Ineresting discussion I had with a Homeland Security agent, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 12 times
Topic started on 21-11-2008 @ 02:02 PM by Supes
First I'd like to say that this is my first time starting a thread here, so please take it easy on me.

Also, I hope this is the correct forum for this, if not I'm sure the mods will take care of it for me.

On to the story!

I work in a small shop in one of Detroit's northern 'burbs. One day a man walks into the shop and after advising him on some of our products he choses one and I bring it to the counter for him and we started chatting a bit. He mentioned he just moved to Michigan and I asked him why on earth he would want to move here. He replied that he was just transferred to Selfridge A.N.G. base a few miles from here. I asked if he was in the Guard, he replied that he worked for Homeland Security. He proceeded to pay for his purchase with his credit card, on the back of which was written "See I.D.", so as I always do, I asked for his I.D. He pulls out his government I.D. and badge, lays it on the counter and said "That one there is Top Secret"
I replied "Ooooh, does that mean you have to kill me? After all I am an Arab-American?"
He chuckled then got pretty serious and said "I'm not here to kill you. I'm here to kill other people."

Was he joking? Probably, it was hard to tell, at that point he wasn't smiling.

He goes on to tell me that while in his previous posting, he was investigating a guy who had gone to the trouble of getting rated as a pilot capable of flying commercial airliners, only to work at his brother's party store in New York, and how the FBI told them to back off. He then goes on to rant about how the government can't protect you, only you can protect you. There's so much bureaucracy and politics involved in the federal law enforcement agencies that they can hardly get anything done. On his way out the door, he stops, turns around and says, "Buy a shotgun and wait for the riots, because they're coming."
I replied, "I'm way ahead of you, thats one of the good things about Michigan, not many hoops to jump through to own and carry guns."
He agreed with me and walked out the door.

This all happened a couple of months ago, I was hesitant to post this, I didn't want any repercussion for him. This is one reason I left out his previous location, though it probably wouldn't take much for anyone working for D.H.S. to put 2 and 2 together. Though I doubt he was breaking any rules by telling me what he did, still I'd rather err on the side of caution.

Everything in quotes is to the best of my recollection a direct statement.

I hope I don't get flamed and branded a Fear Monger for this and as it is anecdotal, I don't expect anyone to believe me as there's no evidence, other than my say so, that this conversation took place. At least I'm not predicting aliens or attacks because my ouija board says so


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 03:00 PM by Supes
reply to post by habu71



He never took his hand off the wallet and when it hit the counter it made a satisfying thud. I'm no expert, but I've seen my fair share of badges. It was real. I think the top secret remark was made in levity, I doubt he showed me those creds. What he set on the counter was a federally issued photo I.D. and badge, cops do it all the time. It's no different than me using my CPL, a state issued photo I.D., when I misplaced my license. The regulations you speak of are so they don't get discounts just because of their job, though every cop or firefighter that comes in here doesn't have to ask for a discount, they will get one anyway, it's what most businesses do.

He hasn't been back since.

Edit for a random thought:
Besides all of that, Top Secret isn't really all that impressive.

[edit on 21-11-2008 by Supes]


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 06:11 PM by marg6043
reply to post by Supes



While the story sounds interesting I will have to agree with others here that posted that if he was a top secret agent he will not be engaging in social conversation with a stranger about his deeds as an agent and neither would be divulging so easily his secret status.

Perhaps he does work for the homeland security but at a very low level.


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 07:03 PM by DocMoreau
The 'See ID' on the back of the credit card makes this feel a bit weird.

He created a situation that enabled him to show you those IDs. He could have paid cash. He could have shown you a driver's license, which is what "he should have done".

In fact, SEE ID is "not legal" per se.
usa.visa.com...
If the card has a “See ID” in place of a signature…



Request a signature. Ask the cardholder to sign the card and provide current government identification, such as a driver's license or passport (if local law permits).
Check the signature. Be sure that the signature on the card matches the one on the transaction receipt and the additional identification.
If the signatures appear reasonably the same and the authorization request is approved, go ahead and complete the transaction.


