reply to post by SaintlyMic
I don't often find myself agreeing with Christians on this board, but you have this absolutely right: to equate Creation with Creator is to say that
a table is the same as a carpenter.
You might find it interesting to contemplate the following Thomist proof of the existence of God:
- Entities in the world exist in varying degrees of perfection. This implies the existence of absolute perfection, a Platonic Ideal of Perfection.
- This absolutely perfect entity must be God. All that is not God is imperfect to some degree.
Now, OP: do you think of the Creator as perfect, or flawed?
What about Creation, then? Perfect, or flawed?
I think most people would agree that Creation is flawed; there is evil in the world, and no-one ever gets his heart's desire, or if he does get it,
it soon cloys and his heart begins to desire something else.
But if Creation is the same as the Creator, then the Creator is flawed, too.
Therefore, either the Creator is flawed, as the Manichees believed, and therefore not God; or else Creation is flawless and death, bereavement,
disease, pain, suffering and evil are not fundamentally different from life, love, health, pleasure and good.
Could you live with that? Do you believe it?
[edit on 24-11-2008 by Astyanax]