believe....
Show me how it is official policy in Israel. Show me prime minister of Israel claiming that. Otherwise it is not comparable. I think that there are
still people in Israel who support transfer of all Arab population. And? Is it position of the state? Is it desire of majority of Israeli
Hitler Pushed Jews into Ghettos and overcrowded them and starved them of essential items, food and other things before mass murdering them.
Israel Have Palestinians in a Ghetto and deprive them of the basics,
and kill civilians on purpose using weapons which were banned to be used against Civilians
Is West bank - ghetto??? And in Gaza, the only place that can be compared to ghetto -
A) are people deprived of all basics? I do not recall red cross being able to pass shipments of aid to people in ghetto in Nazi Germany.
B) was not Gaza open with seaport,airport and passages before
the rockets and Hamas? I do not recall rockets coming from ghettoes fired at Nazi
Germany and Germans tolerating it for almost a decade. The uprisings were suppressed, after which no living soul survived in the same ghetto.Who did
not run, was killed.
C) are people in Gaza dieing of starvations on the street and have a special team hired to just collect the bodies?
Once again - you compare the incomparable. And while actions of Israel in the last Gaza conflict were aggressive and destructive to Palestinian
population - how it differs for example from what Jordan did to the same Palestinians, killing much more by the way?
Nazis stole Jewish Property and land and other assets
Israelis Steal Land and Palestinian assets claiming it’s theirs given to them by GOD.
Yes, Nazis stole land - not only from Jews by the way, they took land from Poles and others. But!!! Tell me - what France did in Africa? Did not it
stole lands? China - Tibet, USSR - Finland;Poland;Latvia;Estonia;Litva;Japan...., Russia - Georgia, UK - Argentina; And hundreds of examples in the
It certainly does not make Israel right. It certainly does not justify what Israel did and does. But it also does not justify on this basis to say
that since Israel did what dozens of other countries did (including Nazi Germany) - they are also Nazis. Call French Nazis and see how it plays
As for propaganda - both sides use propaganda. Proponents of both sides use propaganda (as yours, and probably mine) posts show. So? All countries in
the world use propaganda for their interests. All nazis?
And finally - violin example. Yes, it must be pretty humiliating for this man. And it was pretty sick as far as soldiers are concerned. So? There is
difference between some sick individuals and government policy!
[edit on 6-2-2009 by ZeroKnowledge]