Who wrote Palin speech? the former Bush speechwriter , page 1

privacy

Pages: << 1 2 3 >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 6 times

Topic started on 4-9-2008 @ 08:19 AM by marg6043

Perhaps we should have him for VP because originality was not Ms. Palin best attribute after all.

It was comforting to learn that Sarah Palin has entrusted her first make-or-break speech to my friend Matthew Scully, the former Bush speechwriter (maybe he can slip in a line vowing to take on the factory farms!) What are the key goals for the Palin address tonight?

blog.beliefnet.com...

What a joke.

[edit on 4-9-2008 by marg6043]

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:37 AM by RRconservative

OK you know who wrote Palin's speech. But can you tell me who wrote Obama's acceptance speech, or Joe Biden's?

Here's a hint. They didn't do it themselves.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:46 AM by dbates

So if you get the right guy to help you write a speech, you'll automatically be applauded by millions and cheered as being brilliant? I don't think so. Words are just ink on paper until someone brings them to life. That my friend takes quite a bit of natural talent and skill.

Do you think George Bush could have given that speech so well? I don't think so. She's gifted.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:50 AM by Benevolent Heretic

Of course she didn't write it. She read it real good, though!

She IS gifted! She did a great job! She's exciting and unifying for the party, something they sorely needed. No doubt about that.

She gives a good speech. I don't think that matters to the families living on the streets and out of jobs.

She's going to be great for the McCain/Bush campaign. She'll take her charm and good looks and lilting laughter (

) and go in there and do whatever the party tells her to do. She'll be a wonderful little puppet.

Originally posted by RRconservative
They didn't do it themselves.

Who did? You got a link?

[edit on 4-9-2008 by Benevolent Heretic]

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:54 AM by dbates

I believe that would be Jon Favreau.

www.nytimes.com...

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:54 AM by marg6043

I feel that to take the credit for something that is no original is deceiveing and I think that at least any of our so call brillinat speakers that happen to be poltical candidates and gaining the admiration of their flock should at least be honest enough to give also credit for those that do all the job for them.

I applaud the brilliant work of Matthew Scully.

she just read good and look pretty.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:55 AM by jerico65

Originally posted by RRconservative
OK you know who wrote Palin's speech. But can you tell me who wrote Obama's acceptance speech, or Joe Biden's?

Here's a hint. They didn't do it themselves.

Well, it's easy to know that Biden didn't write his own speech; he's already known to plagiarize stuff!!!

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:57 AM by dbates

So that's it? Again, the rebuttal to her once again is on mundane side topics that have little to do with her. "Oooh look at her daughter's myspace page" and "Her husband had a DUI 20 years ago". Now it's "She used a speech writer so she's a fake."

If that's all the rebuke you can say about her, then I'd say you got nothing. Everyone uses speech writers. Even Obama. Is he a fraud then? What a silly concept.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 08:58 AM by marg6043

Arizona State's Matthew Scully, Sarah Palin's Speechwriter

More on the brilliant men.

He's a pro-God, pro-veggie kinda guy, just the sort of iconoclast you'd expect to be ghosting for the likes of Palin. (Though I wonder what he thinks of all the hunting rifles and animal skin rugs.)

blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com...

I guess he is just a regular guy good with words. He also have verious books wrtten.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:02 AM by jerico65

Originally posted by dbates
So that's it? Again, the rebuttal to her once again is on mundane side topics that have little to do with her. "Oooh look at her daughter's myspace page" and "Her husband had a DUI 20 years ago". Now it's "She used a speech writer so she's a fake."

If that's all the rebuke you can say about her, then I'd say you got nothing. Everyone uses speech writers. Even Obama. Is he a fraud then? What a silly concept.

They need to grasp at something. I'm surprised they aren't saying more about her husbands DUI, but then they know everyone would bring up Teddy Kennedy!

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:03 AM by gottago

Probably the last US president to write his own speeches was Lincoln, and he didn't do such a bad job at it. JFK, whose speeches were often magnificent, used Theodore Sorenson from Harvard. Ronnie, the "great Communicator," used Peggy Noonan.

They all use speech writers. This is nothing to critique; it is SOP for any politician whose words will actually be listened to beyond a town council.

Believe me, you should be thankful they do; can you imagine what it'd be like to listen to a speech actually written by Bush I or II?

[typos]

[edit on 4-9-2008 by gottago]

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:03 AM by dbates

You liberals don't get it do you? You'll spend now till November talking about everything from what kind of shoes she wears, if her hair looks better up or down, or how may boyfriends her daughter has kissed.

If you can't talk about the substance of her speech, the platform and ideas of the McCain/Palin ticket, then you're sunk. They won't stop slamming Obama while your busy worrying about her latest color of lipstick.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:04 AM by jsobecky

Originally posted by marg6043
I feel that to take the credit for something that is no original is deceiveing and I think that at least any of our so call brillinat speakers that happen to be poltical candidates and gaining the admiration of their flock should at least be honest enough to give also credit for those that do all the job for them.

I applaud the brilliant work of Matthew Scully. she just read good and look pretty.

Where did she take credit for the speech, marg?

I think you're confusing her with Joe "The Plagiarist" Biden.

Scully is a gifted writer. But the delivery is the key.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:07 AM by theblunttruth

Why is it that all the democrats have right now is "vote for McCain, get Bush", is it beyond comprehension that people are different or is it more the point that they have resorted because they cant win on substance and argument?

What seperates a good speech from a great speech isn't so much the content but the delivery and conviction. Words are often empty, but Sarah Palin, in my opinion sounded a hell of a lot more genuine than Biden!

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:09 AM by Jadette

EVERY time I hear a comment about how 'pretty' she is, it's like someone hits me in the gut. Particularly when, it seems to be one of the foremost comments in almost every thread about her.

If she were fat, ugly, or grey haired and 60, would people be backing her as strongly?

I am really afraid that they wouldn't.

And that scares me. If the US presidental election has boiled down to a 'who's the prettiest', then I think I'm ill.

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:21 AM by Benevolent Heretic

Originally posted by dbates
I believe that would be Jon Favreau.

That's what I thought. But I don't believe he WRITES Obama's speeches so much as edits them.

Favreau and Obama rapidly found a relatively direct way to work with each other. "What I do is to sit with him for half an hour," Favreau explains. "He talks and I type everything he says. I reshape it, I write. He writes, he reshapes it. That's how we get a finished product.

"It's a great way to write speeches. A lot of times, you write something, you hand it in, it gets hacked by advisers, it gets to the candidate and then it gets sent back to you. This is a much more intimate way to work."

Some speeches are much more the product of the candidate himself. Obama e-mailed Favreau his draft of his announcement speech in Springfield, Ill., at 4 a.m. on the morning of the campaign launch last February.

Source

reply posted on 4-9-2008 @ 09:27 AM by Benevolent Heretic