My co-workers watched as a girl died, page 12
Pages: <<  9    10    11    12    13  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 96 times


reply posted on 18-10-2008 @ 04:49 PM by seamuszharper
reply to post by Shadoefax



I'm not sure it was mentioned elsewhere in this thread but one thing people need to know about CPR. Those of you who are certified to perform CPR should already know this:

Frequently ribs are broken with the pressure CPR places on the sternum. Some studies quote up to 30% of cardiac arrest victims have broken ribs as a result of CPR. This happens more frequently the older the victim since the cartilage is less compliant and the bones more easily crackable. But remember, it's better to have a cracked rib then be dead.

This and more info on CPR can be found here: Ask Questions about C.P.R.

My heart goes out to the original poster. Those coworkers that stood beside and just watched are IMHO not people at all. They should be ashamed of themselves for doing NOTHING.



reply posted on 18-10-2008 @ 04:58 PM by emmy
reply to post by seamuszharper



I'm not surprised ribs crack due to the sternum having to break in the first place to perform CPR correctly. I've never had to do it yet, but one of my friends on placements went to a care home for 3 weeks for retired RAF/Military personnel, and one his first day had to perform CPR. I felt so bad for him then, the poor old man passed away, not surprised mind, he was old.
I guess brittle bone has a part to play in old age too. See I do remember some stuff from training

Thanks for that fact though - to me it was just my blind guess, but to know it's fact makes it much easier for me to not have to worry about it if I were put in a CPR situation!


reply posted on 18-10-2008 @ 07:18 PM by TheOneEyedProphet
reply to post by seamuszharper



thats the thing, we are becoming so jaded, so empty, so naive, that we'd rather believe in some nonsense out of the tv.
its the younger generations the ones that seem to follow this train of thought, we used to rely on the younger generations to turn the old ways around, nowadays, I'm not so sure where are we heading, sometimes it seems, we are on a one way tunnel to something worse...



reply posted on 18-10-2008 @ 08:55 PM by Anonymous ATS
reply to post by Star kitten



upon reading this very sad tragedy i too feel very dissapointed at these so called humans watch a person die and have a dumb excuse of being sued
you to me are an angel for the care you have shown at the moment of need how are these people going to live with them self god only knows
sad sad sad ,god bless you.

zafer


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 12:17 AM by goathead
reply to post by Star kitten



Absolutely terrible and sad. Your co-workers should all be ashamed of themselves. They are cowards with NO integrity. Just like the lawyers they so fear.


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 12:56 AM by Badge01
reply to post by mmariebored

The following is my opinion as a member participating in this discussion.

Though anyone can sue, if there's a good Samaritan Law in effect in that area, and legal precedent to back it up and the courts are acting favorably it might have clout.

But consider - though this sounds callous - if a person has a heart attack and there is no one there, they may die. Undiagnosed weak hearts do exist.

The important thing to know -after the fact- analyzing as we are, is what the law is.

Giving 'emotional' advice doesn't help a lot (again after the fact dissection of the case). Some countries have a statute that there is a legal duty to aid and you are in breach if you do not do something.

The apparent or alleged fact was there was a defibrillator machine on premises and rained CPR in evidence. So we need to explain this VERY curious fact that flies in the face of logic

Maybe there was a history and someone had heartburn, thought they were having a cardiac event (they're sometimes similar) and the defibrillator was used and someone got injured and someone got sued.

Not trying to ake excuses. Just pondering.

As an ATS Staff Member, I will not moderate in threads such as this where I have participated as a member.







[edit on 19/10/2008 by Badge01]


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 05:34 AM by Interestinggg
Originally posted by emmy
reply to
post by Interestinggg



Maybe it is a hox, maybe not. People die everyday, but do you see the papers reporting yet another death?! everyday someone dies but at the end of the day, not everyone will be in the media for it.

And to other people who have been wondering about the cause - perfectly healthy people can drop down dead - i don't understand why some people can question it? Maybe my status is just right mind, always confused, as per

Did I say anything about the media?
The fact remains if a young healthy 27yo dropped dead of unexplained reasons they could not say it was a heart attack until the autopsy was completed.And there would indeed be a full autopsy.
And in cases like these it would take weeks minimum.
The OP is saying this happened only 3 days before, and had been told it was a heart attack at the scene?Didn't explain how she new it was a heart attack.
Paramedics are not qualified to give out causes of death for situations like this.
Then the OP comes back and lies because it forgot about this mess up.
And says they got the autopsy results from the girls parents?
Only 3 days later?
What a moron not only did it mess up the first lie, its cover up lie it messed up to.
Go and call the medical examiner and ask them.
They will tell you that to get autopsy results in 3 days for an unexplained death is impossible.
Think of Heath Ledge, Anna Nicole Smith????
Because they have to test everything before they can make a conclusion.
Even if they cut it open and see a huge heart blockage, or a huge ruptured aneurysm, they still have to test for everything else FIRST.
Im over trying to explain this to you people to stop you looking stupid.


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 01:15 PM by Anonymous ATS
reply to post by Star kitten



Appalling, I agree.

Sorry to strain at gnats and swallow camels, but "...I went over to see what was going on, and lying on the floor in the middle of them, was a 27 year old girl..."

I think any 27 year old female should be called a woman, not a girl. If it were a 27 year old man would you have said 'boy?'


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 02:27 PM by mmariebored
Originally posted by Badge01
reply to
post by mmariebored


The apparent or alleged fact was there was a defibrillator machine on premises and rained CPR in evidence. So we need to explain this VERY curious fact that flies in the face of logic
Maybe there was a history and someone had heartburn, thought they were having a cardiac event (they're sometimes similar) and the defibrillator was used and someone got injured and someone got sued.
Not trying to ake excuses. Just pondering.

That's exactly why they need to go to court, to explain themselves.
The ones standing around may very well have a "good excuse" for doing so and, if not given the chance to bring that understanding to the table, may find themselves being a target for abuse from the victim's family.


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 02:31 PM by mmariebored
reply to post by badmedia


It's not like they can bring them to court just to question them. Sometimes, if people aren't forced to answer questions, they won't, they'll slam the door on the questioner's face. Court is a good thing, in most cases.


reply posted on 19-10-2008 @ 03:55 PM by da pickles
reply to post by Star kitten


makes me sick to think people will stand around watching others die. true it could be shock or more probably a morbid fascination. all people react differently to scenarios but for lots of them to onlook and not help is proof of the society you live in . talk is cheap ,life is cheaper . no doubt all those seeking councilling are either trying to deal with the fact that someone died in front of them [how innapropriate]or that they failed to help. if your a trained first aider / medic/ rescue you should be prepared to use your skills before volenteering to do the course for a break from the office . as for the parents suing i hate the whole litigation culture, but if it helps them grieve and makes people think twice before ignoring someone in peril then fairplay. i volenteer for an emergency service and its scary to think eveytime we do a first aid course
we are reminded we have a large team of lawyers behind the institute
Pages: <<  9    10    11    12    13  >>    ^^TOP^^



Did Carl Sagan know something?
  Posted 18 days ago with 276 member flags
Earthly coincidences...or not.
  Posted 14 days ago with 122 member flags
Was this the real reason why Megaupload was closed down?
  Posted 19 days ago with 96 member flags
The Mysterious Death of Marilyn Monroe
  Posted 16 days ago with 85 member flags
Denver Airport Allows Camera Crew in Underground Facility
  Posted 16 days ago with 83 member flags