On the other hand.
There is no set procedure under international law for attacking pirates.
So who cares? Well, any belligerant nation who wants to start a war can simply say that what you call pirates actually have a "letter of marque" to
stop and search vessels....for pirates.
And you just committed an act of war by detaining them.
All it would take for Libya, Venezuela, ..... or maybe North Korea, to launch a "retaliatory" strike against a major power would be the pretext that
the same ship had just attacked "part of our navy" engaged in piracy suppression.
Sound like an irrelevant scenario?
Before you answer, you ought to read up on the
First and Second Barbary Wars, in which the
major world powers (and the young American republic) were sucked into war based on just such a pretext.
In the name of Piracy suppression, the nascent United States found itself on the verge of a land war in the Sahara, and finally ended up paying ransom
to the Pasha of Tripoli after they got in over their heads.
So, that's what's going on, why no one wants to "sink the pirates."
.
[edit on 4-12-2008 by dr_strangecraft]