The great BTS QB deabte & tournament

I've read countless postings and debates from all over the web,about who is the greatest QB of all time.

So I thought I'd pose the question to the NFL fans of ATS.
Each round will last a full week,starting today.

So here is a tournament of the top 16 QBs in NFL history (IMO)

Dan Marino


~Vs~

Jim Kelly


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Dan Fouts


~VS~

Joe Namath


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Troy Aikman


~Vs~

Roger Staubach


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

John Elway


~Vs~

Peyton Manning


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Tom Brady


~Vs~

Joe Montana


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Bart Starr


~Vs~

Terry Bradshaw


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Brett Favre


~Vs~

Steve Young


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Fran Tarkenton


~Vs~

Sammy Baugh




[edit on 10-1-2009 by Black_Fox]

Was this really that bad of an idea?Sheesh.....

reply to post by Black_Fox


How can you leave out Ken O'Brian?

reply to post by schrodingers dog


Ken O'Brien?
Are you being serious?
I would have put Warren Moon in before Ken.

reply to post by Black_Fox


No I am not serious, or am I?

No I'm not.

Okay, I'll throw ya a bone.

Marino
Fouts
Staubach
Manning (close call)
Montana
Starr
Favre (Close call)
Tarkenton

Of course, you can't leave out Unitas, who many would argue is the greatest ever.