Two million year old find!, page 7
Pages: <<  4    5    6    7    8  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 72 times


reply posted on 21-12-2008 @ 08:28 PM by cruzion
reply to post by Xtrozero



Well no doubt ardipithecus at ~ 5m years is very human-like, but even at the proconsulid level of ~ 20m years ago, they had some human-like traits.
Even 20 million years is nothing in geologic time.


reply posted on 21-12-2008 @ 10:15 PM by ProfEmeritus
Let me try to correct some of the wild statements that have been made so far on this thread.
Here is what the article said about the find:
Stone tools found at the bottom level of the cave — believed to be 2 million years old — show that human ancestors were in the cave earlier than ever thought before. Geological evidence indicates that these tools were left in the cave and not washed into the site from the outside world.
....

The combination of stone tools indicating the presence of human ancestors and the dating of the level leads to the conclusion that human ancestors (hominids) were in the cave 2 million years ago. This is the earliest evidence for intentional cave occupation by human ancestors.

The article does NOT indicate finding any fossils, only tools.

Now, the information in this article does NOT push back the date to which we have found early fossils, believed to be ancestors of modern man:

www.msu.edu...

The Eastern African specimen: Homo habilis represents a pivotal phase in hominid evolution. Scientists have marked habilis as the beginning of the Homo line, where hominids are recognized as breaking off from the australopithecine classification. A large part in making the determination of where the beginning of the Homo line were to take place had much to do with the level of encephalization taking place in H. habilis, as it is with habilis that we begin to see strong movements toward a modern brain size. Homo habilis broke through into science in the early 1960's with the discovery of the OH 7 (the habilis type specimen) fossil at Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania by Louis Leakey and collegues. The existence of Homo habilis is currently dated to between 1.9 and 1.6 million years.


AL 666-1 Maxilla

~Found by William Kimball at Hadar

~Dated to 2.3 million years


Again, in the article:
There were a number of species of hominids in southern Africat 2 million years ago. The most likely candidate as the manufacturer of the stone tools found at Wonderwerk is Homo habilis. The oldest known stone tools from sites in Ethiopia date to 2.4 million years. The Wonderwerk Cave discoveries are those close in age to the very earliest known stone tools and similar in date to the bottom levels at Olduvai Gorge.


Now, how did they draw the conclusion that the site was probably the dwelling of Homo habilis?
In this source:
www.ecotao.com...
we read:
The main features of the transition from Australopithecines to H. habilis are the use of tools and an enlarged braincase (700cc) (Avers, 1989) (600 to 750 cc (Gore, 1997)). H. habilis could walk upright like modern humans, but could probably also climb trees to sleep, feed or escape predators. Their hand and foot had a combination of ancient and modern features, expected from an early ancestor. By the time that H. habilis arose, the foot still fell somewhere between that of a man and gorilla in its weight-bearing capabilities! Even the anklebone suggests their walking differed from the human striding gait. The robust lower legbones, the tibia and fibula showed that the adaptation to bipedalism was even less specialised at the knee joint. This bipedal, plantigrade primate thus had a different gait to modern humans, but not necessarily less efficient, and perhaps superior (see details on the australopithecine hip [2]). An adult female fossil representative of this species stood only 90 cm high, with hands hanging over the knees as in apes! These features of H. habilis are almost identical to those of A. afarensis , showing here that the primitive apelike characteristics served well in the niche of this creature in nature for a very long time.


Thus, since current thinking is that H. habilis was the first tool maker, the conclusion of H. habilis follows.

I should point out that the debate still rages as to whether H. erectus is a direct descendant Homo Habilis, or as some now believe, that both species co-existed, and descended from a common ancestor.

What I have tried to do, is present current thought on the ancestry of man,without regard to anomalous objects found or any other alternate theories. Nowhere have there been any reputable finds of fossils that indicate man goes back 20 million years. That does not mean it is not possible, but based upon the finds to date, such statements would be wild speculation, without reputable scientific or archeological evidence.


reply posted on 22-12-2008 @ 12:54 PM by Melyanna Tengwesta
reply to post by twodee



Great stuff!!! Too bad they don't show any images of the 30 artifacts they say they found ....

Peace!



[edit on 12/22/2008 by Melyanna Tengwesta]



reply posted on 23-12-2008 @ 04:02 PM by sciencenewby
The problem I have with this find is the age and the depth....

your telling me in 2 million years stuff only sinks down 6 meters?

2 million years goes into 1 billion 500 times

so thats 500 times 6 meters which is 3000 meters every billion years.

so 3000 meters is roughly 9000 feet. almost 2 miles deep every 1 billion years.

now this all sounds fine and dandy until i look at how far the continents themselves moved over the past 6 billion years and its thousands of miles... new mountains have formed.... new lakes....

the north and south poles have changed location many times (or so ive read)

volcanoes have exploded and changed the face of the planet over the billions of years and meteor impacts.

and your telling me over 2 MILLION years this stuff only sank 18 feet into the earth?

I can go into my backyard and dig 2 feet down and find stuff thats only a couple years old.

i know the continents move side to side which is different from up and down. but it still doesnt seem to add up correctly.

then again.... I dont know much about this kind of thing so if anyone cares to enlighten me please do.

and how deep do the generally find dinasaur bones? because those are what? 100 million years old? yet they r finding these things not that deep?

100 million years.... the time it takes for a new mountain range to form miles out of the earth....

yet dinasaur bones are like what? sometimes a few feet deep?

I doubt the stuff we find is as old as we think it is. I highly doubt any dinasaur bones are 250 million+ years old and we can find them so conveniently. Tons of them.


reply posted on 23-12-2008 @ 05:50 PM by BornPatriot
reply to post by twodee




Wow - 2 million year old artefacts...

I have heard we found a leather pouch that contained arrowheads "Cherokee" - that was found in a 300K year old Coal seam in West Va. I didnt know the cherokee made it that far north... I'm from the 3 corners area... Tenn. Ga. N.Carolina... area. and well that sort of blows the doors off the theory that we came from Asia 10K years ago ...

you know, the bible uses the term "Re-Plentish" so, maybe life is as old as earth. lord knows what we will find... a few years ago we found an ancient computer "Greek" I think... but this is just a Zodiak calculator that only tracked 5 planets... > 5 Planets.... and we have the Myans who just vanished.... several civilizations that just seem to disappear ... throughout history... I wonder if we are being harvested ... ?


reply posted on 23-12-2008 @ 05:56 PM by Hanslune
reply to post by BornPatriot



I can assure you that the Maya still exist, all thirty plus dialect groups. I use to work with them.


reply posted on 25-12-2008 @ 11:17 AM by RuneSpider
reply to post by Funkydung



So, the Sumer civilization does not count then? Or for that matter the settlements at Jericho or Catalhoyuk?
Pages: <<  4    5    6    7    8  >>    ^^TOP^^



Origin of Ancient Jade Tool Baffles Scientists
  Posted 5 days ago with 96 member flags
12,000 Years Old Unexplained Structure
  Posted 3 days ago with 80 member flags
The Uluburun shipwreck sunk 3,400 years ago
  Posted 13 days ago with 70 member flags
Sigiriya : The 8th Wonder of the World
  Posted 3 days ago with 45 member flags
Tomb of Queen Heterpheres
  Posted 15 days ago with 29 member flags
R.O.V. Photos of Sunken Megaliths off Western Cuba
  Posted 9 days ago with 21 member flags