The Definitive "Birth Certificate" Thread - Updated 8th August 2008

From the Terms and Conditions



It does not matter how you couch it, a thread about Obama's birth certificate is a thread about Obama's birth certificate. There are too many of them already, and more than one has been authored by the same person.

New ones in this forum will be closed. There's no need for any more.

[edit on 7/0708/08 by neformore]

[edit on 7/0708/08 by neformore]

This thread is now the "definitive" Obama Birth Certificate Thread. Please contribute any discuission about the subject below.

[edit on 7/0708/08 by neformore]

[edit on 8/0808/08 by neformore]

Got a favorite?
Maybe it could be retitled the OFFICIAL Obama Birth certificate thread.

That way, if we close others, we could direct them to the "Official".

Then later, people will begin to discuss actual issues...ok, so I'm dreaming.
What do you think?

I was thinking about that. I guess its a case of picking the largest and closing the rest.

So far they've been couched in "slightly different" terms but a birth certificate is a birth certificate is a birth certificate....

so does he have one or not! LOL i didnt want to go reading them all .. so summary anyone?

reply to post by Morrigan

---

Summary:

Obama's birth certificate is fake or altered.

no it's not

Yes it is, I have proof.

No it's not, I have proof.
.........................................

So, one thread is enough. It either is, or it isn't!

Obama?


Who's Obama?


Musta been sleeping..

Cheers

Mungo

reply to post by spacedoubt

---

oh well that clears things up then

See, now I feel bad Morrigan!

I am a moderator, I should be helpful, and provide guidance to our members.

Here's one.
photoshopped?

and another
African is not a race

Those should get you started. That, and a cup of coffee.


[edit on 7-7-2008 by spacedoubt]

reply to post by spacedoubt

---

How about two? One for "it is" and another one for "it isn't"...

Altervatively, we could index them all here, Majic(tm) style, close each one as we link it, and make this the definitive consolidated thread for all things Obama birth certificate wise.

I'm throwing this idea out for discussion. One thing is for certain, a new thread every couple of days/hours/when someone writes a blog entry/someone changes a spelling in a blog entry/someone thinks about maybe changing the spelling in a blog entry etc is not going to work.

Not to be a nudge or anything .. but what the heck.

I started the first one back on June 11th.

www.abovetopsecret.com...

Why not just tack all the others on to this one thread - where they all should have been discussing it to begin with?

reply to post by neformore

---

I'm all for it Nef.

I don't mind the debating, it's just that the forum was being inundated with the same accusation over and over. There wasn't even very much new information to add to the next thread, just a regurgitation. Some threads ended up being hijacked by the Certificate issue. I think some people may have felt that instead of invigorating a dying thread they'd start a new one out for the day to get the debate raging.

I just stopped reading them all together.

Indexing, or consolidating is fine by me, as long as the redundant influx is shut off.
After that if people still want to debate the validity of Obamas birth certificate then have at it.


- Lee

List of Birth Certificate Threads - will be updated.

Obama's Birth Certificate (Flyers Fan)

Obama's Birth Certificate, a now confirmed fake (Jetxnet)

Was Obama's Birth Certificate Photoshopped? (Jamie83)

Obama was born in Kenya, proof to be rolled out shortly (Clay2 baraka)

Barack Obama is technically ineligible to become US President (Jetxnet)

Obama Camp caught intentionally misleading us (Jamie83)

"African" is not a race, Obama has yet to..... (Jetxnet)

Obama's Birth Certificate Confirmed Valid! (Benevolent Heretic)

Obama Releases his Birth Certificate (Crontab)

Is Obamas campaign even considered constitutional? (crmanager)

Obama forged Maya Kassandra Soetoro's Certificate of Birth image as his own(Jetxnet)

[edit on 8/0808/08 by neformore]

[edit on 8/0808/08 by neformore]

Bumped on purpose, to bring this into the mainstream again.

More thoughts please.

reply to post by neformore

---

well. Here's my thought:

In reference to the validity of the CoB, “It’s a valid Hawaii state birth certificate,” spokesman Janice Okubo says its valid.

So.

I submit



Says all but the original should be deleted


and, instead of flagging the original with "OFFICIAL"

and instead of deleting it

Ms. Okubo gives us reason to [HOAX] it. A hawaiin state official says its legit. Until a hawaiian state official says its FAKE, then there's no reason to not use the [hoax] tag that gets used sometimes in other forums.





Its been proven legit by a woman who is in a position to make that call. So (IMO) until such time the unlikely event of something else comes along to disprove Ms. Okubo's claim - this is - by definition - a hoax.

[edit on 7/7/2008 by Andrew E. Wiggin]

[edit on 7/7/2008 by Andrew E. Wiggin]

Sorry, I missed that you were asking for thoughts.

I like Hellmutt's idea of "one for" and "one against" or something like that, but then the discussion is all the same inside both ("Yes it is"!, "No it isn't"!), so I think if it were up to me, I would "smush" them all together (under Flyers Fan's - since it was first) and toss any new ones that creep up - unless, of course something more valid than blog amateur's speculations shows up - Like "State Department fooled by KOS jpeg"!

I'm a hard ass, though.

[edit on 7-7-2008 by Benevolent Heretic]

One of each answer, so, I'm going to make the decision

I will be closing all of the threads listed above, and making this the "Official Thread".

After that any more "Certificate" threads that are opened will be closed and directed here, where all things Birthy, Certificatey, and such ilk will be discussed.

Actually, it was meant as a joke. I wasn't serious. How can it be a discussion if everyone agrees? And having two separate threads running along each other, one thread for and the other thread against, would be sort of... ridiculous.

reply to post by Andrew E. Wiggin

---

my thoughts are multiple people opening the same thread are infact the same person posing as different people.

you only need to read the writing to see it.
I say close all of them accept the one with the MOST replies.

but im a mere peasant!

no [hoax] tag huh

Well, time will tell on this one, maybe closer to election time when Obama drops the bombshell of his phsyical birth certificate, adn this is proven a hoax, ill be able to convince someone to apply the tag

Here's a cheers for that