Obese have right to 2 airline seats: Canada court, page 7
Pages: <<  4    5    6    7    8    9    10  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 4 times


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:11 PM by VelmaLu
Originally posted by Unit541
reply to
post by VelmaLu



Are you serious? You really don't understand that since someone with 35% body fat (also referred to as BMI or "Body Mass Index") is considered OBESE, and that an OBESE person is statistically at 2x to3x the chance of dying prematurely, than the person with 7% body fat (who is NOT obese)?

See, you're airline seat argument evaporated, and you've now turned this into a thread about whether or not it's healthy to be obese. There are some pretty far out topics on ATS, I think this is the first of it's kind however.

Of all the outlandish claims made on this website, I never thought I'd see someone claim an obesity poses no health risks.


Yes, I've actually read the research and written extensively on it.

You can have a body fat percentage of 35% be physically fit and very healthy. You can have a body fat percentage of 7% and smoke, have cancer, AIDS and drink excessively.

Body fat percentage IN AND OF ITSELF is no predictor of health.


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:13 PM by HERACAT
reply to post by Unit541



Not trying to start something but arent boby fat % and BMI two different things? As I understand it your BF% and BMI would probaly be two different numbers even though they might indicate the same condition.



reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:30 PM by mattifikation
reply to post by deadline527



I fail to see how childish insults can further our argument. Comparing large people to hippos? Really? Shame. :-(


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:30 PM by MakeSoap
reply to post by LostNemesis



Do you think that a government file on this case would be classified "above top secret?" No way. Go post in a "news no one cares about" forum. This site is for conspiracies. I hate looking at the top stories and seeing crap like this taking up space.



reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:37 PM by bknapple32
Originally posted by MakeSoap
reply to
post by LostNemesis



Do you think that a government file on this case would be classified "above top secret?" No way. Go post in a "news no one cares about" forum. This site is for conspiracies. I hate looking at the top stories and seeing crap like this taking up space.


i love when people who have been on this site for 4 days can tell us what ATS is all about.


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 11:38 PM by deadline527
Originally posted by mattifikation
reply to
post by deadline527



I fail to see how childish insults can further our argument. Comparing large people to hippos? Really? Shame. :-(


Actually thats no where near what was intended. I just picked a image of something that obviously would not fit in a single seat.

So I guess I'm comparing tall people and muscular people to hippos as well?

I could have put a ride-on lawnmower there for all it matters, but then you'd probably complain that im comparing obese people to a john deer tractor.


reply posted on 22-11-2008 @ 12:30 AM by MakeSoap
reply to post by bknapple32



I created a membership 4 days ago. I've been reading and posting annon. for almost a year. Don't jump to conclusions buddy.

[edit on 22-11-2008 by MakeSoap]

[edit on 22-11-2008 by MakeSoap]


reply posted on 22-11-2008 @ 12:31 AM by GodshipForAll
Originally posted by bknapple32
Originally posted by MakeSoap
reply to
post by LostNemesis



Do you think that a government file on this case would be classified "above top secret?" No way. Go post in a "news no one cares about" forum. This site is for conspiracies. I hate looking at the top stories and seeing crap like this taking up space.


i love when people who have been on this site for 4 days can tell us what ATS is all about.


Well I've been browsing ATS for years and only recently became a member this summer, And it is annoying to see this on a conspiracy site a little.....I guess its alternative topics but this is just another story from problems from a disfunctional society lol


But anyways,
There needs to be a correction to adjust to the ailments of our rise in obesity. Set new standards on foods we let out on market. Un-nutritious foods flood the market, look at a convienant store, It's my estimation that 80 percent of the products sold there are junk, and only help compound the problem with obesity.

However, they're should be a disabled section of the plan to allow for occurences of such problems untill we can solve the epidemic. We are here to help eachother and to support one another, not to lay blame or deny ignorance. We can all do are part by not supporting unhealthy foods even being allowed onto the market and by taking an obese friend exercising.

Peace



reply posted on 22-11-2008 @ 12:33 AM by bknapple32
Originally posted by MakeSoap
reply to
post by bknapple32



I created a membership 4 days ago. I've been reading and posting annon. for almost a year. Don't jump to conclusions buddy.


MMMk buddy. Well , if you want conspiracy, I suggest going to one of the many numerous sections of this site. this particular section of ATs happens to be devoted to alt. news.. and this thread , devoted to fat obese people taking up two seats and only paying for one


but you knew that being a long time lurker and all


reply posted on 22-11-2008 @ 12:39 AM by deadline527
Originally posted by C0bzz
Why is a court, deciding how fully privatised corporations should charge their customers? That's what I want to know. Maybe an overweight person should go to court demanding two pizzas for the price of one, after all, 'one-person-one-charge'. If these idiots do not like it, they should go start their own airline.

[edit on 22/11/2008 by C0bzz]


Reminds me of the gays complaining that eHarmony only matches men with women, so they complained and had a court ORDER a PRIVATE company to change their business model. If somewhere doesn't offer something you want, go somewhere else.

Now, I do believe there should be specific seats for morbidly obese people. Nothing is worse then having a fat body invading your comfort zone, be it on a plane, train, or bus. But, how do they know how many obese people will be getting on the plane? Simplest solution obviously would be make them pay for however many seats they take up, but people dont understand that.

Also, couldn't it be considered a safety hazard having someone so fat that they do not fit in the seat correctly? What if there was a situation where the plane was experiencing turbulence, and an obese body caused injury to the person they are "sharing" a seat with? Thats a lot of weight to be throwing around, and it would be even more dangerous if it happened to be a child sitting next to someone like that.

archives.cnn.com...


Barbara Hewson, 63, was offered damages by Virgin Atlantic after suffering a blood clot, torn leg muscles and sciatica following a flight to Los Angeles in January 2001, the UK's Press Association reported.

She said the woman passenger was so large she had to sit with the arm rests up, but when she complained, the crew said there was nothing they could do as the plane was full.


What a horrible situation for that poor lady..

Or, they could just create larger seats due to the increasing girth of the worlds populations.. but that would require money, and the loss of available seating room - which means even more loss of money, so I doubt that would ever happen.
Pages: <<  4    5    6    7    8    9    10  >>    ^^TOP^^