I did see this and maybe someone can help me understand. I get the timeline and that McCain screwed up (again), but what would be the lie? That he's
purposely using the awakening to "sell" the surge? Knowing full well it happened before the surge?
It's hard to tell whether or not he's lying or just feeble-minded. Either way... This whole focus on the surge
reeks of manipulation.
I personally have the opinion that the surge didn't do a damn thing, they're just spinning it to make it sound like that for McCain's benefit.
There's probably some deal between the governments where Iraqis would calm the violence if Bush promises to start talking about a "time horizon" to
GTFO. That way, we can claim the surge worked and walk away with our pride. It's all very suspicious how these claims that "The Surge Worked" just
started popping up in the past couple weeks along with Bush's willingness to talk about a "time horizon", not willing to say the words, "timeline
for withdrawal". What an idiot!
Troop Surge Timeline
The surge was more than a year ago! And was declared over in November. And just within the past couple weeks, I've heard McCain (and people
here) parroting "The surge worked! The surge worked"!
November 24, 2007: The troop surge in Iraq was effectively declared over when officials announced that 5,000 soldiers will this week begin
pulling out in response to declining violence.
...
November 28, 2007: Presidential candidate Joe Biden (D-DE) states his view on the troop surge, “This whole notion that the surge is working
is fantasy
I have this sneaking suspicion that we are being lied to yet again either about a behind-the-scenes deal between the governments or the level of
violence there to make it appear that things are better there. I suspect the former.
So whether McCain is lying or just feeble, something's fishy about this. I doubt CBS is complicit, but I could be wrong. They probably either didn't
think to check or just brushed it off as McCain being confused again.
This is another "Mission Accomplished" moment and shame on people for falling for it again.
[edit on 23-7-2008 by Benevolent Heretic]