I have a gut feeling that you were a victim of some sort of fraud or social engineering. You felt compelled to give a ton of information because he was so casual with his clearances, past experiences and such.

Social_engineering_(security)

Perhaps he was really with Homeland Security, or maybe he was using a stolen credit card. But something about the guy, and the experience screams at me. I am just not sure what it is....


[edit on 21/11/2008 by DocMoreau]


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 07:15 PM by Supes
Originally posted by DocMoreau
The 'See ID' on the back of the credit card makes this feel a bit weird.

He created a situation that enabled him to show you those IDs. He could have paid cash. He could have shown you a driver's license, which is what "he should have done".

In fact, SEE ID is "not legal" per se.
usa.visa.com...
If the card has a “See ID” in place of a signature…



Request a signature. Ask the cardholder to sign the card and provide current government identification, such as a driver's license or passport (if local law permits).
Check the signature. Be sure that the signature on the card matches the one on the transaction receipt and the additional identification.
If the signatures appear reasonably the same and the authorization request is approved, go ahead and complete the transaction.


I have a gut feeling that you were a victim of some sort of fraud or social engineering. You felt compelled to give a ton of information because he was so casual with his clearances, past experiences and such.

Social_engineering_(security)

Perhaps he was really with Homeland Security, or maybe he was using a stolen credit card. But something about the guy, and the experience screams at me. I am just not sure what it is....


[edit on 21/11/2008 by DocMoreau]


Ever work retail? I not only see that every day, but I do it myself. As for the guy showing his federal I.D. I'm guessing he was looking for a discount.

As far as me being a victim...HUH?? I didn't tell him anything except that I carry a gun. Oh crap I just told ATS!!! This must be some social engineering at work

I didn't even tell him my name, so not sure how you read all that from my recounting.

Here's a thought, he was as paranoid as everyone on this board and he was only saying what everyone else is saying. I just thought it was odd hearing it from someone in his position.


reply posted on 21-11-2008 @ 07:33 PM by manoffewwords
I feel I need to make a comment here, although it does not directly relate to the OP.

Time and again on these boards I have heard talk of the Military being used against the citizenry (sp?). Although, I am not discounting any theory on here, as I don't know exactly what I think. I do think I should clarify some things regarding this.

Riviera

..not all military men are heartless or will follow their commands if they believe it's against their morals and hell against their own people. As well, not all the Top Brass would fall in line, people as evil as we are, we are also human and that brings a lot of empathy along with it.


I agree.

Now I can't speak for the American military, but I can speak for the Canadian Forces. Not only would many of the scenarios discussed on ATS go against a persons morals, they would be considered illegal for a soldier to carry out such orders.

The Canadian Forces are bound by the "Code of Ethics". Which states among other things, that soldiers are not bound to follow an illegal order, i.e. killing non-combatants (civilians), in fact to follow an illegal order makes you guilty of the crime, regardless if a superior officer ordered it. Even if citizens were rioting, I can not see a situation were deadly force could be justified. Even in Afghanistan we are bound by Rules of Engagement. Which state the procedures for Escalation of Force. First off, we can not shoot an unarmed person, even if we know they are Taliban/Al-queda. The only time we can immediately return fire is if our lifes are directly threatened. So a rioting civilian running at us with, maybe a golf club, is not life threatening. Secondly there is another rule called "Proportional Force", meaning if someone is hurling rocks at me, I do not hurl Grenades back. You use only the neccesary force to end the situation.

In other words, rioting citizens, would probably not represent a life threatening scenario, a dangerous one no doubt, but life threatening?

Ultimately, I just don't see soldiers complying with any order to delibrately end civilian lives, especially their own countrymen. I am sure that their would be a few, but these are just psychos, who would be happy to kill for any reason, military or not.

Just my 2 cents.

Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>    ^^TOP^^



I Was Arrested At Occupy Oakland Yesterday
  Posted 12 days ago with 98 member flags
Something funny about ATS...and the whole world for that matter
  Posted 17 days ago with 26 member flags
Black Triangle With Three Lights Just Flew Over Our House!
  Posted 8 days ago with 25 member flags
The Solar Flares Effects on Humans.
  Posted 16 days ago with 17 member flags