ATS and Robbie Williams UFO Investigation: Round Two of Gilliand Videos, page 9

Originally posted by JohnnyAnonymous
When after first hearing the sounds at Gillilands, the first thing I did was to search for perhaps electrical wiring or some type of RF signal in that particular area of the field.

I have been thinking about your search for electrical utility lines and usually everything is above ground stretched across towers or poles. Sometimes a complex of houses or apartments bury all the U/T lines but either way this can be confirmed by locating any telephone poles or an under ground vault on the access road. From here the service line should go straight to the meter on the house. I did a quick search on wiki-

Electricity is usually transmitted over long distance through overhead power transmission lines. Underground power transmission is used only in densely populated areas because of its high cost of installation and maintenance, and because the high reactive power produces large charging currents and difficulties in voltage management.

Source-Wiki. There is also a Power Grid Map.

Even if there was some electro-magnetic disturbance from any power cables I don't think it would make that kind of noise, maybe a blank spot on the tape like you said earlier. As for microwaves and radio waves how could they become audible sound simply by recording them?

I have a couple questions about the camera equipment used. Your Sony camcorder was the only analog device there, does that include the Paranormal Sate crews equipment? If this camcorder was the only thing that picked up the daytime phenomena then I would think that either the cam itself is somehow creating all the phenomena or it has to do with the nature of analog recording. The former you almost completely ruled out, I think all that is left is to use more then one analog cam at the same time to see if they all pick up the sounds. If this has to do with how analog records information waves then I have a lot more questions. Your Sony cam makes it possible to see IR images because of it's lens, can it also make RF or inaudible sound audible? Is there even more information recorded on the tape then we have yet to perceive?

The audible frequency of sound is between 20 Hz and 20,000 Hz, this means that if we can hear this sound on the tape it must be within this range. As to the reason why it was not heard at the ranch is a good question. How good is your hearing? I have been intrigued by the radio signals from Jupiter and have learned that a lot of these share the same frequency as audible sound and some do not such as Jovian whistlers (produced by lightning). I have a very vague understanding of how these signals are created but I think they are some kind of electrical/plasma interference waves. Earth produces it's own song and perhaps you have a recording of an isolated example.

Originally posted by Nohup
I mean, really, aside from the source not being anonymous , what makes these videos any better than your average YouTube clip of some random light in the sky?

Anyone can be skeptical about the source of information to the point of questioning our own existence. Do you exist or is your perception flawed? Read up on Rene Descartes if you find yourself doing this (I think, therefore I am). I believe the difference here is in the credibility of the witnesses and our ability to interact with them, which makes it totally different but that's just my opinion.

Add: Here is a link to the University of Iowa for information on Space Audio.

[edit on 10/7/2008 by Devino]