Ok, this is a perfect example of cherry picking verses with no context to slander someone. The issue is that most people are Biblically illiterate and
have no idea who the Midianites were, however to someone who knows the context you've basically given a quote along the lines of: "At Bastogne, the
Americans killed 100,000 Germans". Context can totally change the meaning of a passage. I know it's alot of reading, but I'm going to ask everyone to
go back to chapter 22 of numbers and read from there.
It begins with the king of Moab observing the Israelites advancing from Egypt and they are stronger than his people so he wants to find a way to
destroy them. So he gathers up the priests of Moab and Balaam, a prophet of the Midianites, to curse the Israelites so that they could be destroyed.
YHWH speaks to Balaam in a dream and tells him not to accept the bribe and not to curse Israel. Balaam doesn't listen and gets on his donkey so that
he can go to the Israelites and curse them. YHWH puts an angel in his path that at the time could only be seen by the donkey. The donkey stops moving
and Balaam hits it three times, after which YHWH gives the donkey the power of speech and it says, "stop hitting me, I was trying to save your life"
(paraphrase, obviously) at which time Balaam sees the Angel who is holding a sword and repents of his actions. Balak, king of the Midianites, goes to
Balaam and presses the issue and orders Balaam to curse the Israelites. They go to three seperate locations and offer seven sacrifices after which
Balaam is incapable of doing anything other than bless the Israelites, because YHWH was with them. After they realize this, they come to the
conclusion that the only way to destroy the Israelites is to seperate them from YHWH. To do this they sent some Midianite women
infected with
plague to have sex with the Israelites and get them to sacrifice to idols. This plague killed tens of thousands of people. So, not only did they
do what can only be compared to forcing AIDS victims to have sex with people you don't like, they separated them from YHWH so they died in very
grievous sins. All of this was done so that the Israelites could be utterly destroyed.
Now concerning the ethics of the battle, the reason the women weren't spared is because they started the whole ordeal and likely had the plague, and
the virgins were not given away for wives because they were most likely prepubescent. Also, the Israelites did not destroy all of the Medianites,
based on the number of casualties and people involved. They only destroyed the sect of the Midianites directly involved along with Balaam.
If you actually read Numbers, you would have noticed the horrendous atrocity committed against the Israelites and how many times Balaam had the chance
to repent and turn back. Heck, YHWH talked to him, sent an angel, and even made his donkey say "don't do it, Balaam!". That's pretty damn generous and
he tried to destroy the Israelites anyway!
For more info on this refer to your Bible and an intelligent apologist:
christianthinktank.com...
edit on 24-2-2011 by kallisti36 because: (no reason given)
edit on 24-2-2011 by kallisti36 because: (no reason given)